Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Hypothetically Speaking......

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Vikingdad
    Junior Member
    • Apr 2012
    • 66

    Hypothetically Speaking......

    I have been trying to figure out what these proposed new laws might mean for me and how would one best address them, hypothetically speaking. As I understand it the bullet button issue would make all guns with a bullet button illegal, so then those guns would then have to be turned in or sold out of state. But would a person be in just as much trouble for removing the bullet button and restoring it to the normal mag release as they would be for having the bullet button?

    This thread is for all of these sorts of hypotheticals. Do not post anything advocating breaking any laws.
  • #2
    stix213
    AKA: Joe Censored
    CGN Contributor - Lifetime
    • Apr 2009
    • 19002

    Please stop asking these questions while there is still time for the legislature to modify the bills.

    Also, there is no bill before the legislature that requires turn in or sale of any guns.

    Comment

    • #3
      CaliforniaLiberal
      #1 Bull Goose Loony
      CGN Contributor - Lifetime
      • Jan 2008
      • 4690

      Originally posted by Vikingdad
      I have been trying to figure out what these proposed new laws might mean for me and how would one best address them, hypothetically speaking. As I understand it the bullet button issue would make all guns with a bullet button illegal, so then those guns would then have to be turned in or sold out of state. But would a person be in just as much trouble for removing the bullet button and restoring it to the normal mag release as they would be for having the bullet button?

      This thread is for all of these sorts of hypotheticals. Do not post anything advocating breaking any laws.

      All the Bills are still in process and might be amended before they are finished. It's hard enough to figure out what the bills mean once they are signed into law, a waste of time to figure out what they hypothetically will mean before a final vote.

      When you are researching these bills, double check that you are looking at the latest amended version.
      Better Way to Search CalGuns - https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=0...78:pzxbzjzh1zk
      CA Bill Search - https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
      California Rifle and Pistol Association - http://crpa.org/
      Sacramento County Sheriff Concealed Carry Info - Search 'Concealed Weapons Permit Information Sacramento'
      Second Amendment Foundation - http://www.saf.org
      Animated US Map Showing Progress of Concealed Carry Laws 1986 to 2021 http://www.gun-nuttery.com/rtc.php

      Comment

      • #4
        Kelster1574
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2008
        • 1053

        Turning over guns.............we don't even have enough law enforcement officers to patrol out streets, let alone to go door to door to enforce that one......maybe make it illegal to purchase, but like has been said many, many times and not only in this thread....we still have time to make a difference
        www.thekelster.com



        Comment

        • #5
          big jim
          Member
          • Sep 2011
          • 339

          Originally posted by Kelster1574
          Turning over guns.............we don't even have enough law enforcement officers to patrol out streets, let alone to go door to door to enforce that one......maybe make it illegal to purchase, but like has been said many, many times and not only in this thread....we still have time to make a difference
          That's what they are using our dros funds for
          Winning is half the battle. The other half? Why red and blue lasers of course

          Comment

          • #6
            Vikingdad
            Junior Member
            • Apr 2012
            • 66

            Originally posted by CaliforniaLiberal
            All the Bills are still in process and might be amended before they are finished. It's hard enough to figure out what the bills mean once they are signed into law, a waste of time to figure out what they hypothetically will mean before a final vote.
            I would better be able to discuss the subject with people who would be inclined to support these bills out of hand if I am better able to give them an example of why these proposals are a bad idea. For example, if there were to be a retroactive ban on standard-capacity magazines with more than 10 rounds, there would not be any way to enforce it. I have gotten a few people to understand my position but I feel I would be better equipped to do a more effective job if I had a better understanding of them as they sit. Maybe, just maybe, some of the people that I educate on these things will call their representatives and tell them not to support the bill in the first place.

            I apologize if you think I am wasting my time.



            When you are researching these bills, double check that you are looking at the latest amended version.
            I try to. Thanks for the advice.

            Comment

            • #7
              Vikingdad
              Junior Member
              • Apr 2012
              • 66

              Originally posted by Kelster1574
              Turning over guns.............we don't even have enough law enforcement officers to patrol out streets, let alone to go door to door to enforce that one......maybe make it illegal to purchase, but like has been said many, many times and not only in this thread....we still have time to make a difference
              While they cannot force us to turn in our guns, they can make the guns we already own illegal and require that we get rid of them. Whether we comply or not would be the question. The fact is that bans do not work. People do not comply. We all understand that.



              In order to make a difference I would like to be better informed.

              Comment

              • #8
                Vikingdad
                Junior Member
                • Apr 2012
                • 66

                Originally posted by stix213
                Please stop asking these questions while there is still time for the legislature to modify the bills.
                That is exactly the approach I took back in 1989 and again in 1999. The result was a slew of Draconian restrictions. This time I am trying to be proactive rather than reactive after the fact thankyouverymuch.

                Also, there is no bill before the legislature that requires turn in or sale of any guns.
                Not directly.

                Comment

                • #9
                  CaliforniaLiberal
                  #1 Bull Goose Loony
                  CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                  • Jan 2008
                  • 4690

                  Originally posted by Vikingdad
                  I would better be able to discuss the subject with people who would be inclined to support these bills out of hand if I am better able to give them an example of why these proposals are a bad idea. For example, if there were to be a retroactive ban on standard-capacity magazines with more than 10 rounds, there would not be any way to enforce it. I have gotten a few people to understand my position but I feel I would be better equipped to do a more effective job if I had a better understanding of them as they sit. Maybe, just maybe, some of the people that I educate on these things will call their representatives and tell them not to support the bill in the first place.

                  I apologize if you think I am wasting my time....
                  For me, the argument that these laws make criminals out of law abiding, responsible citizens for no reason at all is a good one.

                  And imagine the millions of honest, law abiding California gun owners who don't keep up with current events, don't give a crap about the CA Legislature, who won't know that they have been made into criminals until they are shoved up against the hood of a cop car and have a screaming cop push a cop gun in their face.

                  And all because maybe, somewhere, sometime a bad guy might use a normal capacity magazine in his crime.
                  Better Way to Search CalGuns - https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=0...78:pzxbzjzh1zk
                  CA Bill Search - https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
                  California Rifle and Pistol Association - http://crpa.org/
                  Sacramento County Sheriff Concealed Carry Info - Search 'Concealed Weapons Permit Information Sacramento'
                  Second Amendment Foundation - http://www.saf.org
                  Animated US Map Showing Progress of Concealed Carry Laws 1986 to 2021 http://www.gun-nuttery.com/rtc.php

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    2nd Mass
                    Veteran Member
                    • May 2013
                    • 3212

                    Originally posted by Vikingdad
                    I have been trying to figure out what these proposed new laws might mean for me and how would one best address them, hypothetically speaking. As I understand it the bullet button issue would make all guns with a bullet button illegal, so then those guns would then have to be turned in or sold out of state. But would a person be in just as much trouble for removing the bullet button and restoring it to the normal mag release as they would be for having the bullet button?

                    This thread is for all of these sorts of hypotheticals. Do not post anything advocating breaking any laws.
                    It's best to read the legislation. There is a link in my signature. It really only takes 5 minutes to read each. You seem to be interested in SB 374 and 47. If you're in socal come out to one of the range events and I can explain it all to you. You can also PM me and I'll be happy to help break it down for you.

                    In the past the legislature has amended pending legislation because of calguns posts. Hypotheticals or not it's best not to speculate on pending legislation on a public forum.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Vikingdad
                      Junior Member
                      • Apr 2012
                      • 66

                      Originally posted by 2nd Mass
                      It's best to read the legislation. There is a link in my signature. It really only takes 5 minutes to read each. You seem to be interested in SB 374 and 47. If you're in socal come out to one of the range events and I can explain it all to you. You can also PM me and I'll be happy to help break it down for you.

                      In the past the legislature has amended pending legislation because of calguns posts. Hypotheticals or not it's best not to speculate on pending legislation on a public forum.
                      Thank you for the response. I am in Norcal (Santa Clara County).

                      I did read through your link and quite frankly I am not much more informed than before I read it, I have more questions. I honestly don't understand how our discussing it in a public forum would be bad. I do know that they do monitor these forums to get a feel for what we are thinking, but how is that a bad thing? Or am I missing something?

                      For example, in your link it says:
                      SB-396 (Hancock): Ban and confiscation of magazines that are or was at one time capable of holding more than ten rounds (including 10/30 magazines).
                      Status: 8/21 Assembly - Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file.

                      To me this means that law enforcement would be tasked with the impossible and that even the attempt to start such a confiscation would be prohibitively costly in itself as well as the legal costs that would be incurred if such a confiscation were to occur.

                      And further, your link has this:

                      SB-374 (Steinberg): Bans all semiautomatic rifles that does not have a fixed magazine, forced registration of rifles already owned.
                      Status: 8/14 Assembly - Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file.
                      Last amended 8/5 - no longer classifies rimfire rifles as assault weapons; eliminates previously added registration requirements for firearms that did not have to be registered because they were purchased before registration became law (applies to pre-1990 handguns).

                      Forced registration? At what cost? And what level of compliance? And how would this "force" be applied?

                      These are not idle questions either if one wishes to comply with the law, should it be passed in any resemblance how it is written so far.

                      Again, I stood by when standard magazines were banned, and when "assault rifles" were banned. I was told that it wouldn't happen, and it has. Now we are being told again to stand down and wait.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        CaliforniaLiberal
                        #1 Bull Goose Loony
                        CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                        • Jan 2008
                        • 4690

                        Originally posted by Vikingdad
                        Thank you for the response. I am in Norcal (Santa Clara County).

                        I did read through your link and quite frankly I am not much more informed than before I read it, I have more questions. I honestly don't understand how our discussing it in a public forum would be bad. I do know that they do monitor these forums to get a feel for what we are thinking, but how is that a bad thing? Or am I missing something?

                        For example, in your link it says:
                        SB-396 (Hancock): Ban and confiscation of magazines that are or was at one time capable of holding more than ten rounds (including 10/30 magazines).
                        Status: 8/21 Assembly - Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file.

                        To me this means that law enforcement would be tasked with the impossible and that even the attempt to start such a confiscation would be prohibitively costly in itself as well as the legal costs that would be incurred if such a confiscation were to occur.

                        And further, your link has this:

                        SB-374 (Steinberg): Bans all semiautomatic rifles that does not have a fixed magazine, forced registration of rifles already owned.
                        Status: 8/14 Assembly - Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file.
                        Last amended 8/5 - no longer classifies rimfire rifles as assault weapons; eliminates previously added registration requirements for firearms that did not have to be registered because they were purchased before registration became law (applies to pre-1990 handguns).

                        Forced registration? At what cost? And what level of compliance? And how would this "force" be applied?

                        These are not idle questions either if one wishes to comply with the law, should it be passed in any resemblance how it is written so far.

                        Again, I stood by when standard magazines were banned, and when "assault rifles" were banned. I was told that it wouldn't happen, and it has. Now we are being told again to stand down and wait.

                        I don't believe that Law Enforcement would immediately put a gun to the head of all those owning these previously legal items upon passage of the bills. No "Force" in that sense. No door to door confiscation.

                        But, it would make immediate (after the time period stated) criminals out of millions of honest, responsible, law abiding California gun owners. Unless you chose to comply, you would live your life keeping these things hidden, planning how not to get caught, living with a sword hanging over your head. A simple traffic stop or a LE investigation of a break in at your house potentially turns into a threat of prison, many thousands of dollars in legal costs and the end of your life as you know it. This is another way to apply "Force" to gun owners.


                        In the last couple of years Legislative staff have read the discussions of proposed bills on CalGuns. Astute CalGunners have pointed out loopholes and workarounds, possible points of weakness to future legal challenges in the bills. Bills in the legislative process were changed for the worse when Legislators became aware of these. This is how discussing proposed bills can be bad.
                        Better Way to Search CalGuns - https://www.google.com/cse/home?cx=0...78:pzxbzjzh1zk
                        CA Bill Search - https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
                        California Rifle and Pistol Association - http://crpa.org/
                        Sacramento County Sheriff Concealed Carry Info - Search 'Concealed Weapons Permit Information Sacramento'
                        Second Amendment Foundation - http://www.saf.org
                        Animated US Map Showing Progress of Concealed Carry Laws 1986 to 2021 http://www.gun-nuttery.com/rtc.php

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        UA-8071174-1