Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Confiscation
Collapse
X
-
Confiscation
Ephesians 6:10Tags: None -
Citation needed. -
sigpic
"If someone has a gun and is trying to kill you, it would be reasonable to shoot back with your own gun." - Dalai Lama (Seattle Times, 05-15-2001).Comment
-
-
-
Similar but this one had a BB and half the agents. The other thread did not.Ephesians 6:10Comment
-
The question for me is WHEN did he obtain the lower? Did he obtain it after the AW cutoff, 12/31/2016? Because guess what - if he did, then he is guilty of mfg AW. Maybe he made a mistake just like the guy in the other thread. Maybe he thought he could buy a lower and build AW as long as he did it before 7/2018. If so, he was wrong.
Without knowing everything there is to know about this incident, I can't worry much about this story. I have to chalk it up to user error. Otherwise we would have thousands more of them.Last edited by SkyHawk; 04-10-2018, 9:42 AM.Comment
-
-
Well, if that was me I would have........................
What a freakin' mess this whole thing is.Comment
-
This was my initial thought.The question for me is WHEN did he obtain the lower? Did he obtain it after the AW cutoff, 12/31/2016? Because guess what - if he did, then he is guilty of mfg AW. Maybe he made a mistake just like the guy in the other thread. Maybe he thought he could buy a lower and build AW as long as he did it before 7/2018. If so, he was wrong.
Without knowing everything there is to know about this incident, I can't worry much about this story. I have to chalk it up to user error. Otherwise we would have thousands more of them."Far and away the best prize life has to offer is the chance to work hard at work worth doing." - Theodore Roosevelt
Originally posted by rmorris7556They teach you secret stuff I can't mention on line.Comment
-
Shame ...God so loved the world He gave His only Son... Believe in Him and have everlasting life.
John 3:16
NRA,,, Lifer
United Air Epic Fail Video ...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u99Q7pNAjvgComment
-
Cliff notes.
Make absolutely sure your rifle is configured correctly AND wasn't acquired after Dec 31, 2016.
This isn't a reason not to register. This is the reason you should fully understand your states gun laws if you plan to be a gun owner, especially in CA. The unfortunate thing is that it is probably hard to get good and vetted information outside of this forum.
This is merely a case of the DOJ enforcing the law. We already know they aren't on our side so we can't act surprised when someone commits a felony, even unknowingly, and the DOJ confiscates their illegal "AW". Let's just be thankful that it would appear they are just taking the rifle and not arresting and charging these individuals.Comment
-
I'm willing to bet that he did not "comply with the law".Received a newsletter yesterday from a firearms instructor i would frequent in Ca. I've heard a few people comment in different threads about similar situations.
CA DOJ's MOST RECENT OVER-STEP TRUE STORY
...
It has begun. So please think long and hard before you consider complying with the law in this instance. ...
I'm thinking that he assembled a BBAW after the cut-off date thinking that he had until July 2018 to get it done.
Lack of understanding was the culprit here."Everyone must determine for themselves what level of tyranny they are willing to tolerate.
I let my CA residency expire in 2015."Comment
-
All of this stems on just that. Post 2016 is a no no. I remember telling a guy at Turners as he said he could purchase the lower and assemble it anytime he wanted before this coming summer. SMH. But either way this is completely messed up.Originally posted by FjoldI've been married so long that I don't even look both ways when I cross the street.Nothing is so permanent as a temporary government program.
-Milton Friedman
sigpicComment
-
It's really hard to give a good response here because we do not have the benefit of the DOJ agents perspective on the events. All we have are the second-hand reports of the "good friend of the firearms instructor."
1) As to the Search Warrant issue:
The Fourth Amendment requires that all searches be reasonable and that search warrants be based on probable cause. There is no requirement that warrant be issued in order for search to be reasonable. Case law also requires that the "Probable Cause" considered for a warrant be current. The judge cannot find "Probable Cause" based on stale information. This makes it hard for the nice agents at APPS to get warrants since their primary source of data is from the AFS and is months, if not years, old (stale).2) As to the weapon being an illegal Assault Weapon:
In this case the "good friend of the firearms instructor" corresponded with DOJ and supplied a picture. Both or sources of current information.
A search conducted with consent is generally reasonable. The description in the OP's posting is consistent with a consent based search. As a diagnostic question on this point, let's ask if there was any damage to the safe when the agents made entry.
If the "good friend of the firearms instructor" had refused entry into the safe, the agents would likely have had grounds to get a warrant (based on the photo and correspondence). The "good friend of the firearms instructor" would likely have been cuffed and stuffed in the back of a police car while the agents secured the home and got the warrant. (Note: We never go away and come back with a warrant. We know the stuff will disappear in the meantime. We stay and everybody waits).
You're absolutely correct that the statutes and regs are quite confusing. That affects LEOs every bit as much as it does law-abiding private persons and those who would like to be law abiding. IMHO, that's a result of the legislative process where there has to be enough "massaging" of a bill to get enough votes to pass it.
One mistake that I see very often made by folks on this forum, is to read a statute, and then conclude that it means what they want it to mean. That's guaranteed to get you in trouble at some point. It's far better to look at a statute and to construe it as broadly as possible, and then look at it again and construe it as narrowly as possible. You then have some assurance that the actual meaning of the statute, when found by an appellate court, will lie between those two boundaries. The farther that those boundaries lie apart from each other, the more cause for concern exists over the meaning of the statute. When you do this with California's firearm laws, you often find yourself in the "flashing red light" zone.
Management level LEO's have done the same, and have generally concluded that a lot of firearms statutes are not practically enforceable because that gap is just too big. But at the same time the public pressure, and pressure from their elected governing bodies remains to conduct enforcement efforts.
As I've often pointed out in other threads, a lot of the problems with the statutes are definitional. When that is the case, it's possible to get the needed appellate court opinion from either a criminal court, or a civil court. There are many reasons why it is advantageous to the LE agencies to go through the civil court. That's one reason (and there are others) for the "seize the firearm, but don't arrest the offender" strategy.If you build a man a fire, you'll keep him warm for the evening. If you set a man on fire, you'll keep him warm for the rest of his life.Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,884
Posts: 25,177,104
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,395
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 27595 users online. 46 members and 27549 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.


Comment