Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

M193 Clone?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SixPointEight
    Veteran Member
    • May 2009
    • 3788

    M193 Clone?

    I see a lot of people working to clone Mk262 ammo, and some working on m855 clones, but not many people post about M193 clones. My rifle won't stabilize the 77gr bullet, and I feel that the 55gr does a better job than the 62gr at the ranges I'd ever be likely to see.

    From what I find online my goal should be about 3150FPS from a 16" barrel. Options for bullet are a Federal 55gr FMJ, Armscor 55gr FMJ, or Remington 55gr FMJ. I have a can of Varget, they list a max load velocity of 3384fps, which seems like a lot. Traditional knowledge says Varget is better when you get to heavier bullets than it is with light bullets. Is there a better powder to try than Varget? I hear H335 thrown around a lot, but it's listed as 3202fps max. I also have IMR 4895, and H4895, which are listed at 3203fps and 3315fps respectively.

    Looks like Varget and H4895 are my best options for trying to clone this. BL-C(2) and Ramshot TAC are other popular powders, and velocity is listed in the 3310 and 2920fps range respectively. Reloader15 isn't much talked about with 55gr but is listed at 3390fps, so it could be promising as well.

    I have Varget, H4895 and Re15 on hand. So...where do I start? With one of these, or are there already perfectly good recipes out there?
    Last edited by SixPointEight; 01-18-2011, 11:03 AM.
  • #2
    joelogic
    Calguns Addict
    • May 2008
    • 6597

    Are you trying to shoot 1k yards? Why push it so fast? The military uses velocity to kill instead of bullet weight. For us paper shooters just shoot what is most accurate out of your gun.
    Micro/Mini Reflex Red Dot Sight Mount for the M1, M1a/M14 platform

    Comment

    • #3
      rsrocket1
      Veteran Member
      • Feb 2010
      • 2774

      If you like reading, take a look at this article. It is copied and posted in a lot of places around the web.

      The army wanted 3300 fps so that the round could pierce a helmet at 500 yards. For that to work, nearly all rifle powders would generate too much pressure. You certainly don't need that and even with that load, your 16" AR will get only about 3000fps using a 5.56 NATO case, not a .223 case.

      The max recommended load for .223 and 55g bullet is 25.3g H335 which easily fits inside a .223 case. Hodgdon's website claims 3203fps with that. I use 25.0g H335 and get about 3010-3020 fps through my 20" AR with very good groups.

      I think 3150fps out of a 16" barrel is asking too much. Why do you need so much velocity? You should be looking for a load that gives you good precision (consistency), then adjust your sights so your impact points line up with your aim points. Maybe if you exclusively use 5.56 NATO cases, you'll be OK, but I wouldn't use .223 cases and try for those velocities with a 16" barrel.

      I think Hodgdon's velocities are listed using a 24" bbl. 27.5g in your 16" gun will get about 3090fps and you'll really be crunching the Varget into the cases with that charge. 24g of Varget got my .223 cases to the base of where I seat my 55g fmjbt without compression and it shot fairly well at about 2800fps. I preferred the H335 because it's less expensive and I found a very good accuracy node at 25g for my gun. I'm using the rest of my Varget for my .308 loads.

      Comment

      • #4
        SixPointEight
        Veteran Member
        • May 2009
        • 3788

        Even at 3200fps a 55gr bullet would be subsonic by 750yards. I'm not trying to shoot 1000, I'm not chasing accuracy. I have my .308 for that. This is a blaster, if I can be in the velocity range with 1-2MOA accuracy it will be more than okay.

        I want the velocity so I can closely match M193 ballistic data for practice purposes. As for your comment on Nato vs Commercial cases, there really aren't that different. With LC cases being a little thinner, I may be able to fit a tenth or two more powder. In most cases I don't think I'll be pushing 100% case fill(nor do I really want to be) though I know with Varget I would be.

        I know that nato velocity levels are quite high, and many people that attempt clone loads never quite reach them. I understand that, and am prepared to fall a bit short in order to err on the side of safety, but I would like to see 2900-3100fps, which I think is quite reasonable, considering with a middle-low charge, I was getting 2890fps with AA2230 and a 55gr before.

        Anyways, I will shoot M193 through my rifle and over a chrono first, in order to obtain my benchmark, but I have to wait for some warmer days, as many of the powders I'm seeing mentioned have enough temperature sensitivity that I should wait. Though it looks like H335 was chosen over BL-C(2) for reasons of temperature sensitivity.
        Last edited by SixPointEight; 01-18-2011, 10:44 AM.

        Comment

        • #5
          GeoffLinder
          Senior Member
          • Jul 2009
          • 2425

          A faster powder will be needed to get decent velocity in a short barrel. Varget or RL-15 are too slow IMHO for a 55gr in a short barrel. I would recommend AA2230 or WW748 to get full efficiency burn in a short barrel.

          I would start in the 24gr range with 2230 and in the 26gr range with 748. Keep COAL in the 2.235" to 2.245" range to keep pressure low.

          Getting supersonic performance from a 55gr past 600 yards will require a boat tail projectile. A flat base bullet just won't hold it's velocity past 350-400 yards compared to a boat tail bullet.

          Comment

          • #6
            SixPointEight
            Veteran Member
            • May 2009
            • 3788

            Not lookin for long range performance, mostly for use 25-300 yards, as close to m193 as i can get. only expecting 1-2moa performance with cheap bullets. trying really to clone the ammo but still reload it on the cheap

            Comment

            • #7
              GeoffLinder
              Senior Member
              • Jul 2009
              • 2425

              Try the Hornady 55gr FMJBT. They are available from Midway and several other suppliers for about $80-90/1000

              They will shoot one MOA or better if your rifle will shoot MOA AND you find a velocity your barrel likes. The other plus is they are a boat tail so they buck wind well to 300+ yards when you push them at 3100 or better and they will still be supersonic way downrange.

              Can't recommend them enuff for quality 55gr fodder. I use them exclusively for 55gr match grade ammo and have very successfully used them in practical competition at 300 yards plus in heavy wind. Sure the SMK69 and 77gr match bullets are better at distance, but these little bad boys are way good for the price :-)
              Last edited by GeoffLinder; 01-18-2011, 4:48 PM.

              Comment

              • #8
                SixPointEight
                Veteran Member
                • May 2009
                • 3788

                I tried 55gr spire points before. Though they had a flat base, I did not like the length of the round, the cannelure was set so far forward as to make my COL 2.200" when seated to the canelure, sacrificing quite a bit of case capacity.

                Not sure if the FMJBT is different, so I'll snag a few. The federal 55gr's are cheaper, and manufactured by LC, so it's likely the same bullet used in m193, where as the armscor bullet may or may not be. However the federal bullets are all out of stock. I'm going to pick up some Q3131A1(rumored to be a little light) and do my best to find true XM193 ammo, pull a couple and check them out, then shoot the rest and see how they do.
                Last edited by SixPointEight; 01-18-2011, 5:03 PM.

                Comment

                • #9
                  GeoffLinder
                  Senior Member
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 2425

                  The Armscor 55gr are just OK and IMO below average AR fodder. The Hornady FMJBT are well proven by many top competitive rifle shooters as the best bang for a buck in a 55gr out there. There may be a few other specific versions by other Mfgr's that fly as well, but so far myself and everyone I know has only gotten way above average results from the bulk Hornady version of this projectile.

                  As for cannelure, no need to pay any attention to it. You aren't really crimping anyway (are you!, if so stop, only a very light taper crimp is needed, if any at all) so just set OAL where you want it and let the cannelure fall where it may.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Twinspool
                    Member
                    • Nov 2007
                    • 279

                    I bought 10lbs of Ramshot X-Terminator on sale and it's the cat's *** through my RCBS powder meter and it shoots clean and accurate with 55grain pills. Just the ticket for sage rats. I save my Varget for the Berger 80 grainers.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      SixPointEight
                      Veteran Member
                      • May 2009
                      • 3788

                      Originally posted by Twinspool
                      I bought 10lbs of Ramshot X-Terminator on sale and it's the cat's *** through my RCBS powder meter and it shoots clean and accurate with 55grain pills. Just the ticket for sage rats. I save my Varget for the Berger 80 grainers.
                      Ramshot lists it a little faster that TAC. I almost bought tac today, but since the mil powder is essentially H335, I started with that. If I can't hit my target velocity/accuracy with that, then I'll likely go to one of the ramshot powders.
                      Last edited by SixPointEight; 02-01-2011, 6:41 PM.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        rsrocket1
                        Veteran Member
                        • Feb 2010
                        • 2774

                        Did you try the Xtreme 55gr fmjbt's at Discount Shooter's Supply in Roseville? They only sell in lots of 500, but the last batch I got were $40. They may have gone up a little since then, but probably not too much. The box says M193 on it and it is a boat tail bullet with a cannelure and an exposed lead base just like the "real" M193. I wasn't looking for a 193 clone, just cheap .224 pills and these fit the bill. Best of all, they are local.

                        The other option is to get real m193's from High Tech Ammo. If you see what you want there, get it quick because they tend to be up and down in inventory and something you see this week may not be there the next. They also sell "real" WC844 and WC846 if you really want that stuff. I simply got 8 pounds of H335 @ Sportsman's Warehouse because I was more concerned in getting a "sure thing" and was willing to pay the extra $20 for cannister powder rather than pulled powder. Maybe in the future, I'll go the cheaper route.
                        Last edited by rsrocket1; 01-19-2011, 7:46 AM. Reason: punctuation

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          SixPointEight
                          Veteran Member
                          • May 2009
                          • 3788

                          Perhaps everything i need is right there. I havent ordered the others yets, so i think im going to start with 500 of those, since i already have h335 im gonna start with thatt, then order a can when i can

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            smoothy8500
                            Veteran Member
                            • Sep 2009
                            • 3846

                            Re: Armscor and 1-2 MOA. My experience with Armscor and Widener "milspec" 55gr left me disappointed. Your barrel may do great however. I would strongly suggest getting a sample of the inexpensive bullets to try first before buying 1k or more. Hornady 55gr fmjbt gets you 1 MOA easily. My experience with the Hornady spire point was great too. Consider just ignoring the cannelure and going by the c.o.a.l. you want.
                            Last edited by smoothy8500; 01-19-2011, 12:03 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              SixPointEight
                              Veteran Member
                              • May 2009
                              • 3788

                              Im gonna try the pulled m193 bullets. Not expecting too much out of them, but if they dont meet expectations ill go with factory produced bullets. of course im only trying 100 of each and testing before buying in bulk

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1