Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

AR Upper Assemblies: BCM vs YHM

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 1
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous template Next
  • #1
    systems
    Member
    • Jan 2012
    • 330

    AR Upper Assemblies: BCM vs YHM

    SOS TO MY FELLOW BUILDERS....

    Supporters and AR owners you guys are awesome to own an buy good rifles but this question goes out to those of you who who have built and or owned both makes of uppers at some point in time.

    Not just owners of various AR's but owner and builder/assemblers who have used both makes, whats your take on the various configurations....

    And it also applies to gun smiths who are certified that just want to help us out with there take on these two makes....

    I know I know apples, oranges, low hanging fruit anf all that. Just an out right summurized review and response. THNX!!!!!!
    Last edited by systems; 03-11-2012, 1:15 AM. Reason: duh kant spel
    Why get butt hurt over a thread, get a life instead!
    Fanboys unite and share your dislikes
    Favorite Car 1964 Galaxie XL
    Favorite Gun Marlin 336 CS
    FREE when you present a dd214 or active:
    HK Builds your parts, from flats.
    Barrel Work, threading, cutting, finishing, bluing/oxidizing and non caustic finishing.
    EXPERIMENTING with Anodizing let me know if you want to submit a test subject
    Tags: None
    • #2
      freonr22
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Dec 2008
      • 12945
      Interesting comparison. Certified by who though? What about lmt? Or jp or many others? What are you using it for? What is your goal? What is your budget? 50 yds? 500 yds? Fan boi or realist?
      sigpic
      Originally posted by dantodd
      We will win. We are right. We will never stop fighting.
      Originally posted by bwiese
      They don't believe it's possible, but then Alison didn't believe there'd be 350K - 400K OLLs in CA either.
      Originally posted by louisianagirl
      Our fate is ours alone to decide as long as we remain armed heavily enough to dictate it.

        Comment

        • #3
          systems
          Member
          • Jan 2012
          • 330
          thnx

          Originally posted by freonr22
          Interesting comparison. Certified by who though? What about lmt? Or jp or many others? What are you using it for? What is your goal? What is your budget? 50 yds? 500 yds? Fan boi or realist?
          Thanks for the input, please read the thread again, its a simple broad comparison, of the two spefic makes YHM vs BCM.
          I am not in need of one or the other, I have a few AR' in 6.8/5.56/6.5/ BUT I love HK's Marlins.

          BUT BUT Lets stay on point here; a simple broad comparison, of the two makes YHM and BCM, not an sos for DIY help.

          Certifed: organizational; for example lets say you work for AECOM or STANLEY or JACCOBS, your a DOD contractor they certify us in various ways as mechanics or assemblers at depots contracted to clean & repair small arms. My point there is proffesionals.

          thnx
          Last edited by systems; 03-11-2012, 1:31 AM. Reason: mmmm
          Why get butt hurt over a thread, get a life instead!
          Fanboys unite and share your dislikes
          Favorite Car 1964 Galaxie XL
          Favorite Gun Marlin 336 CS
          FREE when you present a dd214 or active:
          HK Builds your parts, from flats.
          Barrel Work, threading, cutting, finishing, bluing/oxidizing and non caustic finishing.
          EXPERIMENTING with Anodizing let me know if you want to submit a test subject

            Comment

            • #4
              dieselpower
              Banned
              • Jan 2009
              • 11471
              Which upper to which upper.

              Here is what you are asking...

              Ford truck against Chevy truck...which is better? Now also keep in mind in this question Ford and Chevy only have a few models... think about that question if both Ford and Chevy had HUNDREDS of different combinations that a buyer could use on the trucks and assemble themselves...and actually sold a dozen different factory made trucks.

              I think I know what you want to hear so here goes...
              BCM is mil-spec. YHM is mil-spec. BCM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. YHM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. BCM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. YHM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. BCM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. YHM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. BCM has a CAGE code. YHM has a CAGE code. BCM has sold items to the military. YHM has sold items to the military.

              hope this helps...
              Last edited by dieselpower; 03-11-2012, 9:25 AM.

                Comment

                • #5
                  systems
                  Member
                  • Jan 2012
                  • 330
                  finally

                  Originally posted by dieselpower
                  Which upper to which upper.

                  Here is what you are asking...

                  Ford truck against Chevy truck...which is better? Now also keep in mind in this question Ford and Chevy only have a few models... think about that question if both Ford and Chevy had HUNDREDS of different combinations that a buyer could use on the trucks and assemble themselves...and actually sold a dozen different factory made trucks.

                  I think I know what you want to hear so here goes...
                  BCM is mil-spec. YHM is mil-spec. BCM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. YHM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. BCM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. YHM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. BCM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. YHM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. BCM has a CAGE code. YHM has a CAGE code. BCM has sold items to the military. YHM has sold items to the military.

                  hope this helps...
                  you get it. See finally
                  Why get butt hurt over a thread, get a life instead!
                  Fanboys unite and share your dislikes
                  Favorite Car 1964 Galaxie XL
                  Favorite Gun Marlin 336 CS
                  FREE when you present a dd214 or active:
                  HK Builds your parts, from flats.
                  Barrel Work, threading, cutting, finishing, bluing/oxidizing and non caustic finishing.
                  EXPERIMENTING with Anodizing let me know if you want to submit a test subject

                    Comment

                    • #6
                      Peter.Steele
                      Calguns Addict
                      • Oct 2010
                      • 7351
                      Originally posted by systems
                      Originally posted by dieselpower
                      Which upper to which upper.

                      Here is what you are asking...

                      Ford truck against Chevy truck...which is better? Now also keep in mind in this question Ford and Chevy only have a few models... think about that question if both Ford and Chevy had HUNDREDS of different combinations that a buyer could use on the trucks and assemble themselves...and actually sold a dozen different factory made trucks.

                      I think I know what you want to hear so here goes...
                      BCM is mil-spec. YHM is mil-spec. BCM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. YHM is not truly certified as per mil-spec. BCM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. YHM has uppers that are 100% identical to military issued uppers. BCM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. YHM has uppers that are not even close to what the military issues. BCM has a CAGE code. YHM has a CAGE code. BCM has sold items to the military. YHM has sold items to the military.

                      hope this helps...
                      you get it. See finally


                      NRA Life Member

                      No posts of mine on Calguns are to be construed as legal advice, which can only be given by a lawyer.

                      sigpic

                        Comment

                        • #7
                          coltn46920
                          Senior Member
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 592
                          Is this a BCM Plug?
                          Originally posted by deadcoyote
                          I will sit by the freshwater creek that runs through my yard and laugh, wait for the bay area folks to start trickling north, then sell off my cheapie C&R collection at inflated prices. "You like my sporterized M44 mosin eh? I'll take your middle daughter and all your jewlery".
                          you just gotta know how to work these situations.
                          Originally posted by Mitch
                          "Ruger semi-auto pistols are well made, but they are ugly.Life is too short to collect ugly guns"
                          Originally posted by flyingcaveman
                          Butt-stroking is for wooden rifles

                            Comment

                            • #8
                              Seesm
                              Calguns Addict
                              • Nov 2008
                              • 7812
                              Seems like there are some questions to be answered prior to answering maybe?

                                Comment

                                Previous template Next

                                Calguns.net Statistics

                                Collapse
                                Topics: 1,861,125   Posts: 25,077,278   Members: 355,125   Active Members: 5,317
                                Welcome to our newest member, GJag.

                                What's Going On

                                Collapse

                                There are currently 3938 users online. 141 members and 3797 guests.

                                Most users ever online was 65,177 at 8:20 PM on 09-21-2024.

                                Working...
                                UA-8071174-1