Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

9mm reloading aggravation

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • john.blowingrock@gmail.co
    Junior Member
    • Feb 2010
    • 3

    9mm reloading aggravation

    Bear with me please, as I am new to reloading and want to include any and all I think pertinent:

    RCBS Rocker Chucker Supreme Kit with 3 piece carbide die set - the 2 seater plugs that came with it are stamped 9mmTMJ and 38RN - is this as it should be?

    First loads were using Blazer fired once cleaned brass

    Berry's 9115RN plated bullets bullets - please confirm which seater plug I should be using for these

    All 3 operations using the dies were carried out to the best of my abilities and according to directions (I think). The crimping was by far the most difficult for me to understand and perform.

    After doing several bullets, I found that they would drop fully into the barrel of a Taurus slim 709, but would not seat all the way in a Glock 19 barrel, with maybe an 1/8" sticking out.

    Here are the specs from a stock PMC round (these shoot flawlessly in both gun), a round that goes into the Glock barrel, and a round that does nto.

    Stock PMC:
    Case at bullet mouth: .377
    Midway down case: .382
    Case at rim end: 3.86
    Overall length: 1.152

    Round that seats in the Glock:
    Case at bullet mouth: .378
    Midway down case: .3815
    Case at rim end: 3.9
    Overall length: 1.121

    Round that does not seat in Glock:
    Case at bullet mouth: .379
    Midway down case: .39
    Case at rim end: .39
    Overall length: 1.114

    I see that the .39 measurements for the one that won't seat are larger, but I am not sure what I am doing or not doing to cause this.

    The group of reloads that will fit was my first run. I went back this morning to load a few more and something was off and I ran a few that won't go in the barrel.

    Any clues as to what step is causing this and what the fix is?

    Thanks a ton for any assistance!

    JC
  • #2
    Dubious_Beans
    Veteran Member
    • Jul 2010
    • 3721

    Originally posted by john.blowingrock@gmail.co
    the 2 seater plugs that came with it are stamped 9mmTMJ and 38RN - is this as it should be?
    Yeah, that's what mine say.

    Berry's 9115RN plated bullets bullets - please confirm which seater plug I should be using for these
    I'd use the round nose (RN).

    I see that the .39 measurements for the one that won't seat are larger, but I am not sure what I am doing or not doing to cause this.
    Are you doing a full length resize?

    Remove the dies.
    With the shell holder in place and the ram raised to it's highest position, screw the resizing die down until it just makes contact with the shell holder. Now back off the die about 1/8 turn so it does NOT quite touch the holder.
    Lock the die in place and that should be adjusted correctly for full length resize. Works for me on my Rock Chucker...

    Measurements from one of my loads prepared on the Rock Chucker Supreme::
    Case at bullet mouth: .379
    Midway down case: .377
    Case at rim end: .387
    Overall length: 1.100" (115 JHP)

    Have fired about 400 rounds of handloads so far through the XD with no failures.
    Last edited by Dubious_Beans; 08-22-2010, 9:39 AM.

    Comment

    • #3
      john.blowingrock@gmail.co
      Junior Member
      • Feb 2010
      • 3

      Resizing was the issue

      As 'Beans' mentioned, it was apparent that I wasn't getting a full resize, and the big question was WHY?

      Sitting around thinking about it, I remembered that for some reason, the primer punch was not fully punching out the primer with one attempt, and I would have to rotate the casing and do another stroke.

      This was a pain, so I kept running the punch in the middle of the die down, hoping it would solve the problem. NADA

      I got some PMC brass, backed the primer punch all the way out to test and SHAZAM!!

      Obviously, what wa happening was the stoke was bottoming out on the head of the punch and not completing the full resize.

      I could feel the extra pressure it was taking to get all the way through a good resize.

      New run drops in the Glock barrel easily.

      Any thoughts as to why the Blazer primer wasn't letting go? The ones in the PMC brass dropped right out.

      JC

      Comment

      • #4
        at_liberty
        Senior Member
        • Jun 2010
        • 699

        The solution may not be sizing but post sizing. A Factory crimp die (FCD) has salvaged many rounds for me.

        The case is expanded by bullet insertion. That's what gives good bullet retention, but the round may need to be resized for maximum chamber diameter to allow feeding.

        I have dealt with this by using a Lyman gauge on all my finished rounds. Anything that won't drop in cleanly gets FCD'd or for a second time. That usually works, but there can be rim damage too that needs filing.

        Gauging specific to a particular gun can be done using its removed barrel, but the Lyman gauge, for me, makes it more obvious when a round isn't dropping in quite all the way. The gauge also can be used to measure high primers.

        I found that I have a lot more trouble with these issues when using plated bullets. I have not tried lead bullets, usually buying pretty standard FMJ, mostly Armscor or Zero. I wonder if the bullet shape is more stable in a jacketed bullet, less like trying to cram a soft blob into a brass tube. The FCD just seems to address all that, ensuring that the shape and size will go in a chamber that is within spec.

        Comment

        • #5
          at_liberty
          Senior Member
          • Jun 2010
          • 699

          Originally posted by john.blowingrock@gmail.co
          <>Any thoughts as to why the Blazer primer wasn't letting go? The ones in the PMC brass dropped right out.

          JC
          Blazer would be CCI primers.

          Comment

          • #6
            J-cat
            Calguns Addict
            • May 2005
            • 6626

            Don't use RCBS RN plugs for seating 9mm RN bullets. The plugs are designed for 1R ogjives and 9mm bullet noses are too pointed (2.5R+). I'd get a different seater die with a plug having a more conical internal profile.

            Why? Because a plug designed for a 1R ogjive will not seat a 2.5R bullet straight in the case. If you seat a bullet crooked, it will bulge the case. If you bulge the case, the round won't chamber.

            Running such a creature through a FCD in hopes of salvaging it is a poor poor practice. It's like throwing bondo at a dent instead of pulling it and fixing it right.

            I suggest you invest in a Redding competition seater and a taper crimp die. It will make your life easier and your reloading experience more pleasant. If that's too much, get a Lee seater and a taper crimp die.

            Comment

            • #7
              at_liberty
              Senior Member
              • Jun 2010
              • 699

              Originally posted by J-cat
              Running such a creature through a FCD in hopes of salvaging it is a poor poor practice. It's like throwing bondo at a dent instead of pulling it and fixing it right.
              I think that's too smug, more of the FCD wars nonsense. It is an insult to the many who have found the FCD to be a very real solution to something that does not deserve the attention of rocket science. A quick-and-dirty, slam dunk solution like an FCD is precisely what the circumstances demand.

              Comment

              • #8
                Chief-7700
                Veteran Member
                • May 2008
                • 3382

                FCD works for some people and for others it is junk science. With properly adjusted dies there is no need for the FCD

                XL-650 to feed the: .45ACP's Les Baer Concept V, Ruger SR 1911, Ruger Nightwatchman,custom built Colt M1911, Springfield .45ACP Loaded.. 9MM SA Range Officer,Ruger P-85, Springfield Stainless 9MM loaded, SA 9MM 5.25" XDM, Springfield 9mm Stainless Range Officer, STI double stack .45ACP.
                IDPA A41750 Safety Officer
                NRA Certified RSO
                "Stay out of the deep end of the pool; correct the problem with your credit card, not your dremel!"

                Comment

                • #9
                  J-cat
                  Calguns Addict
                  • May 2005
                  • 6626

                  Originally posted by at_liberty
                  I think that's too smug, more of the FCD wars nonsense. It is an insult to the many who have found the FCD to be a very real solution to something that does not deserve the attention of rocket science. A quick-and-dirty, slam dunk solution like an FCD is precisely what the circumstances demand.
                  Ladies and gentlemen, this is precisely why you should not shoot anyone's reloads other than your own.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    at_liberty
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2010
                    • 699

                    Originally posted by J-cat
                    Ladies and gentlemen, this is precisely why you should not shoot anyone's reloads other than your own.
                    Shall we also be required to always use virgin brass and only the very best commercial grade of bullets? I think your concern has a proper context. High-powered rifle deserves all the quality and accuracy concerns possible. In terms of high volume pistol shooting and reloading...close enough, safe enough, accurate enough, clean enough, fast enough...are acceptable compromises, when the real criteria is cheap enough and whether it will feed and go bang reliably.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      J-cat
                      Calguns Addict
                      • May 2005
                      • 6626

                      Originally posted by at_liberty
                      Shall we also be required to always use virgin brass and only the very best commercial grade of bullets? I think your concern has a proper context. High-powered rifle deserves all the quality and accuracy concerns possible. In terms of high volume pistol shooting and reloading...close enough, safe enough, accurate enough, clean enough, fast enough...are acceptable compromises, when the real criteria is cheap enough and whether it will feed and go bang reliably.


                      This is not about the quality of components. This is about the quality of assembly. Obviously, if a round does not chamber because the bullet is crooked in the case, "close enough" it is not. Hammering the round to fit, which is precisely what the FCD does, is not the answer. The FCD distorts the bullet inside the case. It changes the balance. The bullet wobbles down the bore. Rounds "repaired" by the FCD are grossly inaccurate.

                      People who reload should pay attention to what they are doing. Paying attention makes the FCD unnecessary.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        at_liberty
                        Senior Member
                        • Jun 2010
                        • 699

                        Originally posted by J-cat
                        This is not about the quality of components. This is about the quality of assembly. Obviously, if a round does not chamber because the bullet is crooked in the case, "close enough" it is not. Hammering the round to fit, which is precisely what the FCD does, is not the answer. The FCD distorts the bullet inside the case. It changes the balance. The bullet wobbles down the bore. Rounds "repaired" by the FCD are grossly inaccurate.

                        People who reload should pay attention to what they are doing. Paying attention makes the FCD unnecessary.
                        It is only the case of oversized lead bullets that the FCD creates a problem worth debating. Why should there be any assumption that everyone is using lead bullets and probably casting their own. That is only one fraternity within the universe of reloaders. I use only jacketed bullets and intend to continue. Being oversized or soft enough to easily deform is not an issue for my bullets.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          J-cat
                          Calguns Addict
                          • May 2005
                          • 6626

                          Originally posted by at_liberty
                          It is only the case of oversized lead bullets that the FCD creates a problem worth debating.
                          The OP is using a .356" plated bullet. He seated the bullet crooked and his case is bulged in the middle. A FCD will remove the bulge by swaging the bullet to shape while inside the case. The bullet is off center now and will remain off center after the trip through the FCD.

                          If you cannot picture this in your head, then the issue is not worth debating on this end.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            sequoia_nomad
                            Senior Member
                            • Mar 2010
                            • 803

                            Originally posted by john.blowingrock@gmail.co

                            Any thoughts as to why the Blazer primer wasn't letting go? The ones in the PMC brass dropped right out.

                            JC
                            Make sure you are dealing with reloadable cases. Some Blazer ammo is Berdan primed and non-reloadable, these would be the ones with a grey aluminum colored case. Then there is Blazer Brass, with a brass case that is boxer primed and reloadable. Look in the case, if you see one hole in the bottom it is Boxer primed, if there are two holes it is Berdan primed. You don't want to try reloading the grey colored ones, regardless of priming style. And you cannot reload anything with the Berdan (2 hole) primer.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              eaglemike
                              CGN/CGSSA Contributor - Lifetime
                              CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                              • Jan 2008
                              • 4002

                              There's some intel in this thread that I certainly don't agree with.

                              Lee FCD dies do not make inaccurate ammunition. Period. If you say that, you ABSO-EFFING-LUTELY do not know what you are taking about. I've used them to make mixed brass reloads that shot under 4" at 50 yards in twilight offhand using a S&W 686 with a custom barrel that I fit. I'm not shooting several times a week anymore, so I'm not sure I could still do it. I did do it though. I know of several competition shooters that have used these when they wanted ammunition that would work every time in the revolver or pistol they were using.

                              BTW, I used to make reloading dies for a living.....

                              If the sized and unloaded brass wouldn't gauge, which seems to the the situation, why not start there? The OP adjusted the decapping punch so it wasn't stopping the process, and now the brass gauges l...........

                              Sometimes plated bullets ARE too soft for a decent crimp. I've seen them bulge above and below the crimp, causing chambering problems. This was in the early 90's long before I'd heard of (maybe they weren't even out?) the LEE FCD. I didn't try the LEE FCD to sure this condition.

                              It does help to use a proper bullet seating punch, but it's not unusual to get one that doesn't fit the bullet nose well. Star Machine Works (the original in San Diego) used to ask for a sample bullet or mold number for the reloader ordered and they'd make a custom punch for each loading tool, with spares as ordered. If your punch doesn't fit perfectly in loading most handgun ammunition, don't panic. Make a few rounds, look at them carefully to see how squarely the bullet seated, and shoot for test. Remember that seating 9mm or .40 deeper than specified can cause pressure to go up very quickly.

                              It can take a while to get a good handle on how things happen and what things are affected when certain things happen. Always be cautious when reloading, be 3X as cautious when you are learning.

                              OP - I personally never reloaded Blazer brass. The only Blazer stuff I ever shot had aluminum cases. Sometimes brass variance causes problem. PMC has been pretty decent in my experience. 9mm brass is pretty cheap. If you need a few hundred to play with, send me a p.m. with your addr, make a $10 donation to the CGF, and it's on the way to you. It'll be once fired mixed brass, useful for practice, moderate pressure loads. I wouldn't mix brass for stout loads.
                              all the best,
                              Mike
                              Last edited by eaglemike; 08-23-2010, 1:02 AM.
                              There are some people that it's just not worth engaging.

                              It's a muzzle BRAKE, not a muzzle break. Or is your muzzle tired?

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1