Miller v. Bonta 9th Ckt "assault weapons": Held for Duncan result 1-26-24

[BAJ475]

May as well get ready for the appeal:

Various Footnotes in the Brief:

Sure enough. With respect to the testimony of experts, that generally applies to issues or questions of fact that may not be generally understood. With respect to questions or issues of law, that is for the court to decide and it only needs the attorneys to point to what they believe are applicable statutes and cases. The court is its own expert on the law.

[pratchett]

The State fell right into the trap and decided to rely on outright racism. The plaintiffs should win a trophy for their retort: "The State cannot rely on unconstitutional restrictions in order to justify another unconstitutional regulation."

[wchutt]

I started to feel kind of sorry for the suckers who were picked by the state to defend its position.



I got over it.

[jcwatchdog]

[ar15barrels]

May as well get ready for the appeal:

Various Footnotes in the Brief:

The 9th circuit's stay is already written.
They are just waiting for the correct date to put on it so they can file it.

[curtisfong]

The 9th circuit's stay is already written.
They are just waiting for the correct date to put on it so they can file it.

QFT. Utterly corrupt.

[BAJ475]

The 9th circuit's stay is already written.
They are just waiting for the correct date to put on it so they can file it.

Question. Who is the request for a stay directed to and who makes the decision? The entire court, the original 3 judge panel, any 3 judge panel or any judge the appellant chooses?

[BobB35]

So all they have is the Trap Gun analog? Put a fork in it this is done!

As far as the expert testimony. Col. Tucker just goes to show you there are dishonest gun grabbers even in the marines...yet he was an officer. This is from him and show a basic misunderstanding of firearms...so I guess all the LEO who carry AR15 are on the offense and are just planning on killing as many people as possible....the stupid is strong here.

he AR-15 is an offensive combat weapon no different in function or
purpose than an M4. In my opinion, both weapons are designed to kill as many
people as possible, as efficiently as possible, and serve no legitimate sporting or
self-defense purpose. Self-defense and military combat are different.

[mshill]

So all they have is the Trap Gun analog? Put a fork in it this is done!

As far as the expert testimony. Col. Tucker just goes to show you there are dishonest gun grabbers even in the marines...yet he was an officer. This is from him and show a basic misunderstanding of firearms...so I guess all the LEO who carry AR15 are on the offense and are just planning on killing as many people as possible....the stupid is strong here.

he AR-15 is an offensive combat weapon no different in function or
purpose than an M4. In my opinion, both weapons are designed to kill as many
people as possible, as efficiently as possible, and serve no legitimate sporting or
self-defense purpose. Self-defense and military combat are different.

This tool is no more an expert on firearms than I am, maybe less so, based on his comments.

[Drivedabizness]

This tool is no more an expert on firearms than I am, maybe less so, based on his comments.

Someone should ask Col Dipsh*t what my beloved Corps would do to him if he tried to deploy with an AR-15 and less than 30-rd magazines.

[Hint: You'd be in BIG trouble because - wait for it - AR15 is NOT military grade!!!]

[chris]

I started to feel kind of sorry for the suckers who were picked by the state to defend its position.



I got over it.

I will never feel sorry for this state nor anyone that was picked for this case.

[Sgt Raven]

Someone should ask Col Dipsh*t what my beloved Corps would do to him if he tried to deploy with an AR-15 and less than 30-rd magazines.

[Hint: You'd be in BIG trouble because - wait for it - AR15 is NOT military grade!!!]

"Military Grade", in other words, "made by the lowest bidder". Every AR I own is better quality than the M16A1 I was issued.

[eaglemike]

So all they have is the Trap Gun analog? Put a fork in it this is done!

As far as the expert testimony. Col. Tucker just goes to show you there are dishonest gun grabbers even in the marines...yet he was an officer. This is from him and show a basic misunderstanding of firearms...so I guess all the LEO who carry AR15 are on the offense and are just planning on killing as many people as possible....the stupid is strong here.

he AR-15 is an offensive combat weapon no different in function or
purpose than an M4. In my opinion, both weapons are designed to kill as many
people as possible, as efficiently as possible, and serve no legitimate sporting or
self-defense purpose. Self-defense and military combat are different.

If they are the same, then why have the full auto arms been banned for so long? Can't be owned in Ca at all. Judge B is a very smart guy, and I know he'll call them out on the facts. It goes to show how corrupt, and what liars, the left has become. I've met a former marine officer that is less than honest, and this "Col Tucker" meets the same criteria. Disappointing.

[BobB35]

If they are the same, then why have the full auto arms been banned for so long? Can't be owned in Ca at all. Judge B is a very smart guy, and I know he'll call them out on the facts. It goes to show how corrupt, and what liars, the left has become. I've met a former marine officer that is less than honest, and this "Col Tucker" meets the same criteria. Disappointing.

That's a really good question and to show that the progressive don't think past 1st order consequences...they have spend all this time arguing that AR-15 are the same as M16...so when Ar-15 are found legal...how are they going to argue against the ban on FA? They have painted themselves in a corner with thier illogic and had judges who were willing to support them. Not now. I could see the NFA or at a minimum the Hughes amendment attacked in the next few years after a few of these other cases get settled.

[bigstick61]

Someone should ask Col Dipsh*t what my beloved Corps would do to him if he tried to deploy with an AR-15 and less than 30-rd magazines.

[Hint: You'd be in BIG trouble because - wait for it - AR15 is NOT military grade!!!]

The AR-15 started out as select-fire and there are still weapons in U.S. military inventory with receivers marked AR-15. The AR-15 design had to be modified to be semi-auto only and weapons officially designated AR-15 exist in both select-fire and semi-auto only forms. M-16 and the like are just military designations for AR-15 variants adopted for military trials or service.