Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Training with Difference institutions and different methods

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jerryballs
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2008
    • 738

    Training with Difference institutions and different methods

    I have an issue with training...I have trained extensively at frontsight and been trained by their methods. Whenever I train somewhere else they always suggest using Their method (stance, grip, etc..)rather than frontsight's method. For those experienced in training with different schools how do you cope with this? All these methods work, but I don't want to confuse my training..especially for muscle memory reasons...

    Thanks!
  • #2
    joelogic
    Calguns Addict
    • May 2008
    • 6597

    Every coach will tell you to do it differently even if only a slight degree, otherwise how could they justify their own school. Any good coach should be able to adapt to your training if your training works for you. Schools that preach there is only one true way to do something I avoid. In my exprience training with different schools/instructors is really just to find a new mindset/better tactic/different point of view than to have them reteach you everytime.

    But I see your point as I am sure many others do. One pet peeve of mine is when manipulating my pistol I use the caveman one hand over the top method but during matches I sling shot it to catch the unfired round in my hand ala "cool guy method". I really should just stick to caveman. YMMV but I believe people can practice two methods especially for holding your rifle. For matches I hold the forearm at the furthest forward point ala magpul but during a training class I hold halfway. People can say I just need to excerise my shoulder more but 8 hours of holding it ala magpul is hard since I am not a super swat specops operator guy.
    Micro/Mini Reflex Red Dot Sight Mount for the M1, M1a/M14 platform

    Comment

    • #3
      Matt P
      Veteran Member
      • Jun 2006
      • 3101

      If you are seeking out different schools for a different take on what training with firearm means to them, why wouldn't you want to try their take on technique?
      Isn't that why you are interested in trying a different school, to get a different take on technique?
      Why not discover all the concepts on techniques with a firearm, and then decide what you feel is best for you.
      Other then that, if you like Front Sights technique, then why try anything else?

      Jerry, many of those in instruction do not choose to instruct weaver, nor Front Sights grip method. We feel their is a better method or technique for stance, grip, or shooting a firearm.

      If you enjoy Front Sights technique, and do it properly and safely, then I do not think any other training outfit will have a problem with you using it.

      Oh, and extracting a unfired cartridge through your caveman technique. Be aware that Todd Jarrett suffered substantial injury when a loaded case dis-charged with the his hand cupping the chamber area.
      Most will discourage using that technique to catch a un-fired cartridge.
      Better to extract normally, and watch the cartridge fall to the ground. Then pick it up.
      Just my opinion. Be safe be well..
      Last edited by Matt P; 12-26-2010, 11:20 AM.
      My WTB of Anything Glock 1-2 Generation, Tupperware, Manuals or Parts. Press Me

      Comment

      • #4
        SuperSet
        Calguns Addict
        • Feb 2007
        • 9048

        If you're training with different outfits and trying different methods, you're doing the right thing. Technology changes so methods and tactics should follow. When you start on the training road, it can seem confusing but trust me, it gets better and easier to filter as you progress. You'll learn what works for you and discard the rest.

        Strictly IMO, look for those courses and instructors that have different influences to their teaching style and curriculum. Their program tends to be the most well-rounded and up-to-date. As an example, take a look at Kyle Defoor's latest blog where he talks about the influences on his shooting and you'll see they run the gamut.

        Comment

        • #5
          jerryballs
          Senior Member
          • Mar 2008
          • 738

          Originally posted by Matt P
          If you are seeking out different schools for a different take on what training with firearm means to them, why wouldn't you want to try their take on technique?
          Isn't that why you are interested in trying a different school, to get a different take on technique?
          Why not discover all the concepts on techniques with a firearm, and then decide what you feel is best for you.
          Other then that, if you like Front Sights technique, then why try anything else?

          Jerry, many of those in instruction do not choose to instruct weaver, nor Front Sights grip method. We feel their is a better method or technique for stance, grip, or shooting a firearm.

          If you enjoy Front Sights technique, and do it properly and safely, then I do not think any other training outfit will have a problem with you using it.

          Oh, and extracting a unfired cartridge through your caveman technique. Be aware that Todd Jarrett suffered substantial injury when a loaded case dis-charged with the his hand cupping the chamber area.
          Most will discourage using that technique to catch a un-fired cartridge.
          Better to extract normally, and watch the cartridge fall to the ground. Then pick it up.
          Just my opinion. Be safe be well..

          I Definately see your point. I do try and take away positives from every class I take. I have trained so much with FS and continue to train there I think that its good to try new stuff when Its offered locally.

          Thanks for your opinion.

          Comment

          • #6
            9mmepiphany
            Calguns Addict
            • Jul 2008
            • 8075

            I agree with the poster who have said, to try the different techniques...that is why you are attending the different schools.

            Schools will usually advocate for the technique that they think most advantages to the student for the student to have success during an exercise. If you have chosen that school because they had something useful to teach you, it would be a huge disservice to you to not try out what they are teaching.

            Techniques are always evolving. I still remember when my academy taught one handed shooting with the off-hand formed into a fist and covering your heart to deflect incoming bullets and that SA shooting was more accurate than DA shooting. I shot the Chapman stance for years, before converting to the Isosceles for it's faster rate of fire. I'll still teach the Weaver to students who have limited training time/dedication...because, even though less flexible, it is easier to teach
            ...because the journey is the worthier part...The Shepherd's Tale

            Comment

            • #7
              guns4life
              Veteran Member
              • Aug 2010
              • 4916

              The more tools in your toolbox, the better off you are.



              no homo.
              sigpic

              Comment

              • #8
                G-forceJunkie
                Calguns Addict
                • Jul 2010
                • 6530

                Do what works best for you, but to discover that, you need to give a honest try to several methods. Its always harder to do something thats new and foreign to you, but do it, it will only make you better and isn't that the whole point? I shot a particular way for many years, shots IDPA an IPSC and got pretty good, but then i hit a plateau. I had maxed out my potential of those particular methods and techniques. So I started looking for different ones. It was difficult, because I was going backwards in speed an accuracy doing things that were different and contrary to what i already had trained. But in the end, some of the methods allowed me to exceed where I was before. The whole point, is you are comfortable with the Front Site method because you have done that the most. But being comfortable does not mean that style will bring you up to your highest level of achievable abilitys. To sum it all up, try other things even when they feel odd or different, you may learn something.

                Comment

                • #9
                  9mmepiphany
                  Calguns Addict
                  • Jul 2008
                  • 8075

                  you really have to give new techniques a fair try...it won't cost you much to try something new for 3-5 days during a class. I will usually try something new out for a couple of months before even considering discarding it
                  ...because the journey is the worthier part...The Shepherd's Tale

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Omega13device
                    Senior Member
                    • Jan 2006
                    • 1943

                    It's important to try different methods, as others have pointed out.

                    More importantly, keep your ears and your mind open and be receptive as to the WHY of various methods. The fact that you have trained a lot on one method doesn't validate it as the best one for you. Be able to articulate a clear rationale for why you are doing something. Your instructor should also be able to clearly articulate the pros and cons of their method.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    UA-8071174-1