Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

first handload woes

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • wayoutwest
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2003
    • 727

    first handload woes

    ...teach your children well...
  • #2
    thmpr
    Veteran Member
    • Dec 2005
    • 3785

    Sounds like your head spacing on your sizing die is set incorrectly. It is not fully sizing the case far enough since engaging the bolt is tight. Do you have a case gauge handy to check the headspace?
    NRA Life Member

    Comment

    • #3
      moredes
      Junior Member
      • Oct 2005
      • 76

      Agreed. It won't close because the headspacing is inconsistent.

      I'll assume it's a .308 we're talking about (I don't follow 30-06, so I dunno if 168's and 75's are used there). Dunno what you expected for accuracy out of a bone stock Rem700. You don't say when it was made, but I'm not so sure that makes much difference. Remington has a pretty inconsistent reputation for their recent specimens (last 20 years, as I hear it). That said, y'oughta be able to get 2MOA with factory loads like BH, I would think.

      How accurate was your seating depth? Were you using a competition seating die that'd allow you to set the bullet depth with precision, or are you using a regular seating component of a 2-die set? (We're getting pretty fussy here now.) Have you measured your rifle for the ideal OAL setting? What're you using to measure? Stoney Point is probably acknowledged as the most accurate and easiest tool to work with within monetary 'reason'.

      As for your load, I've not heard anything good about Remington brass; that's not to say it's bad--I've just never heard anything good. Most guys shooting for groups tout Lake City brass, Lapua, Winchester, Black Hills, and sometimes even Federal (though a lot of folks dislike them for their inherent softness). As to powder and primers, each rifle is different. Varget is a favorite, but both my 700's really do poorly on it. They both like IMR 4064 or RL-15 better. Are your primers GM 210M, or just the usual 210s ? The Match primers *are* manu'd to better tolerances. I swear the PSS only comes in one barrel twist-- a 1/12, which common wisdom claims is more suited to 175+ than 168s especially at long range 300yd+.

      175's and 168's ain't gonna hit the same spot even when you shoot them at the same target distance. What did you mean when you said the first was 'dead on'? If it hit where the 68's did, it's prolly more fluke than design. I dunno if you mean you got a 2-3" group spread with the '75s, or the 175s grouped 2-3" away from the 168s holes.

      How long did you wait between shots? Theory (especially when shooting for group size) says that one should allow the barrel to cool at least a minute between shots. A minute's a long time to wait when that's all you're doing. However, if you don't, by the end of a 5-shot string, the barrel can be pretty hot, and after a quick 15-shot string (say, ~4 minutes for the entire string--~15 seconds per shot) the barrel could be too hot to touch (which violates the cardinal rule of barrel treatment, except in competitions). Under those conditions the barrel will walk and throw the pills everywhere.

      Comment

      • #4
        50BMGBOB
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2005
        • 1738

        If it was once fired in a different gun,aka a military (belt fed) you may need a small base sizer.
        sigpic50BMGBOB aka 50BMGLAZARUS aka 50BMGZOMBIEBOB aka the UN- DEAD!

        Comment

        • #5
          wayoutwest
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2003
          • 727

          oops
          ...teach your children well...

          Comment

          • #6
            wayoutwest
            Senior Member
            • Jan 2003
            • 727

            Originally posted by thmpr
            Sounds like your head spacing on your sizing die is set incorrectly. It is not fully sizing the case far enough since engaging the bolt is tight. Do you have a case gauge handy to check the headspace?
            My noobie guess is that its not sizing the base of the case. I have a case gauge on my list for my next Midway order.

            moredes

            Agreed. It won't close because the headspacing is inconsistent.

            I'll assume it's a .308 we're talking about (I don't follow 30-06, so I dunno if 168's and 75's are used there). Dunno what you expected for accuracy out of a bone stock Rem700. You don't say when it was made, but I'm not so sure that makes much difference. Remington has a pretty inconsistent reputation for their recent specimens (last 20 years, as I hear it). That said, y'oughta be able to get 2MOA with factory loads like BH, I would think.

            How accurate was your seating depth? Were you using a competition seating die that'd allow you to set the bullet depth with precision, or are you using a regular seating component of a 2-die set? (We're getting pretty fussy here now.) Have you measured your rifle for the ideal OAL setting? What're you using to measure? Stoney Point is probably acknowledged as the most accurate and easiest tool to work with within monetary 'reason'.

            As for your load, I've not heard anything good about Remington brass; that's not to say it's bad--I've just never heard anything good. Most guys shooting for groups tout Lake City brass, Lapua, Winchester, Black Hills, and sometimes even Federal (though a lot of folks dislike them for their inherent softness). As to powder and primers, each rifle is different. Varget is a favorite, but both my 700's really do poorly on it. They both like IMR 4064 or RL-15 better. Are your primers GM 210M, or just the usual 210s ? The Match primers *are* manu'd to better tolerances. I swear the PSS only comes in one barrel twist-- a 1/12, which common wisdom claims is more suited to 175+ than 168s especially at long range 300yd+.

            175's and 168's ain't gonna hit the same spot even when you shoot them at the same target distance. What did you mean when you said the first was 'dead on'? If it hit where the 68's did, it's prolly more fluke than design. I dunno if you mean you got a 2-3" group spread with the '75s, or the 175s grouped 2-3" away from the 168s holes.

            How long did you wait between shots? Theory (especially when shooting for group size) says that one should allow the barrel to cool at least a minute between shots. A minute's a long time to wait when that's all you're doing. However, if you don't, by the end of a 5-shot string, the barrel can be pretty hot, and after a quick 15-shot string (say, ~4 minutes for the entire string--~15 seconds per shot) the barrel could be too hot to touch (which violates the cardinal rule of barrel treatment, except in competitions). Under those conditions the barrel will walk and throw the pills everywhere.
            Moredes, some of the stuff above is greek to me. I set the OAL based on the BH match 168 lenght with the standard seating die from Lee. As for primers they are the regular 210. When I switched to the 175s it was with a new target and the first shot hit the 1" shoot and see (POA-POI) (luck) the follow up shots grouped 2"-3" around it. It was not one long fast string but 3 slow 5 shot over about 20-25 minutes or so. The barrel may have got warm, positive it never got hot.

            Thanks for the insight so far.
            ...teach your children well...

            Comment

            • #7
              dw1784
              Senior Member
              • May 2006
              • 705

              turn the dies another 1/4 to 1/3 turns. Get a stoney point like others suggests.


              though there's been lot of talk about recent quality issues, PSS is one of the most accurate rifles out of the box. My pss will often print <1MOA on my best days. Then again, I might've lucked out as I've never had to adjust the trigger, get a new stock or need a new barrel like a lot of people ask on forums. It's more rifle than I am. You do need to try different loads though. For example, my pss seems to like 46gr of Varget with 155gr Amax Palmas, while my friend's light tactical pss(20" barrel) likes 42gr 4895. Good luck and have fun

              Comment

              • #8
                tankerman
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Mar 2006
                • 24240

                The cases may need to be trimmed, was this used brass that you purchased? Full legth resize or neck resize. If you just resized the neck then the shoulder could be to far forward asuuming that this brass was fired in a different gun. Or were up messing with the seater die reapeatedly? Did you check the overall length to see if they were uniform? then measure from the base to the shoulder and the length of the neck compare several cases

                Comment

                • #9
                  moredes
                  Junior Member
                  • Oct 2005
                  • 76

                  Bigtime brain fart on my part. OAL isn't really that "critical" with an OEM Rem700 unless they're barreling the actions with much more attention to machine tolerances than they've done in the past. The reason they're assembled with such a "long built-in OAL" is because of liability; they don't want the average reloader to be able to increase pressures by inadvertantly increasing the cartridge's OAL to the point of the actual bullet's ability to touch the lands and grooves (aka, 'throat').

                  Correctly assembled, there isn't a factory round available that comes close to crowding the throat by having an overly long OAL. Almost any one of the OEM bullet makers will do as a sampler for measuring OAL, and Black Hills is fine. Factory is certainly not the best OAL; you'll need to measure accurately (with something akin to a Stoney Point), but even at that, The OEM dimension will really stretch that cartridge length if one wants to set right off the throat for accuracy. So my previous point about measuring OAL isn't that valid. If you based your reloading OAL on Black Hills dimensions, that's good enough for ballpark.

                  If it took you 20-25 minutes to set off three 5-shot strings, you're right, the barrel never got hot enough to 'walk'. (and the general rule of thumb for 'accuracy' is, if you can't hold the barrel bare-handed, it's too hot to shoot--on a hot day in the sun, firing the 3rd round in a span of three minutes can make the barrel too hot for shooting best groups)

                  What kind of groups did you get firing the Black Hills stuff? How much experience do you have shooting rifles for accuracy? Do you know what "natural point of aim" means? is the rifle set up with a bipod, or did you use bags? Did you use a bag to support the butt, or was it hand-held? Were you using a scope, and if so, how was the parallax?

                  Lastly, my best ammo-related recommendation is that you should try different powder/primer combinations. 2-3" groups ain't very good; and if another shooter confirms that the lack of accuracy is inherent in the rifle (or the Black Hills is giving you groups under say, 1 1/2" at 100yd), I'd say the "fault" is in the ammo and/or your shooting technique. 175 SMK's may not be the best round to proof your gun at 100yd. There's a big camp that believes that 175's can't be as accurate as 168's in close (~first 300yd), and I'm a believer. There's a lot of theory surrounding the results that the majority (I mean like 51+%, not 99) of shooters get better groups with 175's farther out than in close. In any case, under 300yd, I'd use 168's for accuracy, even out of a 1/12 barrel.

                  Help me out here, guys.... I'm not up on my Rem700s anymore--what's the expected standard accuracy for an OEM 700 now?

                  Tankerman makes a good point. This is brass that meets SAAMI specs, yes? If not, you should trim the cases. I'd suggest you go with a Full Length resizing die for the initial firings only because you're having problems, but after that, a neck-sizing die (only) built for that gun would be a nice luxury.
                  Last edited by moredes; 02-03-2007, 8:19 AM.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    MisterDudeManGuy
                    Member
                    • Jul 2006
                    • 262

                    For accuracy, "exactly the same" is the word. Trim cases, weigh them, weigh charges, use high quality primers, find a charge that fills the case, use a cartridge gauge to make sure the shoulder is where it ought to be, and use a gauge to measure dead length. If you are off the lands, then a crimp isn't a bad idea - especially if your rifle is throated long. Personally, I don't shoot anything that can't be made to seat in the lands. Not for accuracy, anyway.

                    OAL measurements are almost meaningless, but are really meaningless between different bullets with different ogives. Dead length is the measurement to get. That's the length between the case base and the contact point to the lands on the bullet ogive. A stoney point will do it.

                    Wait until you get your cartridge gauge before doing anything else. The only way to know if it's right is to measure it. Just turning the die in 'more' really doesn't do it. Even if turning the die gets the cartridges within SAAMI, you'll not know what you've done - nor how to replicate it if it works well. Nothing worse than getting a great load, and then not being able to make it again.

                    On short line, I shoot 150gr spitzers. My opinion is that boat tails take time to stabilize. That time can be increased by getting enough wrong in load development. I shoot for group size at 200. Hope some of this helps.
                    "California blows. Or maybe it sucks. Either way, I'm outta here." - MisterDudeManGuy

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      tankerman
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Mar 2006
                      • 24240

                      Originally posted by MisterDudeManGuy
                      For accuracy, "exactly the same" is the word. Trim cases, weigh them, weigh charges, use high quality primers, find a charge that fills the case, use a cartridge gauge to make sure the shoulder is where it ought to be, and use a gauge to measure dead length. If you are off the lands, then a crimp isn't a bad idea - especially if your rifle is throated long. Personally, I don't shoot anything that can't be made to seat in the lands. Not for accuracy, anyway.

                      OAL measurements are almost meaningless, but are really meaningless between different bullets with different ogives. Dead length is the measurement to get. That's the length between the case base and the contact point to the lands on the bullet ogive. A stoney point will do it.

                      Wait until you get your cartridge gauge before doing anything else. The only way to know if it's right is to measure it. Just turning the die in 'more' really doesn't do it. Even if turning the die gets the cartridges within SAAMI, you'll not know what you've done - nor how to replicate it if it works well. Nothing worse than getting a great load, and then not being able to make it again.

                      On short line, I shoot 150gr spitzers. My opinion is that boat tails take time to stabilize. That time can be increased by getting enough wrong in load development. I shoot for group size at 200. Hope some of this helps.
                      OAL is not meaningless if the cases need to be trimmed and the shoulder is moved forward, or if he is seating the bullet out to far it could be contacting L and G's. I bet on the shoulder being to far forward, specially if they were not completely resized

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Fjold
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        • Oct 2005
                        • 23094

                        If your sizing die is adjusted correctly (check the directions that came with your dies) then make sure before you size the cases that you have some lube inside the neck. Alot of times people will lube the outside of the cases but not the inside of the neck, this causes the expander ball to drag on the neck as it is pulled out and pull the neck and shoulder forward making the headspace to tight.
                        Frank

                        One rifle, one planet, Holland's 375




                        Life Member NRA, CRPA and SAF

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          C.G.
                          Calguns Addict
                          • Oct 2005
                          • 8259

                          Originally posted by moredes
                          damn
                          You can delete these posts.
                          sigpic

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            moredes
                            Junior Member
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 76

                            Thanks, CG. I missed that. duh

                            I bet your right about the shoulder being to far forward, Tankerman. But if he's right, and his OAL is copied from BH ammo, I wouldn't guess he's on the Ls and Gs.
                            Last edited by moredes; 02-03-2007, 5:45 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              anotherted
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2005
                              • 1198

                              NM, Fjold beat me to it.

                              I had the same problem. lube the inside of the case neck for sure.
                              <bof>all your guns are belong to us</bof>

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1