Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

buffer springs

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • scott fisher
    Junior Member
    • Jun 2013
    • 92

    buffer springs

    So I want to change from a mil spec tube to commercial tube. I noticed the length on the commercial is longer and with a magpul stock all the way out its a perfect length for me. Have this set up on my LR 308. So right now I'm using my carbine lower with a mil spec tube and it a little short. My question is when ordering a commercial tube can I use the same spring. The tube is longer. When looking on the midway site I don't see any springs that say commercial specific. It just says carbine spring, which I assume is for mil spec. So is there any difference between a carbine spring for mil spec and commercial tubes or do you just use the same spring.
  • #2
    Dutch Henry
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2012
    • 733

    Only two springs I've ever seen are Rifle and Carbine.

    Measured end to end: Carbine: 10-1/16" Minimum; 11-1/4" Maximum.
    Rifle: 11-3/4" Minimum; 13-1/2" Maximum.

    Comment

    • #3
      jglabe
      Member
      • Jan 2013
      • 415

      If you get a commercial tube you will need to get a commercial stock as well. If you want a longer stock get a VLTOR A5 tube. You will have to use a rifle spring, but can use any old milspec stock.

      Comment

      • #4
        Centaine
        Member
        • Aug 2013
        • 222

        Spring size remains the same, whether it is a commercial or milspec tube. no difference there.

        Comment

        • #5
          scott fisher
          Junior Member
          • Jun 2013
          • 92

          Thanks

          Comment

          • #6
            Centaine
            Member
            • Aug 2013
            • 222

            Originally posted by scott fisher
            Thanks
            No problem.

            The only real difference in spec between Mil-spec and Commercial spec buffer tubes is the outside diameter of the tube itself, with the commercial spec being slightly larger in diameter than the mil-spec. That's the only difference, everything else is the same in spec or close..

            Comment

            • #7
              socalgto
              Member
              • Feb 2012
              • 111

              While on this topic I have a question too. I am building my first ar and I was wondering if there is a certain buffer spring I could put in so I don't get that twangy spring sound. It is a psa 16 inch mid length upper. I also have a spikes heavy tungsten buffer for my rifle.

              Comment

              • #8
                sumdood
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2008
                • 1103

                ^^
                Same question.
                sigpic

                Comment

                • #9
                  jglabe
                  Member
                  • Jan 2013
                  • 415

                  Originally posted by socalgto
                  While on this topic I have a question too. I am building my first ar and I was wondering if there is a certain buffer spring I could put in so I don't get that twangy spring sound. It is a psa 16 inch mid length upper. I also have a spikes heavy tungsten buffer for my rifle.
                  I have built 2 rifles, so by no means am I an expert. Both of my rifles have the VLTOR A5 buffer tube, A5 buffer, and rifle spring. The A5 tube is longer than a carbine tube, and the A5 buffer is longer than a carbine buffer. On the inside of the A5 buffer there is a spring that is attached to the last weight in the buffer. The spring inside the buffer dampens that "twang" to the point where I don't even hear it. I have not tried any other buffer, so take that for what it's worth. I am sure that someone with more experience with the AR platform could give you other options to consider. Something to consider though.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    jameshenry
                    Member
                    • Jan 2011
                    • 327

                    I use good grease on my springs, it kind of dampens the noise. With good hearing protection you barely hear the spring noise. On the other hand when there is no spring noise you know the buffer is locked back and your mag is empty.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      kcstott
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Nov 2011
                      • 11796

                      Originally posted by jameshenry
                      I use good grease on my springs, it kind of dampens the noise. With good hearing protection you barely hear the spring noise. On the other hand when there is no spring noise you know the buffer is locked back and your mag is empty.

                      Thats how I knew I ran dry

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        DEF23
                        Member
                        • Aug 2010
                        • 381

                        Spring size remains the same, whether it is a commercial or milspec tube. no difference there.


                        Not entirely true, sir. Most of the blow-back pistol caliber AR's have longer recoil spring and buffer lengths from rifle caliber AR's.

                        And some springs are made intentionally longer for special purposes. (ie, I have a 2x recoil spring in my AR-45 for .45 Supers that I run with a 9.5oz. buffer that is actually within 1" of a rifle length recoil spring size.)

                        So, generally yes --- but not always.......

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Centaine
                          Member
                          • Aug 2013
                          • 222

                          Originally posted by DEF23
                          Spring size remains the same, whether it is a commercial or milspec tube. no difference there.


                          Not entirely true, sir. Most of the blow-back pistol caliber AR's have longer recoil spring and buffer lengths from rifle caliber AR's.

                          And some springs are made intentionally longer for special purposes. (ie, I have a 2x recoil spring in my AR-45 for .45 Supers that I run with a 9.5oz. buffer that is actually within 1" of a rifle length recoil spring size.)

                          So, generally yes --- but not always.......

                          Thanks for the correction, but I was referring to his specific application that he mentioned in his original post i.e. commerical spec vs milspec in carbine length, not psitol or rifle length. Im sure there are a gazzillion different spring lengths and sizes for various calibers out there but for 5.56/.308 generally speaking there is no difference between a "milspec" buffer spring and a "commercial" buffer spring. Forgot to also add that the back of the buffer tube on commercial spec buffer tubes are slanted and the milspec ones are not, if it matters..
                          Last edited by Centaine; 11-22-2013, 10:04 PM.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            DEF23
                            Member
                            • Aug 2010
                            • 381

                            Im sure there are a gazzillion different spring lengths and sizes for various calibers out there but for 5.56/.308 generally speaking there is no difference between a "milspec" buffer spring and a "commercial" buffer spring.

                            Again, generally true --- but not totally correct.

                            There is one set of spring specs. that people go by for .223 recoil springs (mil spec). But in reality there is a lot of variation amongst different manufacturers of the springs themselves.

                            I have 5 different brand new .223 recoil springs sitting in front of me right now, from 5 different manufacturers and each one of them is a totally different length and spring material.

                            The cheaper Tapco and Chinese made spring sets are usually a little soft and they are very rarely in-spec. The US made springs seem to be a little bit better made and premium recoil springs are exactly as their name implies.

                            That isn't counting the X-tra power springs and the lightweight springs from people like Wolff.

                            And yes, sir. These are all .223 and carbine length recoil springs that I am discussing.

                            That is why so many people keep the spring length/coil count chart lying around to double check what you have before installing it.

                            I am just saying that there IS some variation amongst .223 carbine length recoil springs.

                            I'll pass on your buffer tube comment, only to say --- Again, generally the buffer tube rear ends are different (slanted vs. flat) as you stated but again, not always sir !!!

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              XDshooter
                              Senior Member
                              • Apr 2007
                              • 902

                              You are detracting from this thread. The information you are posting here has no relevance to the OPs question or Centaine's response to the OP.

                              Centaine is correct in his statement.

                              Which ever spring the user decides on won't be chosen based on whether the buffer tube is milspec or commercial.


                              Originally posted by DEF23
                              Im sure there are a gazzillion different spring lengths and sizes for various calibers out there but for 5.56/.308 generally speaking there is no difference between a "milspec" buffer spring and a "commercial" buffer spring.

                              Again, generally true --- but not totally correct.

                              There is one set of spring specs. that people go by for .223 recoil springs (mil spec). But in reality there is a lot of variation amongst different manufacturers of the springs themselves.

                              I have 5 different brand new .223 recoil springs sitting in front of me right now, from 5 different manufacturers and each one of them is a totally different length and spring material.

                              The cheaper Tapco and Chinese made spring sets are usually a little soft and they are very rarely in-spec. The US made springs seem to be a little bit better made and premium recoil springs are exactly as their name implies.

                              That isn't counting the X-tra power springs and the lightweight springs from people like Wolff.

                              And yes, sir. These are all .223 and carbine length recoil springs that I am discussing.

                              That is why so many people keep the spring length/coil count chart lying around to double check what you have before installing it.

                              I am just saying that there IS some variation amongst .223 carbine length recoil springs.

                              I'll pass on your buffer tube comment, only to say --- Again, generally the buffer tube rear ends are different (slanted vs. flat) as you stated but again, not always sir !!!
                              Originally posted by E Pluribus Unum
                              I was on a ride-along, and the officer i was with saw a parked car with occupants. He was going up to ask them to move their car and as soon as he gets to the window the passenger says "I have meth under my seat."

                              I've never understood the self-confessors....

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1