Peņa v. Cid (Handgun Roster) **CERT DENIED 6-15-2020**

[advocatusdiaboli]

Correct. The one handgun in the world specifically mentioned by the SCOTUS as coming under 2A protection is deemed unsafe and prohibited in CA.

Yep, it's that F'd up.

Technically, all handguns now unsafe are since none are manufactured to support micro-stamping. They are only grandfathered in with the micro-stamping exemption for a short time until they are modified enough to require retesting.

[wireless]

I believe you guys. I'm just curious if anyone knows the make and model.

[Maestro Pistolero]

Smith and Wesson Revolver Model 442

https://saf.org/?p=1063

[malfunction]

I believe it was a nine-shot revolver, that seems to be confirmed here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...071801212.html

He was not allowed to register his 1911 as it apparently qualified as a machine gun in DC

[canadagoose]

I thought that revolvers were exempt from the CA list. Is that not true?

[thayne]

I thought that revolvers were exempt from the CA list. Is that not true?

Not true

[taperxz]

I believe it was a nine-shot revolver, that seems to be confirmed here: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...071801212.html

He was not allowed to register his 1911 as it apparently qualified as a machine gun in DC

Thats the revolver he was registering when the press was there for his first registration. Not the gun that was involved in the court case.

[narcolepsy]

My understanding is that single action revolvers are exempt.

I thought that revolvers were exempt from the CA list. Is that not true?

[hornswaggled]

Microstamping requirement will help kill the roster. Not even Cuomo was dumb enough to let the "no semi-autos with >7 rounds" categorical ban part of the SAFE Act stand.

[IVC]

I thought that revolvers were exempt from the CA list. Is that not true?

Revolvers are exempt from LCI (loaded chamber indicator), magazine disconnect (obviously, no magazine) and microstamping. Also, *single action* revolvers over certain barrel/overall length are exempt.

That's probably what you had in mind.

[IVC]

My understanding is that single action revolvers are exempt.

Correct, except for barrel and overall length limits. SAE (single action exemption) is a counterpart of SSE (single shot exemption) for revolvers. I've transferred a few this way.

[IVC]

He was not allowed to register his 1911 as it apparently qualified as a machine gun in DC

See what happens when we don't pay attention to words?

Machined gun becomes machine gun... /jk

[REH]

June at the earliest seems to be the consensus and it seems that nothing definitive will be accomplished then, just four more yards in a cloud of dust near mid-field.

So this BS will continue into the future?

[advocatusdiaboli]

So this BS will continue into the future?

[REH]

I was not necessary looking for an opinion that would make me feel warm and fuzzy. I was only asking if this would be the final ruling, for or against. Not familiar with the court system, and it’s various levels.