Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Eotech vs Aimpoint vs ? vs Iron sights

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    m1371
    Senior Member
    • Oct 2005
    • 1118

    Originally posted by bobfried
    Take this advice:

    Buy a flat top upper if you must have optics.

    The goosenecks mounts are mediocre at best, you are basically slapping on a long piece of metal that's leveraged, great for moving rocks, not for mounting sights.

    Mounting anything on any type of railed handguard isn't a good idea. Even a quality piece like the Larue FF isn't optimal for optic mounting. Even as little as 100 yards your looking at some serious deflection and warping when you hold on the front end and it heats up after several rounds. How serious is this?

    1 MOA is 1 Minute of Angle at 100 yards which is approximate to 1.047197580733 inches. To understand what it means let's view it as something more visual. A circle is 360 degrees. 1 Degrees is 60 minutes. So a minute of angle is 1/60 of a degree. Now if you have a projactor handy with you, you'll realize that's beyond small. Your hands on a free floated fore-end will easily deflect it several MOA, that's a few inches at 100 yards. Heating up the upper with firing will create further warping between the reciever, barrel and rail, this can lead to several DEGREES of shifting. What does this mean to you? Well it means that on a GOOD free floated rail fore-end you are looking at potentially being off by several FEET at 100 yards in the appropriate conditions.

    The above upper posted by Maxicon with the plastic Samco handguards will have more than several degrees of deflection and warping when in any type of usage. Not to mention it can potentially shift by tenth of an inch in any direction, further exasperating the situation.

    It's all quite complicated and a bunch of voodoo magic, but there's a reason why the flat top upper was concieved.

    I just sat down and re-read this, and I've got to disagree with you for several reasons.

    While mounting optics on the front rail of a rifle isn't the optimal location, it can still be done if necessary.

    A free-floated rail is NOT going to heat up enough to deflect the barrel as much as you are describing.

    Just touching a free-floated forend isn't going to cause several MOA deflection either.

    It's not as drastic as you're making it out to be.

    In the case of something like the First Samco rail or SureFire's rail, something that just replaces the standard handguards, that's going to have an impact on barrel deflection. But still not nearly to the extent you're describing.

    A quality free-float tube should attach to the receiver itself, not the barrel. That's the whole point, to minimize barrel deflection (and to maximize airflow around the barrel for better cooling).

    Take a look at the ARMS #50 bi-level SIRS. It places the optic forward, above the barrel instead of mounting it to the top of the receiver. Same thing with the ARMS #39 mount, except this attaches directly to the carry handle.

    If you're firing enough rounds so fast that you manage to warp the barrel to the point where it is off by a foot at 100yds, odds are you've also managed to destroy the barrel in the process.
    Learning without thought is labor lost, thought without learning is perilous. -Foamy

    Comment

    • #17
      Ratters
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2005
      • 694

      I have both and prefer the Eotech. Ampoint charges way too much for just a single dot. I like the dot and circle reticle on the eotech. It also coowitnesses perfectly with my flip up rear sight and front post. I got the gg&g lever mount which I really like too.

      Comment

      • #18
        maxicon
        Veteran Member
        • Oct 2005
        • 4661

        Originally posted by bobfried
        Take this advice:

        Buy a flat top upper if you must have optics.

        Mounting anything on anytype of railed handguard isn't a good idea. Even a quality piece like the Larue FF isn't optimal for optic mounting. Even as little as 100 yards your looking at some serious deflection and warping when you hold on the front end and it heats up after several rounds. How serious is this?

        1 MOA is 1 Minute of Angle at 100 yards which is approximate to 1.047197580733 inches. To understand what it means let's view it as something more visual. A circle is 360 degrees. 1 Degrees is 60 minutes. So a minute of angle is 1/60 of a degree. Now if you have a projactor handy with you, you'll realize that's beyond small. Your hands on a free floated fore-end will easily deflect it several MOA, that's a few inches at 100 yards. Heating up the upper with firing will create further warping between the reciever, barrel and rail, this can lead to several DEGREES of shifting. What does this mean to you? Well it means that on a GOOD free floated rail fore-end you are looking at potentially being off by several FEET at 100 yards in the appropriate conditions.
        While it's a definitely good idea to go flattop for optics mount if possible, I also disagree with your analysis. I'll go into a bit of detail on my reasons; anyone easily bored should leave now!

        I believe either a carry handle mount or a handguard mount can be a good optics option for A2 configurations. Each has its weak spots and tradeoffs, and as long as those are understood, you can get good results.

        Originally posted by bobfried
        It's all quite complicated and a bunch of voodoo magic, but there's a reason why the flat top upper was concieved.
        I'd call it 95% physics, materials science, and tolerances. The last 5% is just some of the first 95% that we haven't identified yet.

        There are 2 basic issues with most mounts - stiffness, and mounting design and tolerances.

        If any mount is loose and wobbly, the gear mounted to it will wander. Nothing will help that except a tighter mount.

        Free-floated handguards are mounted at one end. They will deflect under pressure, depending on length and stiffness of material, and if the mounting end isn't solid, they'll move around.

        Since they're acting as levers, things mounted close to the pivot point move less than things mounted further out. If your optic is mounted near the barrel nut, then several MOA deflection at the end of the handguard will have much less effect at the barrel nut end of the handguard. Shorter tubes will also have less deflection due to less torque for a given amount of pressure.

        Assuming a quality FF handguard with a solid mount that doesn't move around, the main issue is deflection under pressure. Heat deflection is much less of an issue unless you're dumping lots of ammo in a short time, and that's not much of an MOA accuracy scenario.

        An unfloated handguard is attached at both ends, and will be constrained by the tolerances of the mount and the stiffness of the barrel. A thin barrel like the old AR pencil barrel or the SU16A will shift a good bit when pressure is put on it, while a bull barrel will be considerably stiffer and more resistant to deflection.

        Since non-FF handguards are supported at both ends, it's the barrel's stiffness and the handguard's stiffness that primarily determines the amount of flex under pressure. Assuming flexing of the handguard, the distance from the anchor positions is going to determine how much variation you're going to get - mount the optic close to the anchor point at the receiver end, and you'll get much less movement than away from the anchor points, even if both the barrel and handguard are flexing.

        Non-FF handguards that are made to replace the standard handguards are more susceptible to mount tolerances, and extra care must be taken to make sure they're tight and not shifting around. This is part of the choice made when deciding how much to spend on a handguard.

        Originally posted by bobfried
        The goosenecks mounts are mediocre at best, you are basically slapping on a long piece of metal that's leveraged, great for moving rocks, not for mounting sights.
        The real problem with good quality goosenecks is mount tolerances, as carry handle tops are not spec'ed with the tight tolerances of optics mounts. People get around that by bedding the mount to the handle. With this and a sturdy mount, you'll see very little shifting once it's sighted in, since there's nothing but the weight of the optic to apply pressure on the lever - you're not holding it or resting the rifle on it while shooting. Repeatability is the issue.

        There are cheap goosenecks that will be more of a problem, but like most optics problems, these can be avoided by application of a few dollars more.


        Now, precisely measuring the amount of handguard or mount deflection is tricky business for those of us without machine shops, but fortunately, if we mount a non-magnified optic that can be co-witnessed, we have a built-in measurement device on the gun - the sight itself.

        Assuming 100 yards (but it works at any range), the optic can be set for an absolute co-witness. This is best because the dot is right on the sight post when the iron sights are aligned.

        Once this is done, any shifts are obvious and measurable. You can shoot some rounds, dismount and remount the optic, thump it with your hand, twist the mount around, twist the handguards, lean on the barrel, etc, and line up the iron sights again to see how much it's shifted.

        With standard targets of a known size, you can estimate how much the dot has shifted from the sight post, and that will give you your approximate MOA shift.

        This is easy to do at any range session, and is a good test of any mount. It doesn't work for magnified optics, due to the lack of co-witnessing, but a few groups downrange will give the same result.


        Originally posted by bobfried
        The above upper posted by Maxicon with the plastic Samco handguards will have more than several degrees of deflection and warping when in any type of usage. Not to mention it can potentially shift by tenth of an inch in any direction, further exasperating the situation.
        Several degrees? You mean 120 inches (10 feet) at 100 yards, or 30 inches (2.5 feet) at 25 yards? You must have had a bad experience with one of these handguards. I'd be interested in hearing the details.

        Mine is mounted on a bull barrel .22 rimfire, so heat's not an issue, and barrel deflection is minimal. A slimmer barrel will have more deflection, but that's mitigated by mounting the optic close in. The materials issues are minimized by this as well, since recoil is low; add that the optic is relatively light, and is not an MOA type of optic in the first place, and it just doesn't seem to be a problem for me.

        This is a budget railed handguard, for sure, and I wouldn't recommend it for serious use or large calibers, but I'm pretty sure I'd have noticed if my POI was off by several feet from my POA. Maybe I've just been lucky. My return to zero when I dismount and remount this sight has also been very good, but I don't beat it around a lot. For my use, it's been very reliable and repeatable.


        All that said, I'm always willing to change my opinion based on data. Most of this is based on my own analysis and limited experiences, but if there's data out there showing big shifts while using optics mounted on quality handguards (like LaRue FF or KAC RAS, or even YHM), I'd be interested in seeing it.
        sigpic
        NRA Life Member

        Comment

        • #19
          m1371
          Senior Member
          • Oct 2005
          • 1118

          Real "Barney-style" example to go along with this.....

          In various military and LE units which use lasers as aiming devices, those items are usually mounted........ somewhere on the front of the railed forend. No issues with deflection there.

          When we first started getting the AN/PAQ-4's (laser aiming devices) several years ago, the mounting bracket for them attached directly to the barrel through the upper handguard. Even with the laser directly mounted to the barrel, never experienced any shots being significantly off by a drastic amount. Just a little personal experience to add to the discussion.
          Learning without thought is labor lost, thought without learning is perilous. -Foamy

          Comment

          • #20
            Aluisious
            Banned
            • Nov 2006
            • 1934

            Something about this just occured to me last night, while I was practicing with my shotgun and noticed my aiming was off if I tried to use both eyes.

            While I shoot right handed, I am left eye dominant. If I aim with the bead im my peripheral vision with two eyes, I will aim the gun left of the target.

            Would I have the same issue with an EoTech or other reflexive sight?

            Comment

            • #21
              Mute
              Calguns Addict
              • Oct 2005
              • 8609

              Originally posted by Aluisious
              Something about this just occured to me last night, while I was practicing with my shotgun and noticed my aiming was off if I tried to use both eyes.

              While I shoot right handed, I am left eye dominant. If I aim with the bead im my peripheral vision with two eyes, I will aim the gun left of the target.

              Would I have the same issue with an EoTech or other reflexive sight?
              If you shoot with both eyes open, the Eotech and Aimpoints should not give you that problem. They're supposed to be more or less parallax free.
              NRA Benefactor Life Member
              NRA Certified Pistol, Rifle, Personal Protection In The Home, Personal Protection Outside The Home Instructor, CA DOJ Certified CCW Instructor, RSO


              American Marksman Training Group
              Visit our American Marksman Facebook Page

              Comment

              • #22
                m1371
                Senior Member
                • Oct 2005
                • 1118

                Originally posted by Aluisious
                Something about this just occured to me last night, while I was practicing with my shotgun and noticed my aiming was off if I tried to use both eyes.

                While I shoot right handed, I am left eye dominant. If I aim with the bead in my peripheral vision with two eyes, I will aim the gun left of the target.

                Would I have the same issue with an EoTech or other reflexive sight?
                Even with shooting both eyes open, one of them is still going to try & establish dominance.

                If you think about how a good pair of binos works, there is usually a focusing ring for one of the eyepieces to allow you to equal out the amount of magnification between the dominant and non-dominant eye. Gives you a clearer picture to focus on.

                Your optics do not have that kind of option, so running a red dot sight on your non-dominant side is possible but not optimal.

                You've got to remember to force yourself to look at the target and focus hard on it. It'll take a bit of work, as most of us have been conditioned to focus on the front sight post. Having the reticle really close in your field of view doesn't help much, as I've found a lot of people will unconsciously revert to focusing on whatever is closest without realizing it.

                A solution to this that I've been using is to not crank up the brightness on your sight. Keep it on a medium to low setting so it doesn't overwhelm everything else in your sight picture. If it's really subdued, you'll be able to focus strongly on the target and there will be a "ghost" of a reticle or a dot for you to aim with.
                Learning without thought is labor lost, thought without learning is perilous. -Foamy

                Comment

                Working...
                UA-8071174-1