Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Question on Complying

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ugimports
    Vendor/Retailer
    • Jun 2009
    • 6251

    Question on Complying

    This thread: https://www.calguns.net/calgunforum/...0&postcount=13

    Reminded me of something from my childhood.....

    Hypothetically if this scenario happened, what should the person do?

    Scenario:
    Subject gets pulled over
    Multiple police cars have responded
    Ghetto bird overhead

    Commands Yelled from responding Officer(s) or over PA system
    a) Shut off engine (easy enough)
    b) Put your hands up (ok easy enough)
    c) Keep your hands up and Get out of the vehicle

    How is the subject supposed to get out of the vehicle once they've complied with B and not being able to communicate to the officers who likely had firearms drawn?

    For the sake of this scenario the subject(s) were not told to roll down the window and the officers are some distance behind the vehicle.
    UG Imports - Fremont, CA FFL - Transfers, New Gun Sales
    Closure Schedule: http://ugimports.com/closed
    web​ / email / vendor forum

    I AM THE MAJORITY!!!

    Amazon Links Posted May be Paid Links
  • #2
    Spyder
    CGN Contributor
    • Mar 2008
    • 17371

    If their hands are already out the window? Same way one would open the door if they were on the outside of the vehicle, I suppose. Most doors have operable handles on the outside too, that are easily reachable by the vast majority of people, from the inside. At least, that's what I would do.

    Comment

    • #3
      ugimports
      Vendor/Retailer
      • Jun 2009
      • 6251

      Originally posted by Spyder
      If their hands are already out the window? Same way one would open the door if they were on the outside of the vehicle, I suppose. Most doors have operable handles on the outside too, that are easily reachable by the vast majority of people, from the inside. At least, that's what I would do.
      Windows are closed
      Hands touching roof from inside the car, in this context assume minivan
      Being told to exit the driver door
      3 subjects, driver, front passenger, and rear middle seat
      UG Imports - Fremont, CA FFL - Transfers, New Gun Sales
      Closure Schedule: http://ugimports.com/closed
      web​ / email / vendor forum

      I AM THE MAJORITY!!!

      Amazon Links Posted May be Paid Links

      Comment

      • #4
        71MUSTY
        Calguns Addict
        • Mar 2014
        • 7029

        Originally posted by ugimports
        Windows are closed
        Hands touching roof from inside the car, in this context assume minivan
        Being told to exit the driver door
        3 subjects, driver, front passenger, and rear middle seat
        Be an operator. Open the door with your feet.
        Only slaves don't need guns

        Originally posted by epilepticninja
        Americans vs. Democrats
        We stand for the Anthem, we kneel for the cross


        We already have the only reasonable Gun Control we need, It's called the Second Amendment and it's the government it controls.


        What doesn't kill me, better run

        Comment

        • #5
          mixicus
          Senior Member
          • Jun 2009
          • 624

          I've never had an issue being able to be heard by occupants of a vehicle at a felony stop including with freeway traffic and windows rolled up on the suspect vehicle. The PD units have PA's. They don't always comply or may start pumping up the tunes but then there are alternative tactics and time.

          As far as what to do, do what the officer is telling you to do at that time. Giving you a generic procedure what not be advisable as different agencies have different ways of doing things.

          Comment

          • #6
            ugimports
            Vendor/Retailer
            • Jun 2009
            • 6251

            Originally posted by mixicus
            I've never had an issue being able to be heard by occupants of a vehicle at a felony stop including with freeway traffic and windows rolled up on the suspect vehicle. The PD units have PA's. They don't always comply or may start pumping up the tunes but then there are alternative tactics and time.

            As far as what to do, do what the officer is telling you to do at that time. Giving you a generic procedure what not be advisable as different agencies have different ways of doing things.
            So an officer would not be worried when they are yelling:
            a) keep your hands up
            b) get out of the car

            when b) causes a) to no longer happen?

            The subjects could hear the officers fine, but would you be able to hear the subjects if you are standing 10-15ft behind the vehicle and the subjects windows are all rolled up and they are facing forward?

            In my story the subjects all made it out of the car and were safely arrested, but it was a little tense being yelled at to keep your hands up while trying to get out of the car without lowering your hands.

            This may have been about 30 years ago.. how do LEO treat a similar situation now (telling subject to keep hands up, but getting out of car requires a hand to disappear from view)? Would it be the same / similar?

            The crux of my question is why do/did LEO yell conflicting commands or is/was that a mistake or is it a "test" to see if the subject can figure out what the hell the officer wants them to do?
            UG Imports - Fremont, CA FFL - Transfers, New Gun Sales
            Closure Schedule: http://ugimports.com/closed
            web​ / email / vendor forum

            I AM THE MAJORITY!!!

            Amazon Links Posted May be Paid Links

            Comment

            • #7
              nick
              CGN/CGSSA Contributor
              CGN Contributor
              • Aug 2008
              • 19152

              The question here would be how to deal with contradicting orders from multiple officers. If only one officer is giving the orders, that's probably the guy to talk to and see what can be done. When multiple officers are yelling contradicting orders - what do you do?
              DiaHero Foundation - helping people manage diabetes. Sending diabetes supplies to Ukraine now, any help is appreciated.

              DDR AK furniture and Norinco M14 parts kit: https://www.calguns.net/calgunforum/....php?t=1756292
              sigpic

              Comment

              • #8
                mixicus
                Senior Member
                • Jun 2009
                • 624

                Originally posted by ugimports
                So an officer would not be worried when they are yelling:
                a) keep your hands up
                b) get out of the car

                when b) causes a) to no longer happen?

                The subjects could hear the officers fine, but would you be able to hear the subjects if you are standing 10-15ft behind the vehicle and the subjects windows are all rolled up and they are facing forward?

                In my story the subjects all made it out of the car and were safely arrested, but it was a little tense being yelled at to keep your hands up while trying to get out of the car without lowering your hands.

                This may have been about 30 years ago.. how do LEO treat a similar situation now (telling subject to keep hands up, but getting out of car requires a hand to disappear from view)? Would it be the same / similar?

                The crux of my question is why do/did LEO yell conflicting commands or is/was that a mistake or is it a "test" to see if the subject can figure out what the hell the officer wants them to do?
                Would I be able to hear the occupants...depends. Can't recall an issue that went unresolved or escalated unnecessarily.

                Once the suspect car is stopped and there are enough resources, everything SHOULD get slowed down. One officer gives commands in a simple clear language. This helps reduce confusion. Nobody is intentionally giving conflicting command to "test" the suspect. If there is something that prevents a suspect from completing a command as described, the officer makes adjustments in his commands and expectations. The driver dropping his right hand to unfasten his seatbelt for 2 seconds upon command after initially being told to put his hands up is reasonable. Just do what the officer says.

                An agencies standard procedure may not always be applicable. It's fluid. A guy in a wheelchair couldn't get out in the standard way...adjustments were made. The car came to a stop in a location that prevented the normal script...adjustments were made. Deaf driver...been there, figured it out. You get the idea.

                Comment

                • #9
                  mixicus
                  Senior Member
                  • Jun 2009
                  • 624

                  "When multiple officers are yelling contradicting orders - what do you do?"

                  One officer takes charge (there's preference for which one) and tells the others to shut up.

                  If you're asking from the suspect's position. Calmly ask for clarification while maintaining a non-threatening posture.
                  Last edited by mixicus; 04-10-2021, 10:25 PM.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    ugimports
                    Vendor/Retailer
                    • Jun 2009
                    • 6251

                    Makes sense... probably what happened in my hypothetical was what was said above regarding someone taking charge after the conflicting commands were thrown out.

                    Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk
                    UG Imports - Fremont, CA FFL - Transfers, New Gun Sales
                    Closure Schedule: http://ugimports.com/closed
                    web​ / email / vendor forum

                    I AM THE MAJORITY!!!

                    Amazon Links Posted May be Paid Links

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    UA-8071174-1