In the Writ of Certiorari for Duncan v. Bonta at page 17-18 the 9th circuits en banc panels opinion , Judge VanDykes dissent is referenced. Stating: This is referenced several times in the writ of cert. Tracing that back to the en banc panel opinion, at page 155 (dissent starts at page 143), Judge VanDyke writes:
During the dissent I find reference to the following:
Which "50 Second Amendment challenges since Heller" are referred to? Can we name them all? Bonus: Which and how many Second Amendment challenges have been supportive of the right in the ninth circuit (and how long ago were those) in all of it's history?
In those few instances where a panel of our court
has granted Second Amendment relief, we have without fail
taken the case en banc to reverse that ruling.
has granted Second Amendment relief, we have without fail
taken the case en banc to reverse that ruling.
Mai v. United States
Jackson v. City & Cnty. of San Francisco
Pena v. Lindley
Fyock v. City of Sunnyvale
Jackson v. City & Cnty. of San Francisco
Pena v. Lindley
Fyock v. City of Sunnyvale
Which "50 Second Amendment challenges since Heller" are referred to? Can we name them all? Bonus: Which and how many Second Amendment challenges have been supportive of the right in the ninth circuit (and how long ago were those) in all of it's history?
Comment