Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Inconsistent Full Length Resizing

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    J-cat
    Calguns Addict
    • May 2005
    • 6626

    Comment

    • #17
      Fire4Effect
      Senior Member
      • Dec 2009
      • 601

      Originally posted by John Galt
      There are a lot of variables here.

      One thing that comes to mind is the brass. All brass has a memory of sorts. It wants to return to the last shape it was heated to. You said you fired the brass in different chambers. This will create different memories where it wants to return to. This phenomenon is commonly called "spring back" by a lot of reloaders.

      Also assume you have different lot's of brass and likely different manufacturers. This will also induce variance. Different cases have different metallurgy even though they are all brass. They will have different spring back.

      For the above reasons a lot of the guys that are interested in very repeatable ammo(f-class and becnhrest) use the same lot of brass and tie it to a specific camber.

      One other thing that I have found over the years. For precision ammo I dont use the decaping pin in my sizing die. I full length resize and then use a neck expanding die to set neck tension. It gives me much more consistency.

      As a test remove the decaping pin from both and see if you still get the same issues. Ideally you would use the same lot of brass fired from the same rifle when testing.

      Comment

      • #18
        Dooder
        Senior Member
        • Nov 2012
        • 1514

        If I'm not mistaken doesn't the RCBS precision mic read to 0.001" not 0.0001"?
        Man, this place has gone bonkers.

        Comment

        • #19
          LynnJr
          Calguns Addict
          • Jan 2013
          • 7959

          I just read your post on typers hide and think you are getting some conflicting results.
          When you size brass it grows in length as you start to adjust the die lower in the press.
          This happens because you are squeezing the brass and it doesn't compress it goes in the direction of least resistance.
          As you keep lowering the die down the shoulder of the brass makes contact with the die and stops getting longer base to shoulder.
          As you now lower the die even further the shoulder gets bumped back to a shorter length but the case gets longer.

          The extra brass gets moved forward into the neck of the brass and will require you to trim the brass.

          Start with a unsized piece of brass and see if everything I post is 100% spot on. If you find a problem post it and I will let you know what happened.

          Your Dillon dies are shorter from the bottom of the die to the shoulder contact area of the die. They are made not to contact the shell holder so the die itself is shorter to the shoulder. If you have a machinist cut 0.005 off the bottom of your Redding dies your brass will once again be consistent.

          The reason it will be consistent is the extra 0.005 will take into account the sloppiness of the co-ax press that I said I wasn't familiar with in my earlier post.

          Now for some thoughts.
          Sizing lube has a thickness to it and doesn't compress so adding a lot to a case will size it more than a little will.

          Your setting of the shoulder to 0.0003 means nothing to anyone who reloads.
          0.001 is enough for any bolt gun so taking it down to 0.0003 looks like a BB in a boxcar. It is insignificant at that small.
          You then posted this is for an AR or five or six which require 0.004 to be reliable further showing that 0.0003 means anything.
          Yes you want consistent brass but more importantly you want brass that fits your chamber correctly.
          In my earlier post I said none of my chambers have zero headspace.
          On my small caliber rounds I have my gunsmith run the reamer 0.004 deeper than zero.
          This means I can use an off the shelf die and a Co-ax press and not have to rework the die.
          On my large caliber rifles I have the gunsmith run the reamer 0.008 deeper for the same reason.
          Lynn Dragoman, Jr.
          Southwest Regional Director
          Unlimited Range Shooters Association (URSA)
          www.unlimitedrange.org
          Not a commercial business.
          URSA - Competition starts at 2000 yards!

          Comment

          • #20
            pacrat
            I need a LIFE!!
            • May 2014
            • 10287

            Originally posted by Dooder
            If I'm not mistaken doesn't the RCBS precision mic read to 0.001" not 0.0001"?

            ^^^Correct^^^




            Determines chamber headspace and bullet seating depth to 0.001-inch

            Comment

            • #21
              Dooder
              Senior Member
              • Nov 2012
              • 1514

              So if op is sizing +2 on the mic and reporting 0.0002" then there's some confused going on elsewhere that probably needs to be sorted out first l.
              Man, this place has gone bonkers.

              Comment

              • #22
                ar15barrels
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jan 2006
                • 57202

                Originally posted by Fire4Effect
                I have been reloading 308 Win and 6.5mm Creedmoor and now started reloading 223 Rem. I have never loaded 223 Rem before and have encountered inconsistent full length resizing when I was setting up and adjusting the full length resizing die.

                EQUIPMENT
                • Forester Co-Ax Press
                • Redding Type S Bushing Style Full Length Die
                • Once Fired Winchester 223 Rem Cases (Note: Fired from my rifles)
                Inconsistency in shoulder length comes from variation in press frame stretch due to hardness variations in the brass.
                Go search for my explanation of "hard bump vs soft bump" sizing.
                Randall Rausch

                AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                Comment

                • #23
                  slamfire1
                  Banned
                  • Aug 2015
                  • 794

                  Yes it will. Melvin Johnson wrote an article about this in one of the 1940's American Rifleman magazines. Mr Johnson (the inventor of the Johnson rifle) called it drive in. Weapons need clearance between the bolt and breech face. I am going to use the example of the extractor star on a revolver. The slightest piece of powder gets between the extractor star and the cylinder, and you can't close the cylinder. Basically that will be true of rifles, the slightest bit of dirt between the bolt face and the breech, and a weapon with zero clearance won't go into battery.

                  Now that I remember, I went to a mid range rifle match with an AR15, put it in a hard case, and I had the bolt back, open bolt indicator device in the magazine, holding the bolt open. I got into position at 600 yards, put a round in the chamber, closed the bolt, and the rifle would not go bang. After a bunch of attempts, I finally separated the upper from the lower, looked in the locking area, and found a staple. One tiny staple had gotten in the case, gotten into the action, because the bolt was back, and I never saw it. That staple prevented the bolt from going fully into battery. I burned about half my shooting time before I figured it out.

                  Any way, that bolt to breech face clearance is taken up in semi auto weapons, as the breech assembly feeds the case into the chamber. And thus, if you eject an unfired case, and measure it, you will find that the mass of the breech assembly will have shortened the case a bit.

                  Now I am going to offer something really radical: to prevent case sidewall stretch in semi automatic weapons, leave the case lube on the case. Or, as I did, add a lubricant before firing. I took one set of LC66 cases 22 reloads,in a M1a, and never had a case head separation, or evidence of side wall stretch, because the cases were always fired with a lubricant.

                  With a dry case in a dry chamber, the front of the case adheres to the chamber front, and then as pressures build, the sidewalls have to stretch to allow the case head to reach the bolt. And even worse for gas guns, the things unlock, and are designed to unlock when there is a little bit of pressure left in the barrel. This is called the residual blowback effect, the desired effect is to pop the case out of the chamber, like a cork. But what happens is, the case is stretched even more as the bolt unlocks, because the bolt is moving backwards.

                  But, as I learned, if the case is lubricated, the front does not adhere to the chamber shoulders, or the chamber sidewalls, and so as pressure builds, the whole case slides to the bolt face. The case shoulders fold out to fill the void, but lube prevents the shoulders from grabbing the chamber. The end result is,with a lubricated case, there will not be any sidewall stretch.

                  I regularly fireform lubricated cases in my bolt guns. Even if the shoulder is set back some ridiculous amount, as what happens when I neck up 30-06 brass to 35 Whelen, as long as the case will fire, and the lubricant sufficient, the case will not experience sidewall stretch.This ensures that the ejected case is a perfect fit to the chamber, and is stress free.

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    Fire4Effect
                    Senior Member
                    • Dec 2009
                    • 601

                    Originally posted by Dooder
                    If I'm not mistaken doesn't the RCBS precision mic read to 0.001" not 0.0001"?
                    Yes, you are correct. I was off a decimal point.

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      Fire4Effect
                      Senior Member
                      • Dec 2009
                      • 601

                      Originally posted by Dooder
                      So if op is sizing +2 on the mic and reporting 0.0002" then there's some confused going on elsewhere that probably needs to be sorted out first l.
                      I will go back and correct my posts when I have time.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        Fire4Effect
                        Senior Member
                        • Dec 2009
                        • 601

                        Thank you to everyone who has provided input. I am not going to respond individually, but instead provide a recap of what I am experiencing.

                        I purchased a Redding 223 full length Type S resizing die and I am using it with my Forester Co-Ax press. Upon initial setup I have been having a difficult time resizing cases to 1.4636”. I get one case resized to 1.4636” then the next one is 1.4656” and the next one is 1.4626”. I use Imperial Sizing Die Wax and Imperial Application media with Dry Neck Lube and you carbide expander ball. The cases resize effortlessly. NOTE: I have to cam-over to achieve 1.4636”. All the brass is commercial Winchester 223 Rem from the same lot and fired once from different AR rifles that I own.

                        I have a new Dillon 223 resizing die I have never used and decided to see how it performed with the Forester Co-Ax press. I found I was able to consistently resize cases to 1.4636” without resorting to cam-over.

                        Next I installed the Redding 223 Rem resizing die on my Dillon 550 press and found I was able to consistently resize cases to 1.4636” without resorting to cam-over.

                        I suspected the auto shell holder on the Forester press might be the issue (flexing under cam-over) and I reinstalled the Redding 223 Rem resizing die in the Forester Co-Ax press to retest. I set aside once fired cases that measured +5 on my RCBS Precision Mic and tried resizing them and found I was able to obtain consistent resizing until I tried to go lower than +3 on the RCBS Precision Mic. I noticed that any attempt to resize lower than +3 required the press to cam-over.

                        What I have been able to show is that the combination of the Redding FL resizing die with the Forester Co-Ax press will consistently resize cases as long as I don’t cam-over. I can consistently resize cases to +3 (1.4666”) without resorting to cam-over. If I try resizing to obtain 0 (1.4636”), I get inconsistent resizing.

                        I did inquire on the Internet and another reloader responded that he had experienced the same issue with 223 Rem resizing dies and the Forester Co-Ax press and traced the problem to the press auto shell holder when cam-over is applied. I am hoping removing .005” from the base of the Redding resizing die will eliminate cam-over and result in consistent resizing. I am going to send my die along with fires cases for Redding engineers to evaluate.

                        In the meantime, a reloader on another thread I started said he gets consistent resizing with his Forester Co-Ax and a 223 Rem resizing die that cams-over if he resizes the case twice without the expander button. He rotates the case 180˚ between passes and then in a separate operation he runs the resized cases through the expander ball. I tried that this morning with 50 once fired Winchester cases and I am obtaining resized brass that is consistently within 0.001”. This will be my fallback position if removing 0.005” of material from the base of the Redding resizing die is not an option.
                        Last edited by Fire4Effect; 01-04-2021, 2:36 PM.

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          ar15barrels
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Jan 2006
                          • 57202

                          Originally posted by Fire4Effect
                          Thank you to everyone who has provided input. I am not going to respond individually, but instead provide a recap of what I am experiencing.

                          I purchased a Redding 223 full length Type S resizing die and I am using it with my Forester Co-Ax press. Upon initial setup I have been having a difficult time resizing cases to 1.4636”. I get one case resized to 1.4636” then the next one is 1.4656” and the next one is 1.4626”. I use Imperial Sizing Die Wax and Imperial Application media with Dry Neck Lube and you carbide expander ball. The cases resize effortlessly. NOTE: I have to cam-over to achieve 1.4636”. All the brass is commercial Winchester 223 Rem from the same lot and fired once from different AR rifles that I own.

                          I have a new Dillon 223 resizing die I have never used and decided to see how it performed with the Forester Co-Ax press. I found I was able to consistently resize cases to 1.4636” without resorting to cam-over.

                          Next I installed the Redding 223 Rem resizing die on my Dillon 550 press and found I was able to consistently resize cases to 1.4636” without resorting to cam-over.

                          I suspected the auto shell holder on the Forester press might be the issue (flexing under cam-over) and I reinstalled the Redding 223 Rem resizing die in the Forester Co-Ax press to retest. I set aside once fired cases that measured +5 on my RCBS Precision Mic and tried resizing them and found I was able to obtain consistent resizing until I tried to go lower than +3 on the RCBS Precision Mic. I noticed that any attempt to resize lower than +3 required the press to cam-over.

                          What I have been able to show is that the combination of the Redding FL resizing die with the Forester Co-Ax press will consistently resize cases as long as I don’t cam-over. I can consistently resize cases to +3 (1.4666”) without resorting to cam-over. If I try resizing to obtain 0 (1.4636”), I get inconsistent resizing.

                          I did inquire on the Internet and another reloader responded that he had experienced the same issue with 223 Rem resizing dies and the Forester Co-Ax press and traced the problem to the press auto shell holder when cam-over is applied. I am hoping removing .005” from the base of the Redding resizing die will eliminate cam-over and result in consistent resizing. I am going to send my die along with fires cases for Redding engineers to evaluate.

                          In the meantime, a reloader on another thread I started said he gets consistent resizing with his Forester Co-Ax and a 223 Rem resizing die that cams-over if he resizes the case twice without the expander button. He rotates the case 180˚ between passes and then in a separate operation he runs the resized cases through the expander ball. I tried that this morning with 50 once fired Winchester cases and I am obtaining resized brass that is consistently within 0.001”. This will be my fallback position if removing 0.005” of material from the base of the Redding resizing die is not an option.
                          Two comments.
                          1. I think you are misunderstanding or mis-using the term cam-over to mean something different than it does.
                          Camming over is a matter of the press linkage design.
                          Some cam-over and others do not.
                          This has nothing to do with how hard the die is set against the shellholder.
                          Unless you are adjusting a stop on the press linkage which changes how far the handle moves the ram, you can not adjust a press to cam-over or not cam-over.

                          2. You won't attain absolutely consistent sizing without a hard fit between shellholder and die as you will be relying on the consistency of the stretch of the press frame to create a consistent stop of the sizing operation.
                          An air gap between shellholder and die ensures that the stop will not be consistent if there is stretch in the frame/linkage.
                          There is ALWAYS stretch in the press frame/linkage if force is being applied.
                          When you use a solid steel-on-steel (no air gap) at a pressure level above the threshold of the brass, the shoulder locations become much more consistent.
                          Randall Rausch

                          AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                          Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                          Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                          Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                          Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            divingin
                            Veteran Member
                            • Jul 2015
                            • 2522

                            I'm guessing it's a lube problem. Inconsistent or insufficient lube means that some cases have more resistance (or drag) to sizing, causing varying amounts of press stretch. You don't see that effect with the carbide dies, as they generate less friction due to their hardness.

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              mtenenhaus
                              Veteran Member
                              • Jul 2007
                              • 3416

                              i so often learn a tremendous amount from the experienced members of this forum.
                              if i might contribute, here's a nice little article by Mr. Zediker on the topic in which he specifically refers to the Forster Co-Ax press. Perhaps that might help as well.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                Bastard
                                • Jul 2009
                                • 2209

                                Originally posted by ar15barrels
                                Two comments.
                                1. I think you are misunderstanding or mis-using the term cam-over to mean something different than it does.
                                Camming over is a matter of the press linkage design.
                                Some cam-over and others do not.
                                This has nothing to do with how hard the die is set against the shellholder.
                                Unless you are adjusting a stop on the press linkage which changes how far the handle moves the ram, you can not adjust a press to cam-over or not cam-over.

                                not to drive this thread too off topic - I though I knew what cam-over meant but after this thread and the subsequent couple of hours that I spend reading different post on multiple different forums, checking a couple of books and falling into the youtube vortex I can't find a definitive answer... though I think I came close with a 10 year old post by Guffey on a differnt forum

                                could someone give a clear and concise answer as to what exactly cam-over is

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1