New long gun suggestion

[ACfixer]

Henry, case colored .357 with the octagon barrel. I have one in .44, it might be my favorite gun.

https://www.gunbroker.com/item/888444221

Just as an example, you can probably find it for a hundred or two less... but Henrys are hot right now on Gunbroker.

[larkja]

Henry, case colored .357 with the octagon barrel. I have one in .44, it might be my favorite gun.

https://www.gunbroker.com/item/888444221

Just as an example, you can probably find it for a hundred or two less... but Henrys are hot right now on Gunbroker.

I was looking at that one too. Pretty pricey, but in this day and age, might just have to pony up.

[ACfixer]

I was looking at that one too. Pretty pricey, but in this day and age, might just have to pony up.

You can save a few hundred on the round barrel blued model, but man their case coloring is really sweet. Here's my .44, I added the bigger loop and the Leupold of course. Henry is really making some nice stuff right now.

[larkja]

Found a couple straight for sale over on GB.

One's a steel 20", round barrel, no side loading gate for $800 - https://www.gunbroker.com/item/888467882

One's a color case hardened 20", octagon barrel, with loading gate for $1,400 - https://www.gunbroker.com/item/888444221

I have had some Winchesters, Marlins, etc. and frankly really don't like the side loading gate, so the magazine tube appeals to me a bit more. Any reason why I should spend the extra $600 and get the side loading gate? And yes, I realize it comes with both the gate and tube loader. Just not sure it's worth the extra $600.

Thanks

[Imageview]

For just a fun gun, it matters less. The Henry's have a better reputation for the side gate than the Marlin's, which are picky with how you load 357 (has to be a specific angle, you get used to it quick).

I love my remlin, but the prices on any Marlin in 357 are nuts these days. I'd hold out for a side gate personally, I like being able to top off, but your milage may vary. Definitely take a look at Skinner sights whichever you pick, I have the express with scope mount and it's by far my favorite out of the options available.

[PaperTarget]

OP, from what you described, I'd say the Lever in .357 will be the natural and best choice for now. I hope you have fun shopping for one and shooting it.

[The War Wagon]

AR, in oddball caliber - that way you can find ammo. 6.5 or 6.8SPC is where I'd be looking.

[golfish]

I'd suggest a lever gun but then there is this bolt gun in .357

https://ruger.com/products/77Series77357/models.html

[S.A.]

Timberwolf in .357 pump action, but they are pricey

[larkja]

Thanks for all the suggestions. Was going to get one of the steel versions, but then came across the silver - https://www.henryusa.com/rifles/henry-big-boy-silver/

It's a bit shiny, but I love the wood, the barrel, and everything about it. I'm usually a bit more conservative and don't go for bling, but I really like this one. I'll post pics when it's in my hands.

[plumbum]

^WINNER!
Great choice - a .357 carbine is a thing of beauty.

edit: dang, I actually stared at the link... I think I might need one of those too!

[larkja]

^^^ Thanks

[RiskyBusiness]

Definitely aim for a side loading gate. I got a remlin and looking to add a 2nd in either 357 or 44

[BigPimping]

OMG get an AUG!!!!

Yes yes yes!!!

[ar15barrels]

Turning to the community to help narrow down a purchase. Looking for a long gun as a range toy and home defense. Where I am:

Have a .357 handgun and considering a lever (Henry or Marlin) to complement. Have a bunch of .38 special plinking ammo so could go for a while. However, I have had levers before, and shooting from a bench is a bit of a pain.

Have a 16 gauge Browning A5 Sweet 16 from the '50s that has been in the family since new. Have around 300 rounds of shot and 100 slugs. This gun never gets shot but is in working condition. Pretty much a safe queen.

Considerations:
1. Do I pick up a lever in .357/.38 to go with the revolver?
2. Do I pick up another 16 gauge shotgun since I already have the ammo? Was looking at one of the new Browning 16 gauge offerings.
3. Do I pick up something like a Winchester SXP or Remington 870 in 20 gauge and start purchasing shot since it's available and not too expensive yet. If I go this route, I would purchase a bird and rifled slug barrel so I could have some fun at the range. But by the time I purchase an extra barrel, and ammo, I'll be close to the price of the 16 gauge Browning.

Presently, I have been enjoying range time with my .22LR rifles since I have the ammo and they're fun to shoot. The long gun I am looking to purchase would, probably, not get a lot of range use since I have a couple 22lr rifles.

Budget:
No more than $2,000 all-in.

Thanks

You don't mention having a 223/5.56 or 9mm carbine of any sort.
You SHOULD get an AR type 223/5.56 or even a 9mm carbine before you get another shotgun or a lever gun.
A Ruger PC9 is a more friendly setup than most featureless AR's.