H-Frame vs A-Frame HF Press?

[massguy]

I'm looking at picking up a press from Harbor Freight for AKM building.

I'm told the 12 Ton should be fine.
Is there a reason to choose the 12 Ton A-Frame version over the H-Frame version? What is the difference between having the A vs the H frame for a press?

Spec wise it looks like the A-Frame allows for smaller working distances (1-3/4" vs 3-1/4" minimum) - is this an advantage?

The H-Frame is on sale right now but I'll spend another $20 if the A is better, easier to use, or allows for added functionality.

H-Frame: http://www.harborfreight.com/12-ton-...ess-33497.html

A-Frame: http://www.harborfreight.com/12-ton-...ress-1667.html

[couch]

Can't really help much with picking one since I only have experience with the H-Frame, but there is a 25% off coupon right now for one item in the store.

http://www.harborfreight.com/20off-coupon912-aff-17547.html

[morepoop4u]

I have the H frame and it works great plus the extra clearance is helpful when using it on other things.

[massguy]

I have the H frame and it works great plus the extra clearance is helpful when using it on other things.

Do you have the 12 Ton H?
Is it shaky at all. I read some complaints there was a lot of play and one buyer said his had to be "shimmed" o tighten it up??

[baih777]

Do you have the 12 Ton H?
Is it shaky at all. I read some complaints there was a lot of play and one buyer said his had to be "shimmed" o tighten it up??

mine is real loose. i did shim it up. i just used 1inch flat steel. cut them at 4 or 5 inches. put a 90degree bend and use them to shim the adjustable cross brace.

[Gunsmith Dan]

The only difference, talking HF ones, is just how much space you have. If working in a small area get the A Frame but if you got the room to spare get the H Frame.

Actually they are not bad and pretty tight the problem is when you assemble them FIRST put it all together, DO NOT tighten any of the screws or bolts leave them loose, square it up and line up everything THEN TIGHTEN the screws taking care to use criss cross pattern (like with tires).


That alone solves most of the loose/misaligned issues.