Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Muzzle velocity and temp powder

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • shooterfpga
    Veteran Member
    • Feb 2009
    • 2761

    Muzzle velocity and temp powder

    If i have 4fps of variance between 0* & 125* would i enter 4fps for my variance? How does that compute per degree of change?
    U.S. Army Combat Engineer

    Originally posted by Cactuscooler
    I have Paramilitary training
  • #2
    postal
    Banned
    • Mar 2008
    • 4566

    Is this what you actually measured? It would likely be quite a bit more even with varget- (a continuation of that thread I guess?)

    I dont recall, but I think from 35 deg to 110 deg I noticed a MV change of about 40-50.

    However, if you reload, and you shoot 10 rounds through a chronograph, your ES (extreme spread) from slowest to fasted will all depend on your anal retentiveness... My ES is in the mid 20's FPS which is fine for most practical shooters though BR guys would scoff unless they hit single digits.

    So- Consider that- your ES on the same day, same ammo has a ES of 25+ FPS... And you want to learn how to plot a 4 fps difference? Even BR guys dont get an ES of 4 fps with 10 rounds unless Lynn Jr tells me I'm wrong.

    Simple approach is to have 3 charts (if you normally shoot at the same location) 1 for for cold weather, 1 for moderate and one for hot weather. If you have an "in between" weather day- look at the 2 charts and split the middle.

    Once again, your true issue is the Density Altitude. And a Kestrel and shooter app will cover those- and you can can also plug in your expected MV correction from temp conditions.

    Comment

    • #3
      shooterfpga
      Veteran Member
      • Feb 2009
      • 2761

      Sorry dinner time. Short answer is definately not 4fps. Im seeing 5.45fps difference per every 1*.

      When dinner is over ill revisit. I like your explaination.
      U.S. Army Combat Engineer

      Originally posted by Cactuscooler
      I have Paramilitary training

      Comment

      • #4
        Rbutler
        Senior Member
        • Jul 2009
        • 675

        personally 4fps gets chalked up as a wash. In perspective, put into your calculator your velocity and right down your drop at 100 yards and at the max range of your firearm, do the same with the velocity +4fps, i highly doubt you can shoot the different.

        example my 308
        my standard load

        @1k has a drop of 294.5
        @1500 - 943.8

        +4fps
        @1k - 293.6
        @1500 940.6

        so 1 inch at 1k your talking 1/10 of 1 MOA. if you're that accurate kudos!
        primer, powder, projecile, press, load, fire repeat!

        Comment

        • #5
          shooterfpga
          Veteran Member
          • Feb 2009
          • 2761

          I think all of this extended thinking is hurting my brain and making my formula muddied. I think i need to log some more data and go back to a traditional chart like suggested above before i revisit trying to adjust it automatically instead of manually.
          U.S. Army Combat Engineer

          Originally posted by Cactuscooler
          I have Paramilitary training

          Comment

          • #6
            shooterfpga
            Veteran Member
            • Feb 2009
            • 2761

            My es is the same 20-25fps difference but i only use the avg for figuring out anything.
            U.S. Army Combat Engineer

            Originally posted by Cactuscooler
            I have Paramilitary training

            Comment

            • #7
              postal
              Banned
              • Mar 2008
              • 4566

              Originally posted by shooterfpga
              My es is the same 20-25fps difference but i only use the avg for figuring out anything.
              What I've noticed winter to summer if you keep your ammo out of the sun which is important.... It makes a difference but not much for practical distances which is easy with cold moderate and high temp charts. If you shoot a big bore extended range like 1500+ is where you see it make a difference.

              To be honest I only run 1 chart for moderate weather... it's of such minor significance.

              Comment

              • #8
                shooterfpga
                Veteran Member
                • Feb 2009
                • 2761

                Originally posted by postal
                What I've noticed winter to summer if you keep your ammo out of the sun which is important.... It makes a difference but not much for practical distances which is easy with cold moderate and high temp charts. If you shoot a big bore extended range like 1500+ is where you see it make a difference.

                To be honest I only run 1 chart for moderate weather... it's of such minor significance.
                Maybe i should just do it how i normally do. Sounds like the extra charts, logs and math isnt worth it.
                U.S. Army Combat Engineer

                Originally posted by Cactuscooler
                I have Paramilitary training

                Comment

                • #9
                  kcstott
                  I need a LIFE!!
                  • Nov 2011
                  • 11796

                  So how are you measuring this 4fps difference??

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    postal
                    Banned
                    • Mar 2008
                    • 4566

                    Also, the chart you posted on the other thread shows 168 SMK... for longer distances, people either use the 175 SMK or the hornady 177 (very similar higher BC than the 168) or the VLD for longer range.. which personally I dont like the VLD since they want to be jammed into the lands... unloading a live round becomes problematic.... round sticks in rifling, brass pulls out.. dumping powder in your action and need a cleaning rod to knock out the bullet.... Seen it happen about 4 times.....

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      shooterfpga
                      Veteran Member
                      • Feb 2009
                      • 2761

                      I use both 168gr and 175gr. 168gr (600 under) 175gr (600 over) im just currently using 168gr right now. I had to temporarily stop using 175gr as they kept unseating as you experianced with vld. I also have a 6.5 creedmoor running 140gr amax.
                      U.S. Army Combat Engineer

                      Originally posted by Cactuscooler
                      I have Paramilitary training

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        shooterfpga
                        Veteran Member
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 2761

                        Its definately not fun trying to clean out all the powder from the chamber and then rod out the bullet.
                        U.S. Army Combat Engineer

                        Originally posted by Cactuscooler
                        I have Paramilitary training

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          kcstott
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Nov 2011
                          • 11796

                          Originally posted by postal
                          Also, the chart you posted on the other thread shows 168 SMK... for longer distances, people either use the 175 SMK or the hornady 177 (very similar higher BC than the 168) or the VLD for longer range.. which personally I dont like the VLD since they want to be jammed into the lands... unloading a live round becomes problematic.... round sticks in rifling, brass pulls out.. dumping powder in your action and need a cleaning rod to knock out the bullet.... Seen it happen about 4 times.....
                          I don't know who told you to have the bullets touching the lands but even if that's what the mfg said i wouldn't do it.

                          I always start .005 off the lands and start playing with it from there. I,ve had loads that wouldn't shoot worth a damn until i gave it 1/8" of free bore.
                          Last edited by kcstott; 01-20-2015, 8:20 AM.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            postal
                            Banned
                            • Mar 2008
                            • 4566

                            Originally posted by kcstott
                            I don't know who told you to have the bullets touching the lands but even if that's what the mfg said i wouldn't do it.

                            I always start .005 off the lands and start playing with it from there. I,ve had loads that wouldn't shoot worth a damn until i gave it 1/8" of free bore.
                            It all depends on the bullet you shoot.

                            It's very common that smk shoots well with a 25-30 thou jump.

                            It's very common the VLD doesnt shoot well until it's jammed into the lands.

                            I do not and never have shot VLD's but have seen others using them that jam the lands and had to unload.... and have seen them pull apart 4 times now.

                            Currently swapped my 308 for a 6.5 creed with hornady Amax 140 with a 15 thou jump.

                            VLD specifically is known to tighten up groups when jammed into the lands- no others I recall.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              kcstott
                              I need a LIFE!!
                              • Nov 2011
                              • 11796

                              Originally posted by postal
                              It all depends on the bullet you shoot.

                              It's very common that smk shoots well with a 25-30 thou jump.

                              It's very common the VLD doesnt shoot well until it's jammed into the lands.

                              I do not and never have shot VLD's but have seen others using them that jam the lands and had to unload.... and have seen them pull apart 4 times now.

                              Currently swapped my 308 for a 6.5 creed with hornady Amax 140 with a 15 thou jump.

                              VLD specifically is known to tighten up groups when jammed into the lands- no others I recall.

                              If thats true it sucks, as that severely limits your powder charge ability.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1