Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Overpressure question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    Fjold
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Oct 2005
    • 23096

    If you are too close to the lands then seating the bullets deeper will lower pressure. Roy Weatherby proved that with his proprietary cartridges. He stuffed more powder into bigger cases and then lengthened the throats on his rifle so that the long jump to the lands before the bullet meets the lands lowered the peak pressure of the cartridge.

    That's the same reason that the 5.56 can run hotter than the 223, the 5.56 has a long throat which lowers the peak pressure. The combustion chamber is larger because the bullet has a lot of room to move forward before it is forced into the rifling.

    The peak pressure isn't reached in the cartridge case. And the variations in the size of the pressure chamber due to the seting depth of of the bullet is minor. It takes very little pressure to push the bullet out of the case (a primer alone can do that). The maximum pressure of 50,000 - 60,000 PSI peaks after the bullet hits the rifling as it requires more pressure to engrave the bullet and force it down the barrel.
    Last edited by Fjold; 12-30-2012, 10:18 PM.
    Frank

    One rifle, one planet, Holland's 375




    Life Member NRA, CRPA and SAF

    Comment

    • #17
      skibuff
      Senior Member
      • Sep 2011
      • 617

      Are you loading from the Magazine or one at a time?
      If loading semi auto from a mag could the bullet be getting bumped deeper when chambering from the mag? (not enough crimp)

      Comment

      • #18
        bitethebullet
        Member
        • Oct 2012
        • 187

        Originally posted by FLIGHT762
        Gas guns run different than bolt guns. I've owned and reloaded for a Knight's SR-25 since 1993. I have to use medium burning powders and cannot run it as hot as a bolt gun, usually 3-2 grains less. I tried some CFE 223 recently and blew primers. It does not have an adjustable gas block.

        This rifle beats the brass. I've put in a Tubbs buffer spring and a CWS (Carrier Weight System) which has helped. With Federal Brass, I may get only 2 reloadings out of them. I get better results with Remington, Winchester and Hornady brass, but the brass still gets beaten.

        You may be experiencing the same thing with your rifle. Try dropping your powders charges a bit and try some different primers, it may help.
        Seems like the guns are pretty similar on how finicky they are to charge weight. What kind of receipe have you been using? I don't know how much further I can go under minimum charge weight with IMR4895? I am at 41gr (typical minimum) with a 2.80 COAL.

        I also tried 10 rounds with CFE223 that I use for the smaller rounds. I went a full 1.6gr under Hogdon's minimum fearing that it would produce similar results as the IMR4895 at minimum charge and it did the same thing as you stated...pierced a primer and some were cratered....

        Comment

        • #19
          FLIGHT762
          Veteran Member
          • Mar 2009
          • 3072

          A few of my loads I've shot recently.

          Loads with not too much trouble are:
          43.0 RE-15 W/ 168 A-MAX in R/P cases without much galling.
          40.0 AR-COMP W/ 168 A-MAX is pretty accurate.
          43.0 AR-COMP W/ 155 Nosler OTM
          42.0 Radway Green 4895 W/168 Nosler OTM
          43.0 XMR 4064 W/ 168 A MAX
          42.0 H-335 W/ Hornady 168 OTM

          Loads that stretched primer pockets:
          42.0 AR-COMP W/168 A MAX
          43.0 8208 XBR W/168 Hornady OTM
          42.0 8208 XBR W/ 178 A MAX
          46.0 CFE 223 W/175 Nosler OTM

          If I keep the loads down 2-3 grains less than I use in my bolt guns, the SR-25 shoots fairly well. This rifle has a tight match chamber. When It was new, it blew primers with Federal 168 GMM. It got a little better over time, but stills beats the brass with the GMM.

          Your load of 41.0 of IMR 4895 should not be too hot. Give the chamber a good scrubbing for caked up carbon. You can use a 50 cal. bronze brush for a chamber brush with a good carbon cutter.

          I seat my bullets to about 2.780"- 2.8" for reliable feeding from the magazine.

          You can look into the Tubbs Carrier Weight System, it's not too expensive, it might help. It has two weights. I use the heavy weight.



          It fits into the open hole in the rear of the carrier. I don't know if it will fit your DPMS, you can give them a call and ask. I'd figure out what you've got going on first.

          Comment

          • #20
            the86d
            Calguns Addict
            • Jul 2011
            • 9591

            I have seen brass from factory 5.56 with primers that almost flowed out into the entire primer pocket. I never saw this on my Federal, nor my PMC X-TAC, but range pick-ups I have. Even 27.2 grains of Varget with 62 grain projectiles don't seem to make the primer flow like that, if at all or I'd be backing off (I don't know if because I have a 20" barrel, or if that even makes a difference)...

            WC846 is what I was thinking about getting for my next powder purchase, and you helped me decide: Yes for sure!
            Last edited by the86d; 12-31-2012, 6:07 AM.

            Comment

            • #21
              bitethebullet
              Member
              • Oct 2012
              • 187

              Originally posted by FLIGHT762
              A few of my loads I've shot recently.

              Loads with not too much trouble are:
              43.0 RE-15 W/ 168 A-MAX in R/P cases without much galling.
              40.0 AR-COMP W/ 168 A-MAX is pretty accurate.
              43.0 AR-COMP W/ 155 Nosler OTM
              42.0 Radway Green 4895 W/168 Nosler OTM
              43.0 XMR 4064 W/ 168 A MAX
              42.0 H-335 W/ Hornady 168 OTM

              Loads that stretched primer pockets:
              42.0 AR-COMP W/168 A MAX
              43.0 8208 XBR W/168 Hornady OTM
              42.0 8208 XBR W/ 178 A MAX
              46.0 CFE 223 W/175 Nosler OTM

              If I keep the loads down 2-3 grains less than I use in my bolt guns, the SR-25 shoots fairly well. This rifle has a tight match chamber. When It was new, it blew primers with Federal 168 GMM. It got a little better over time, but stills beats the brass with the GMM.

              Your load of 41.0 of IMR 4895 should not be too hot. Give the chamber a good scrubbing for caked up carbon. You can use a 50 cal. bronze brush for a chamber brush with a good carbon cutter.

              I seat my bullets to about 2.780"- 2.8" for reliable feeding from the magazine.

              You can look into the Tubbs Carrier Weight System, it's not too expensive, it might help. It has two weights. I use the heavy weight.



              It fits into the open hole in the rear of the carrier. I don't know if it will fit your DPMS, you can give them a call and ask. I'd figure out what you've got going on first.

              I will look into the carrier weights....in the meantime, I will try lowering the charge weight and get some harder primers

              Comment

              • #22
                Ahhnother8
                Senior Member
                • Feb 2007
                • 1454

                Originally posted by bitethebullet
                I will look into the carrier weights....in the meantime, I will try lowering the charge weight and get some harder primers
                All large rifle primers are .027" cup thickness. Have not heard of any being of a harder or softer material, only larger or smaller in diameter.

                Primer piercing or more accurately, blanking, is commonly caused by too large of a firing pin hole in the bolt face. This will also cause cratering, even before excessive pressures are reached. Oh, and those "blanks" are somewhere in the rifle. They will stack up inside the bolt and eventually cause failure to fire and some can get down into the trigger area also.

                Rather than carrier weights, many of us in highpower fill the buffer with lead or lead shot. It will not help your problem, but it helps with brass longevity and felt recoil.

                Primer info - http://www.jamescalhoon.com/primers_and_pressure.php

                Comment

                • #23
                  FLIGHT762
                  Veteran Member
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 3072

                  Originally posted by Ahhnother8

                  Primer piercing or more accurately, blanking, is commonly caused by too large of a firing pin hole in the bolt face. This will also cause cratering, even before excessive pressures are reached.

                  All large rifle primers are .027" cup thickness. Have not heard of any being of a harder or softer material, only larger or smaller in diameter.
                  This is true. If you're getting "Blanking" (a round cookie cutter hole) the firing pin hole in the bolt may be too large. Usually, a firing pin hole greater than
                  .065" can cause blanking in .308 AR gas guns.

                  That can be checked in the O/P's bolt.

                  CCI does make a L/R and S/R Military spec primer cup for autoloaders a #34 and #41, which they call "Mil Spec sensitivity".


                  Wolf/Tula also makes a S/R primer that they say has a harder primer cup. I use them in my .223 gas gun loads.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  UA-8071174-1