Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

I tried the Satterlee v2.0 load dev method

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Tripplet918
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2022
    • 918

    I tried the Satterlee v2.0 load dev method

    Ive been following a youtube channel called ?Shooting with the Lillys?. A couple of years ago, they posted a video on Satterlee v2.0 load development.

    As I understand, it goes like this.

    Use the max load provided by the powder maker. Satterlee actually states, max loads from Hodgdon are safe.
    Conduct seating depth tests, 3-5 per.
    Load the bullets from 0.005 to 0.015 in 0.003 increments.
    Shoot them at 100 yards and evaluate groups with a focus on vertical dispersion. (The vid on it explains that in greater detail).

    The result can be further refined such as smaller test on seating depth. Or even go further from the lands.

    Since I already worked up a load, and have a powder charge that is already over Alliants recipe, I decided to stick with my powder charge. I just loaded up the ammo with different seating depths. Tests came back with good data.

    My best load that day came from the furthest from the lands that I seated. 0.015.

    6.5CM Hornady 140 ELD-M with 43.1 gr Reloder 16 2831 fps Alpha cases Federal 210M.


    The winning load, furthest from the lands that I loaded at 0.015", a 0.366" group



    The other loads...

    depth at 0.005



    0.008


    Not sure what to make of 0.012. Vertical dispersion is excellent, but I got that one round fly left. The groups just get better the further I am from the lands on this rifle.


    Satterlee was pretty upfront that this method isnt definitive. It will get anyone very close to a great load in as little as 12 rounds. Shortening load development for PRS shooters is important as they burn barrels like no tomorrow, and cant be developing loads OCW style all the time. That further refinement can be done.

    He did mention something that resonated with me. This method is a distillation of a lot of techniques, and that its main purpose is to serve those that dont wanna spend a lot of time developing a load to the degree where it adds results that are not worth the time and effort required for some people. He recognizes what the benchrest guys do will take load dev to the Nth degree, and its up to the person to decide if he wants to go there.

    What I unpacked from the v2.0 method is that 1) speed is less important 2) speed nodes as a result are less important but instead this method focuses on 3) controlling pressure spikes created by the powder charge relative to when the bullet hits the lands (rifling) is what makes for an accurate load. He's basically saying, pick any reasonable powder charge and you can make it work based on where you seat the bullet.

    I have a 75gr 223 load that I would really like to get to touch each other on a 5 round group. I'm going to see if I can do these same tests on a gas gun soon and get similar results.

    This method is not shared to say your process is wrong. Its just another method out there
    Last edited by Tripplet918; 07-24-2023, 11:09 AM.
  • #2
    kcstott
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Nov 2011
    • 11796

    Now that you have your seating depth, go back and refine your powder charge. .1gr steps, two steps above and two below.
    More rounds in the group too. like five round groups but in reality with good components a two round group will tell you if it's good or not. if the first two rounds are not touching or in the same hole a third shot will not make it better.

    Comment

    • #3
      Tripplet918
      Senior Member
      • Mar 2022
      • 918

      Originally posted by kcstott
      Now that you have your seating depth, go back and refine your powder charge. .1gr steps, two steps above and two below.
      More rounds in the group too. like five round groups but in reality with good components a two round group will tell you if it's good or not. if the first two rounds are not touching or in the same hole a third shot will not make it better.
      Great suggestion.

      I mentioned earlier that I had worked up my load to 43.1 grains. I have data on charges above and below that level in 0.2 grain increments.

      Given that Ive got data that tells me I have a plateau in velocity above and below 43.1 grains, I am not inclined to do anymore powder charge tests.

      Im very happy with the 0.366? group on a 30 cal projectile.

      Comment

      • #4
        divingin
        Veteran Member
        • Jul 2015
        • 2522

        Not to trash their method, but .005-.015 off the lands is a fairly small range.

        I've found (as have quite a few others) that the "gotta be tight to the lands" thing is not always best. For instance, in 6BR with a Berger 105 VLD (current advice is to jam it at least .010"), I found my rifle shot best at .070" off. 108BTHPs run best about .030" off.

        Another possible advantage of running further out is that a given amount of throat erosion causes a smaller percentage change to seating depth, which *may* make it less of an issue (not sure that's going to be meaningful though.)

        Comment

        • #5
          Tripplet918
          Senior Member
          • Mar 2022
          • 918

          ^^^good point. I've only tried the method and am looking at ways to refine it vs what I picked up off the video.

          I dont have experience in seating deeper, but I did find this.

          "I could cite even more books, but it seems like there is overwhelming support that if the absolute smallest groups are your highest priority, then minimizing jump seems to be the way to go. Everyone from accomplished scientific researchers to the absolute best-of-the-best, world-champion shooters are convinced that you’ll likely find the best accuracy with 0.020 inches of bullet jump or less."

          https://precisionrifleblog.com/2020/...20the%20target.

          Then there is this...

          "regardless of the shooter, order the shots were fired in, or the specific load used, there appears to be a sweet spot around 0.060” of bullet jump, because all of the lines on the chart appear to flatten out near that area. Also, we can see on the chart above that there doesn’t appear to be anything less than 0.040” of jump that seems to be forgiving, and 0.050-0.070” appears to be best for the rifle that was tested … regardless of shooter or specific load."

          This post shares more of Mark Gordon’s research on bullet jump, which is very interesting, original research – and has everyone talking! This post looks at research data on the Hornady’s 6.5mm 147 gr. ELD-M and Tubb’s 6mm 115 gr. DTAC RBT bullets. Check it out!


          So the method can remain the same, your theory on how much jump is to be tested, can vary from being up close, to going really far (0.05-0.070") depending on what you believe serves your purpose best.

          UPDATE: this 2022 vid has Satterlee saying he now starts at 50 thousandths of an inch.

          Last edited by Tripplet918; 07-25-2023, 10:12 AM.

          Comment

          • #6
          Working...
          UA-8071174-1