Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Reloading Issues - Large Chamber, Freebore

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Hinnerk
    Senior Member
    • May 2015
    • 779

    Reloading Issues - Large Chamber, Freebore

    I have been loading rounds for an Arisaka Type 99 (7.7x58 Jap) that has presented a couple of problems/issues. Firstly, the chamber in this rifle is quite broad. A fully expanded case has at least 5% additional capacity (measured as contained water) compared with a FL resized case before firing. Secondly, a bullet (.312 Hornady RN, in this instance) pushed into the lands from a modified case is so far forward that it cannot be retained by the neck of the case. Thirdly, and probably as a result of issues two and one, many cases fail to obturate the chamber and are dirty after firing, all the way back to the case head (and beyond). Usually, these cases have .335" neck ODs after firing while fully expanded cases have .344" neck ODs. Furthermore, when the case expands radially to fill the broad chamber, there is a tendency for the shoulder to pull back slightly.

    To deal with issue #2, I have tried using a heavy crimp with these cannelured projectiles, reasoning that this will retain the bullet a bit longer and allow more pressure to build before leaving the case. To some extent, this has helped reduce the instance of dirty cases and gas blow back. My last set of loads were about 50:50, as shown on the attached plots. Shown are plots of the .375 datum to head distance after firing versus before firing. The points are color coded according to whether the cases were dirty or not and whether the neck had fully expanded or not. Any point below the diagonal line had reduced datum to head distance after firing while any point above the diagonal had increased datum to head distance. 1.936" seems to be the maximum distance between the .375 datum and the bolt face. Cases with that dimension just begin to exert resistance to bolt closure.

    OK, so now comes the real dilemma, how to bump that shoulder back and minimize overworking the brass (from repeated FL resizing and radial expansion). I know that dies are made to do that but I know of none for the 7.7x58. In any case, a special die is probably not worth the cost when the excessive freebore issue remains and the failure to obturate issue probably (?) more related to that than case headspace.

    So, for those of you with more experience than I (which should be just about everyone):

    Have you had similar issues with rifles having excessive freebore or chamber width?

    How have you dealt with it?

    Any other comments you wish to make?
    Attached Files
  • #2
    pacrat
    I need a LIFE!!
    • May 2014
    • 10287

    It is a 70 plus year old Mil-Surp. Humongous chambers are the norm. As are copious amounts of freebore.

    Applying reloading techniques suitable for modern commercial bolt guns. In most cases just don't work.

    Learn to enjoy it for what it is. Accept the limitations, then go have fun.

    You have 2 choices for reloading for this old thumper.

    You can spend twice the amount of money the rifle is worth, on special custom made dies that match your crappy chamber. And still have a 70 yr old mil-surp that shoots like a 70 yr old mil-surp.

    Or you can "partial neck" size your cases. Using a standard FL die. Leaving them as close to chamber dimensions as possible. To extend case life and keep them from rattling around in the chamber like a BB in a box car. Forget about all the "bump the shoulder X number of thousandths" for whatever reason BS.

    JM2c


    EDIT

    Usually, these cases have .335" neck ODs after firing while fully expanded cases have .344" neck ODs. Furthermore, when the case expands radially to fill the broad chamber, there is a tendency for the shoulder to pull back slightly.

    Rereading your post. I'm a bit confused as to what you mean. Neck OD of 7.7 Jap ammo is .337".

    How can they shrink to .335", "after firing"? Do you mean OD "after sizing"?

    What does your expander button measure as?

    And what is meant by "fully expanded"? Is that the actual after firing OD of the neck?

    The .344" OD after firing in a generous milsurp camber is not an unreasonable expectation.
    Last edited by pacrat; 03-24-2016, 2:48 PM.

    Comment

    • #3
      opos
      In Memoriam
      • Oct 2009
      • 1597

      I have a 1917 Eddystone Enfield with the often found loose chamber..I got a set of Lee collet neck sizing dies and trim the first time I neck size..then keep an eye on trimming and just neck size each time...It's not a super tack driver but as said...it's an old milsurp and I'm content with what it does...and I don't bump shoulders, etc...I inspect the cases carefully..any issues and out they go..I get about 4-5 loads with the brass and perhaps could get more but I just don't push it...I shoot 180 grain bullets and they would probably shoot better if I loaded them long but I don't...they are accurate enough for my needs.

      Got a similar situation with a 7x57 Mauser...they were chambered for a long round nose cartridge...I neck size as above and don't get to concerned about setting the bullet close to the lands...it shoots fine (as good as I can shoot it)
      God and the Constitution give me my rights and actions...any other input is just blabbering.

      Comment

      • #4
        Hinnerk
        Senior Member
        • May 2015
        • 779

        Originally posted by opos
        ...I neck size as above and don't get to concerned about setting the bullet close to the lands...it shoots fine (as good as I can shoot it)
        Yeah, I'm not trying to seat the bullets close to the lands (not even possible in this case). I just seat these bullets to the cannelure and hope that I don't get too much residue blowing back at my face from cases not sealing the chamber.

        I am on the 4th loading on this particular batch of PPU brass. First two loads were after FL sizing in a Lee die and last two loads were after neck sizing with an RCBS die.

        At 50 yds I don't notice any difference in precision between the rounds where the chamber sealed and where it did not but I would think that should have an impact on muzzle velocity.

        Comment

        • #5
          Hinnerk
          Senior Member
          • May 2015
          • 779

          Originally posted by pacrat
          ...

          Rereading your post. I'm a bit confused as to what you mean. Neck OD of 7.7 Jap ammo is .337".

          How can they shrink to .335", "after firing"? Do you mean OD "after sizing"?
          No, these measurements were made on the fired cases. Perhaps it was from neck tension but I am not sure that it ever measured .337 before firing, with these components. In any case, it is clear that in those instances, the gas from the burning powder is getting to the outside of the case and at some point there should be no difference in pressure from inside the neck to outside the neck. I am imagining that when the bullet can no longer plug up the case neck and if the pressure inside the neck, when that happens, is still below the yield strength of the brass, it never expands to seal the chamber.

          Originally posted by pacrat
          What does your expander button measure as?
          I will have to measure it. I did polish it when I purchased the die.

          Originally posted by pacrat
          And what is meant by "fully expanded"? Is that the actual after firing OD of the neck?
          By 'fully expanded' I mean that the neck appears to have expanded to the largest diameter observed with this brass and this rifle. These are usually the clean cases that have apparently sealed up the chamber when fired.

          Originally posted by pacrat
          The .344" OD after firing in a generous milsurp camber is not an unreasonable expectation.
          Yes, I agree that it sounds like a reasonably 'normal' expansion.

          Comment

          Working...
          UA-8071174-1