Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
A question for you LEOs- How would you react?
Collapse
X
-
You can say nothing and be polite at the same time. If a cop is going to mess with you for politely exercising your rights you have bigger problems. If that does happen it's the exception and not the norm. Being a smartass is only going to make the situation worse.
The smartasses start answering questions with questions. I'm sure cops love that approach.
My favorite response is: "Am I legally required to answer that question officer?" Now you're going to ask the police for legal advice, as that same cop is detaining you? Brilliant.sigpicNRA Life MemberComment
-
Funny thing, here in Florida, we can't wait to show off what we are carrying to any LEO. They are the only ones that can appreciate a really awesome weapon.There have been several threads in the 2A section lately dealing with different interactions with LEO and their respective outcomes. One of the things that keeps coming up is that legally a citizen is not obligated to talk to the police at all and when asked if we have any weapons etc in the car we dont have to answer the question. I wanted to see how you guys would respond in the following situation.
LEO: Do you have any guns, knives, Etc. in the car?
Citizen: As far as I know there is nothing illegal in my vehicle.
LEO: Where are you coming from today?
Citizen: With all due respect Officer that is my private business.
At this point in the exchange what is going through you mind? What is the thought process? Where would you go from here? I would assume the Citizen is going to get a ticket for what ever the stop was for but are you going to take an even harder look at him? Try to find PC for a search?
I am really curious about this as there has been MUCH discussion on this topic. I wanted to get the Officers prospective.
Thanks.
-LG
I routinely travel with a Carbon-15 with a fully loaded 30 round mag. A Glock 22 with a 17 round mag and something I call the "Zombie Killer" all within easy reach but not out in the open.
I would get out and let the LEO know what I have if they ask and tell them where they were.Comment
-
Then the LEO has the authority to do a loaded check on the spot which you can not, by law, refuse. That takes the issue completely out of the realm of a search requiring probable cause. Once the LEO has the authority to enter your vehicle to do the check, anything that is in plain sight falls into his purview. If he sees something else that perhaps is not legal, you are hosed.
This is why if your gun is properly stowed in your vehicle, and you don't want the LEO nosing through your car, you don't tell him you are transporting firearms.
-- Rifle, Pistol, Shotgun
Not a lawyer, just a former LEO proud to have served.
Americans have the right and advantage of being armed - unlike the citizens of other countries whose governments are afraid to trust the people with arms. -- James MadisonComment
-
I haven't even seen them and I appreciate them!!!!Funny thing, here in Florida, we can't wait to show off what we are carrying to any LEO. They are the only ones that can appreciate a really awesome weapon.
I routinely travel with a Carbon-15 with a fully loaded 30 round mag. A Glock 22 with a 17 round mag and something I call the "Zombie Killer" all within easy reach but not out in the open.
I would get out and let the LEO know what I have if they ask and tell them where they were.
Deputy Vu Nguyen #1427 EOW 12/19/07
Deputy Robert "Bob" French #1162 EOW 8/30/17
Deputy Mark Stasyuk #728 EOW 9/17/2018
Deputy Adam Gibson #729 EOW 1/18/2021Comment
-
Policeman are people, treat them like you would want to be treated and don't break the law...and stop being so friggin parinoid!
Even if you do break the law in a minor way if you handle it right they will just send you on your way after a lecture.
So what that means is don't come out snarling from your car and have someone in the trunk screaming to be let out and you reek like a cheech and chong movie character....or like scarface.I love America for the rights and freedoms we used to have.Comment
-
There's more truth to this post than most people realize.Policeman are people, treat them like you would want to be treated and don't break the law...and stop being so friggin parinoid!
Even if you do break the law in a minor way if you handle it right they will just send you on your way after a lecture.
So what that means is don't come out snarling from your car and have someone in the trunk screaming to be let out and you reek like a cheech and chong movie character....or like scarface.
LASD Retired
1978-2011
NRA Life Member
CRPA Life Member
NRA Rifle Instructor
NRA Shotgun Instructor
NRA Range Safety Officer
DOJ Certified InstructorComment
-
[QUOTE=bubbapug1;3579193]I would have thought he might have pulled you over for spelling and grammer....but thats just a wild ars guess.
LMAO !
LASD Retired
1978-2011
NRA Life Member
CRPA Life Member
NRA Rifle Instructor
NRA Shotgun Instructor
NRA Range Safety Officer
DOJ Certified InstructorComment
-
It seems to me, and this has been mentioned numerous times, that it is the attitude of the person being stopped. If you have nothing to hide, then don't be a dick. Be polite and answer the officers questions with "yes sir" and "no sir". If you disagree with what/why the officer has stopped/cited you, then politely take your lumps on the spot and wait for your day in court.
Now on the other hand, let's say you do have something illegal in your car. Depending on what it is, see the previous paragraph. Don't be stupid and tell on yourself, but if it is clear to you that the officer has/or is going to find your illegal "booty", then just fess up. The worst thing you can do is lie. If you tell the truth, you may get off with a warning or a reduced charge. Lying is a great way to get the book thrown at you.
Sorry for rant. Just my two cents.Comment
-
Here in Kern... as a probation officer... wear a uniform with a regular gunbelt, vest, mesh loadbearing vest.. drive a crownvic marked interceptor... which is different than alot of counties... we don't do "stops" normally... and if I am stopping you it is because I saw something Illegal and not a traffic violation...
so the situation is different ...
but when we contact someone in a house... it's usually because someone in the house is a felon... and another felon with prison tattoos says... sir I don't have to answer any questions? well it all depends don't it...
bottom line... it usually works better to be polite and cooperative... but I still might tell the officer I have nothing illegal in the car...cause some officers will do everything legally possible to lock you up... I have nothing against that per se... but for me, I find, in the long run, it works better to be reasonable with people while still holding them accountable for their actions.....the officer might still develop enough info. to search it and that is up to him/her...but polite has always worked for me... and I usually cut people slack if they earn it up front...arrrested a guy last week who was not coop. with his probation officer and moved without telling us and then didn't show up for his committment...naughty naughty... dude is still sittin' in the jail.. .with an ICE hold... cause it don't pay to mess with the PO and fail to cooperateLast edited by El Gato; 01-05-2010, 11:27 PM.Greebo, as a matter of feline pride, would attempt to fight or rape absolutely anything, up to and including a four-horse logging wagon. Ferocious dogs would whine and hide under the stairs when Greebo sauntered down the street. Foxes Kept away from the village. Wolves made a detour. Terry PratchettComment
-
Don't be stupid and tell on yourself, but if it is clear to you that the officer has/or is going to find your illegal "booty", then just fess up. The worst thing you can do is lie. If you tell the truth, you may get off with a warning or a reduced charge. Lying is a great way to get the book thrown at you.
Sorry for rant. Just my two cents.
couldn't agree more...
tell me where your dope is and I'll arrest you and see if we can get you treatment etc... maybe even write the report up that way... lie to me and I'll find any way I can to stick it to you... my favorite...asking a prisoner if he/she/whatever has any "dope" on him/her/whatever just prior to going into the jail... they of course say no sir... then I find it on him/her/it while in the jail and it is a felony charge where you cannot get out of jail as easily and you can't get "prop 36" treatment...very common to charge with bringing an illegal drug into jail... you are going to get caught cause we are going to do a thorough search.. so confess away... about 5 weeks ago a guy told me about the ecstasy pills hidden in his sock as I was parking in front of the receiving area... I treated him fairly and he was charged with a simple possession... and I didn't book him on it.. just his misd. warrants (they cite and release) based upon his up front and complete cooperation about the drugs and other things... the charges are referred to the DA and they will get him into court... dude is happy... and I still got what I needed...
having said that, be cautious some officers will stick you with whatever... however your cooperation with them is listed as a "mitigating circumstance" at sentencing... not that that is any comfort...
how does that apply to guns... I have had husbands/wives/whatever's of felony probationers tell me about the guns hidden in the house and how they belong to the non-felon... we work with them to get things secured and in compliance instead of just arresting the felon...on one occasion I had a felon tell me he had a gun and asking what he should do... I referred him to the local gun shop where he sold it within an hour and brought me the receipt... cooperation and asking for help can go a long way...Last edited by El Gato; 01-05-2010, 11:35 PM.Greebo, as a matter of feline pride, would attempt to fight or rape absolutely anything, up to and including a four-horse logging wagon. Ferocious dogs would whine and hide under the stairs when Greebo sauntered down the street. Foxes Kept away from the village. Wolves made a detour. Terry PratchettComment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,934
Posts: 25,177,602
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,392
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 39148 users online. 58 members and 39090 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment