Which: S&B or Winchester in 45ACP?

[timeexposure]

Was headed to SGAmmo's website to get some more Sellier & Bellot .45 ACP FMJ 230 grain rounds. For the same price, they have Winchester FMJ.
I like the S&B, but for the same price is the Winchester better? I have shot Winchester white box 9mm before, and it all fired, but seemed very smoky.
Which would you buy?

http://www.sgammo.com/product/45-auto-acp-ammo/1000-round-case-45-auto-230-grain-fmj-sellier-bellot-brass-case-ammo-sb45a

http://www.sgammo.com/product/45-auto-acp-ammo/special-purchase-1000-rounds-45-auto-230-grain-fmj-winchester-service-grade

[maggie06]

What gun? My sig220 magazines do Not like S&B ammo.

Sent from my SM-N915V using Tapatalk

[timeexposure]

What gun? My sig220 magazines do Not like S&B ammo.

Sent from my SM-N915V using Tapatalk

All my .45 pistols (including my P220) shoot S&B just fine. Even the "finicky" 1911's eat it.

[omega]

I would go with Winchester brand .45 ammo , I always choose US mfg ammo before any eastern euro ammo, especially for a M1911A1

I only use eastern european / com bloc ammo in sks, ak's, maks, toks

[Pofoo]

Both are premium brands. For the same price, or even a little more, I'll always go with American made. Old school here.

[autopro]

I prefer S&B over the Winchester white box. Never an issue in any of my 1911's, P220 or 97B. To me seems much cleaner.

[ACfixer]

Both are premium brands. For the same price, or even a little more, I'll always go with American made. Old school here.

Indeed. And that's a great price SG has on that Winchester.

[brownfeathermedic]

S +B good to go

[Irv]

S&B.

[GW]

Ah hell, whichever one is cheaper. They're both good to go. With all things equal, I like S&B because they pack in smaller boxes which makes storage easier.

[hambam105]

S&B once fired .45acp brass doesn't hold a candle to the quality of W-W 45acp once fired brass.

I will take that as a clue.

[Steponmytoes]

So both are better than any reman out there. They are also both considered lower rather than premium ammo. For me, Winchester shoots dirtier. S and B is just a tad less so I would go that way. No noticeable difference in feeding and accuracy