Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Magnification Overkill?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • williamcm
    Senior Member
    • Jul 2013
    • 529

    Magnification Overkill?

    Is there such thing as magnification overkill for a scope of different calibers and different barrel length? Or is it more of a sight picture and aperture preference?

    Example: Would anything over 16x be useless/not necessary on a 14.5" barrel in 5.56, or any .22 caliber rifle?

    I know this is a total scope newb question, but if it saves me some money/time on the next scope I purchase, I'll take it.
  • #2
    MaHoTex
    Calguns Addict
    • Jul 2010
    • 5002

    No such thing. Magnification and clarity for the win!
    NRA Life Member

    sigpic

    Mr. President, I can't take any more winning! Make it stop Mr. President. The winning is YUGGEEEE!

    "If you've got a problem with the US, you better make sure it's not a military problem." SSgt Leslie Edwards

    Comment

    • #3
      ElvenSoul
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Apr 2008
      • 17431

      Well if your hunting and the lowest your scope starts is 8x and the game is 15 to 20yds away it can be a pain. As I understand it you just sight in one of the fleas on the animals hide and shoot!
      sigpic

      Comment

      • #4
        jdouglas
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2011
        • 1101

        For bench shooting where precision and group size are of the highest importance more magnification is usually better (assuming it isn't at the expense of quality optics). Or at least I personally find it more enjoyable (you can see the holes in the paper if the target is close enough, without having to use a spotting scope).

        For actual "in the field" use (tactical, hunting, etc), less is usually more.
        WARNING: THE ABOVE POST MAY CONTAIN EXCESSIVE USE OF SARCASM.

        sigpic
        Are you a member?

        Comment

        • #5
          williamcm
          Senior Member
          • Jul 2013
          • 529

          Originally posted by ElvenSoul
          Well if your hunting and the lowest your scope starts is 8x and the game is 15 to 20yds away it can be a pain. As I understand it you just sight in one of the fleas on the animals hide and shoot!
          Oh yeah. I get that close range situation. i just wondered if putting a 20x on a rifle that has a range of 200 yards was pointless. I guess I can answer my own question after being reminded of the video I saw where a guy was hitting targets at like 600yds with his .22lr.

          It's just good to hear other's thoughts before I make a purchase.

          Comment

          • #6
            kayaker
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2009
            • 1011

            My hunting rifles have 2-7 and 3-9 scopes. That's plenty for big game hunting, I actually prefer the 2-7 scope because it's lighter and smaller. I've yet to shoot an animal with my scope turned all the way up.

            Comment

            • #7
              williamcm
              Senior Member
              • Jul 2013
              • 529

              Originally posted by jdouglas
              For bench shooting where precision and group size are of the highest importance more magnification is usually better (assuming it isn't at the expense of quality optics). Or at least I personally find it more enjoyable (you can see the holes in the paper if the target is close enough, without having to use a spotting scope).

              For actual "in the field" use (tactical, hunting, etc), less is usually more.
              I want to stick to real world situations; hunting, defense, etc. Until I get a real job and can afford such nice bench toys, I'll enjoy my range time trying to master what I have. I actually think I'm addicted to Angeles Range.

              Comment

              • #8
                Merc1138
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Feb 2009
                • 19742

                Depends entirely on what you're using the rifle for, and whether or not something like field of view, or exit pupil matters to you.

                If you ignore everything else like the quality of the glass in the optic, turrets, and whatever other features and just look at magnification, you probably wouldn't want to use a 36x scope for hunting. You probably wouldn't even want to use it in a situation where you need to move and then re-acquire the target since not only is the field of view limited, but the exit pupil is going to be a pinhole.

                On the flip side, just because you could get away with 3x magnification at 1000+ yards, doesn't mean you'd want to if you can get more magnification than that(there are people who can do it with irons, but I'm talking about people without superhuman eyesight). So 10x or 20x magnification might be something to consider.

                You need to get what fits your actual use. If you think 16x is possibly useless, then the March 8-80x56 would be incomprehensible. Yet someone out there can probably make very good use of such a scope. BTW, it's not necessarily a matter of your barrel length, cartridge, or distance either. It really does come down to exactly what you intend to do with it.

                Comment

                • #9
                  JMP
                  Internet Warrior
                  CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                  • Feb 2012
                  • 17056

                  Originally posted by williamcm
                  Example: Would anything over 16x be useless/not necessary on a 14.5" barrel in 5.56, or any .22 caliber rifle?

                  I know this is a total scope newb question, but if it saves me some money/time on the next scope I purchase, I'll take it.
                  You are using a 14.5" SBR? Newb or LEO?

                  Yes, you have magnification overkill. Too much magnification gives you too much mirage at further distances. On the other hand, it may not allow your to spot your hit at medium distances. Tons of magnification is great up close on paper where you aren't concerned with sporting your hits or mirage.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    williamcm
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2013
                    • 529

                    Originally posted by Merc1138
                    Depends entirely on what you're using the rifle for, and whether or not something like field of view, or exit pupil matters to you.

                    If you ignore everything else like the quality of the glass in the optic, turrets, and whatever other features and just look at magnification, you probably wouldn't want to use a 36x scope for hunting. You probably wouldn't even want to use it in a situation where you need to move and then re-acquire the target since not only is the field of view limited, but the exit pupil is going to be a pinhole.

                    On the flip side, just because you could get away with 3x magnification at 1000+ yards, doesn't mean you'd want to if you can get more magnification than that(there are people who can do it with irons, but I'm talking about people without superhuman eyesight). So 10x or 20x magnification might be something to consider.

                    You need to get what fits your actual use. If you think 16x is possibly useless, then the March 8-80x56 would be incomprehensible. Yet someone out there can probably make very good use of such a scope. BTW, it's not necessarily a matter of your barrel length, cartridge, or distance either. It really does come down to exactly what you intend to do with it.
                    Excellent points thanks. I just want to stay good and effective/practical. If I could sum it up, I want to stay "minute of rabbit" lethality with my .22 and "minute of deer" with my rifle. I still have plenty of fun with anything I have at the range so long as I'm not throwing rocks.

                    Edit: But I was grounded from playing with sticks as a kid so who knows?

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      russ69
                      Calguns Addict
                      • Nov 2009
                      • 9348

                      I'll play the devils advocate. A high power scope doesn't make your gun more accurate nor does it make you a better shooter. There are practical limits for every use. I have many high power scopes but I wouldn't feel I was at a handicap if I only had a 10 power on most of my guns. This might be against the current wisdom where guys have 45 power scopes but it's not my thing to have "overdrive" scopes.
                      sigpic

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Merc1138
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 19742

                        Originally posted by williamcm
                        Excellent points thanks. I just want to stay good and effective/practical. If I could sum it up, I want to stay "minute of rabbit" lethality with my .22 and "minute of deer" with my rifle. I still have plenty of fun with anything I have at the range so long as I'm not throwing rocks.
                        So go with 3-9 or 2-7. You'll have a decent field of view on the low end, and can still crank the magnification up to a reasonable amount if you need to. There's even 1-8x these days if you want, or if you still want a little magnification on the low end and don't mind paying through the nose US optics has a 3-17(if I remember right).

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          williamcm
                          Senior Member
                          • Jul 2013
                          • 529

                          Originally posted by JMP
                          You are using a 14.5" SBR? Newb or LEO?

                          Yes, you have magnification overkill. Too much magnification gives you too much mirage at further distances. On the other hand, it may not allow your to spot your hit at medium distances. Tons of magnification is great up close on paper where you aren't concerned with sporting your hits or mirage.
                          14.5, no. Just using an extreme example. Thanks for looking out though.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            williamcm
                            Senior Member
                            • Jul 2013
                            • 529

                            Originally posted by Merc1138
                            So go with 3-9 or 2-7. You'll have a decent field of view on the low end, and can still crank the magnification up to a reasonable amount if you need to. There's even 1-8x these days if you want, or if you still want a little magnification on the low end and don't mind paying through the nose US optics has a 3-17(if I remember right).
                            I really like the PA 1-6x I'm having to sell. The 1x was really true and great sight picture, while even my newly shooting girlfriend could hit the 400yd steel 3 out of 5 rounds.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              Vlad 11
                              Veteran Member
                              • Nov 2009
                              • 2961

                              Magnification Overkill

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1