I have to disagree with you in this. Most level IV plates these days are stand alone and do not require the soft armor ICW the plates. While overseas I only wore my esapi plates in a JPC without soft plates and can personally say that they saved my life. But that’s another story for another time. Infantry dudes who were part of big army wore more armor but mostly for frag protection.
I do agree that a plate carrier over an external vest is problematic which is the reason for the post. IMO armor that meets NIJ ratings function in a similar matter which is why personal vests are allowed. The issues I see with The external carriers is the presentation. Some departments, especially ones in nicer nieghborhoods do not want to perceive militarization so they limit the external carrier style to the one that still looks like a uniform with Molle on it.
And unless the person is running steel armor (AR500) there should not be an issue with spalling. Level IV plates are made of ceramic due to weight and do a good job of catching the bullet as opposed to deflecting it. Although if running level III or III+ Steel plates, I can see how that would be an issue. I’m not saying it’s not possible, just less likely and IMO a compromise worth taking if going against a subject armed with a rifle, especially a trained subject.
I do agree that a plate carrier over an external vest is problematic which is the reason for the post. IMO armor that meets NIJ ratings function in a similar matter which is why personal vests are allowed. The issues I see with The external carriers is the presentation. Some departments, especially ones in nicer nieghborhoods do not want to perceive militarization so they limit the external carrier style to the one that still looks like a uniform with Molle on it.
And unless the person is running steel armor (AR500) there should not be an issue with spalling. Level IV plates are made of ceramic due to weight and do a good job of catching the bullet as opposed to deflecting it. Although if running level III or III+ Steel plates, I can see how that would be an issue. I’m not saying it’s not possible, just less likely and IMO a compromise worth taking if going against a subject armed with a rifle, especially a trained subject.

Comment