Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Bullet Length

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • arrowshooter
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2013
    • 724

    Bullet Length

    Hi Everyone. I have a question as it pertains to small differentials in bullet length and pressure. Let me start by saying that I have been reloading rifle for about 3 years, but I have just started loading for .45 ACP. After I worked up the final ladder for my SR45 I ended up as follows with no issues:

    230gr Hornady RNFMJ
    6gr Unique
    CCI 300 LPP
    CBC brass
    COAL 1.26
    .469 crimp
    790 fps

    At this point I did 100 rounds with this same formula (and I measure each drop) but switched to the Xtreme 230gr plated RN (should'a started over). When I shot these rounds (not through my crony) I noticed a slightly weaker ejection which sometimes left the last case sitting on the magazine and black burn/soot on 1/2 of the outside of the cases, which has brought me to my question. The Hornady bullets are .004" longer than the Xtreme bullets. Given the same COAL is that differential enough to make that big of a change in pressure to cause this issue? I am thinking that I need to either lower the COAL the .004"+, or increase the charge to 6.2gr, but thought I would ask first. Thanks!
  • #2
    Par5In2
    Member
    • Aug 2015
    • 486

    Originally posted by arrowshooter
    Hi Everyone. I have a question as it pertains to small differentials in bullet length and pressure. Let me start by saying that I have been reloading rifle for about 3 years, but I have just started loading for .45 ACP. After I worked up the final ladder for my SR45 I ended up as follows with no issues:

    230gr Hornady RNFMJ
    6gr Unique
    CCI 300 LPP
    CBC brass
    COAL 1.26
    .469 crimp
    790 fps

    At this point I did 100 rounds with this same formula (and I measure each drop) but switched to the Xtreme 230gr plated RN (should'a started over). When I shot these rounds (not through my crony) I noticed a slightly weaker ejection which sometimes left the last case sitting on the magazine and black burn/soot on 1/2 of the outside of the cases, which has brought me to my question. The Hornady bullets are .004" longer than the Xtreme bullets. Given the same COAL is that differential enough to make that big of a change in pressure to cause this issue? I am thinking that I need to either lower the COAL the .004"+, or increase the charge to 6.2gr, but thought I would ask first. Thanks!
    .004 wouldn't be cause for concern. You're okay with that number in variation. I'd say you need to get the cron up and see what it's pushing. I don't know what the SAMMI max is, and where you're at with it, but .2 isn't going to hurt you, esp loading .45.
    Originally posted by pacrat
    What part of Cuba are you located in, Havana? Or closer to Guantanamo?

    Comment

    • #3
      h.charlie
      Member
      • Feb 2014
      • 497

      Lower pressure from a softer bullet/smaller diameter

      Comment

      • #4
        arrowshooter
        Senior Member
        • Aug 2013
        • 724

        Speer has it at 5.5 - 6.5 so I'll go .2 up to .5 and go back out and run those with the 6.0 through the chrono and see what I get. Thanks guys!

        Comment

        • #5
          mmesa005
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2013
          • 874

          I have only loaded my 45's with Bullseye and WST though I have read Unique is another good choice. With that I did run into similar issues with a Sig that I had to send back to the factory to fix. Note the second link with a similar issue with a Ruger.

          Have you done a "Drop Test" between factory ammo and your reloads just to confirm you were not having chambering issues?

          Has anyone reloaded for an SR45?? I can't get it to eject rounds with HP-38 without exceeding max loads? either with 230gr lrn or 200gr plated rn. Any advice? Ejects factory ammo no problem.


          Also see here http://rugerforum.net/ruger-pistols/...on-issues.html
          Regards,
          mmesa005
          Lifetime NRA Member

          Comment

          • #6
            arrowshooter
            Senior Member
            • Aug 2013
            • 724

            Drop test was good and just reconfirmed. I am fairly certain I am experiencing a low pressure issue simply based on the amount of soot on the outside of the fired cases. I already have another ladder loaded up to the 6.5gr that Speer recommends and I will shoot that through the chrony along with the 6.0 load and another batch of the Hornady load. Gotta wait till next weekend though since local range is having a trap shoot this weekend. Kicking myself in the a** for not retesting with the Xtreme bullets. Still alive and learning.

            Comment

            • #7
              mmesa005
              Senior Member
              • Jan 2013
              • 874

              I am also a member of the S&W forum and found this thread on favorite loads: Seems at 6.5gr your at the top of the load charts so be careful!

              The Lyman 49th edition listed the starting load of Unique with 230gr as 5.9gr with a Max Load of 6.5gr.

              I have been loading 230g FMJ, 230g HP, and 200 HP loads with Bullseye for years. I am interested in duplicating factory performance of non- +P ammunition. But lately it has occurred to me that not only does Bullseye become more energenic when the ambient temperature rises, but recoil is...


              Note the dialog about the powder being dirty but a favorite.
              Regards,
              mmesa005
              Lifetime NRA Member

              Comment

              • #8
                ar15barrels
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jan 2006
                • 57202

                Quickload says they should be very similar.
                Perhaps there is something else that is not being account for here...

                Code:
                Cartridge          : .45 Auto (ACP) (SAAMI)
                Bullet             : .451, 230, Hornady FMJ-RN ENC 45177
                Useable Case Capaci: 13.312 grain H2O = 0.864 cm³
                Cartridge O.A.L. L6: 1.260 inch = 32.00 mm
                Barrel Length      : 5.0 inch = 127.0 mm
                Powder             : Alliant UNIQUE
                
                Predicted data by increasing and decreasing the given charge,
                incremented in steps of 1.666% of nominal charge.
                CAUTION: Figures exceed maximum and minimum recommended loads !
                
                Step    Fill. Charge   Vel.  Energy   Pmax   Pmuz  Prop.Burnt B_Time
                 %       %    Grains   fps   ft.lbs    psi    psi      %        ms
                
                -16.7   63     5.00    776     308   12850   2390     89.9    0.825
                -15.0   65     5.10    789     318   13337   2450     90.6    0.811
                -13.3   66     5.20    802     329   13837   2509     91.3    0.798
                -11.7   67     5.30    815     340   14350   2567     91.9    0.784
                -10.0   68     5.40    828     350   14876   2625     92.6    0.772
                -08.3   70     5.50    841     361   15416   2682     93.2    0.759
                -06.7   71     5.60    854     372   15969   2739     93.7    0.747
                -05.0   72     5.70    867     383   16535   2795     94.3    0.735
                -03.3   73     5.80    879     395   17116   2851     94.8    0.724
                -01.7   75     5.90    892     406   17711   2905     95.2    0.713
                +00.0   76     6.00    904     417   18320   2959     95.7    0.702  ! Near Maximum !
                +01.7   77     6.10    916     429   18944   3012     96.1    0.692  ! Near Maximum !
                +03.3   78     6.20    928     440   19583   3064     96.5    0.682  ! Near Maximum !
                +05.0   80     6.30    941     452   20237   3115     96.9    0.672  ! Near Maximum !
                +06.7   81     6.40    953     464   20906   3166     97.3    0.662  !DANGEROUS LOAD-DO NOT USE!
                +08.3   82     6.50    965     475   21590   3215     97.6    0.653  !DANGEROUS LOAD-DO NOT USE!
                
                Results caused by ± 10% powder lot-to-lot burning rate variation using nominal charge
                Data for burning rate increased by 10% relative to nominal value:
                +Ba     76     6.00    946     457   21283   2979     99.3    0.661  !DANGEROUS LOAD-DO NOT USE!
                Data for burning rate decreased by 10% relative to nominal value:
                -Ba     76     6.00    850     369   15452   2826     89.1    0.753
                Code:
                Cartridge          : .45 Auto (ACP) (SAAMI)
                Bullet             : .451, 230, RN Rainier
                Useable Case Capaci: 13.032 grain H2O = 0.846 cm³
                Cartridge O.A.L. L6: 1.260 inch = 32.00 mm
                Barrel Length      : 5.0 inch = 127.0 mm
                Powder             : Alliant UNIQUE
                
                Predicted data by increasing and decreasing the given charge,
                incremented in steps of 1.666% of nominal charge.
                CAUTION: Figures exceed maximum and minimum recommended loads !
                
                Step    Fill. Charge   Vel.  Energy   Pmax   Pmuz  Prop.Burnt B_Time
                 %       %    Grains   fps   ft.lbs    psi    psi      %        ms
                
                -16.7   65     5.00    773     305   11996   2364     89.0    0.858
                -15.0   66     5.10    786     316   12489   2425     89.8    0.841
                -13.3   67     5.20    799     326   12995   2485     90.5    0.824
                -11.7   68     5.30    813     337   13515   2545     91.2    0.808
                -10.0   70     5.40    826     348   14049   2604     91.9    0.793
                -08.3   71     5.50    839     359   14597   2663     92.5    0.778
                -06.7   72     5.60    851     370   15160   2720     93.1    0.764
                -05.0   74     5.70    864     381   15737   2778     93.7    0.750
                -03.3   75     5.80    877     393   16328   2834     94.2    0.737
                -01.7   76     5.90    890     404   16935   2890     94.8    0.724
                +00.0   78     6.00    902     416   17557   2944     95.3    0.711
                +01.7   79     6.10    915     427   18194   2998     95.7    0.699  ! Near Maximum !
                +03.3   80     6.20    927     439   18846   3051     96.2    0.688  ! Near Maximum !
                +05.0   81     6.30    939     451   19515   3103     96.6    0.676  ! Near Maximum !
                +06.7   83     6.40    952     462   20200   3155     97.0    0.665  ! Near Maximum !
                +08.3   84     6.50    964     474   20901   3205     97.3    0.655  !DANGEROUS LOAD-DO NOT USE!
                
                Results caused by ± 10% powder lot-to-lot burning rate variation using nominal charge
                Data for burning rate increased by 10% relative to nominal value:
                +Ba     78     6.00    946     457   20651   2972     99.1    0.661  !DANGEROUS LOAD-DO NOT USE!
                Data for burning rate decreased by 10% relative to nominal value:
                -Ba     78     6.00    847     366   14557   2801     88.3    0.776
                Last edited by ar15barrels; 01-08-2016, 8:05 PM.
                Randall Rausch

                AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                Comment

                • #9
                  arrowshooter
                  Senior Member
                  • Aug 2013
                  • 724

                  Cool charts AR15 thanks! Even though gun is rated for +P+ I'll watch out after 1st shot at the top Loads.

                  As for something else, these are the differentials I found with the calipers while making up the new Loads:

                  .004" diff in bullet length, Xtreme shorter
                  Hornady diameter is .451 vs Xtreme .452
                  Hornady bullet diameter at top of case was .002" greater than the Xtreme
                  Crimp on the Hornady is .469 but the Xtreme was .4705 with the same setting.
                  Last edited by arrowshooter; 01-08-2016, 10:35 PM.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  UA-8071174-1