Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Asking the experts, does it *really* matter?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • hardlyworking
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2013
    • 1210

    Asking the experts, does it *really* matter?

    Question for the shotgun experts:

    Does it REALLY matter? We all ask, about HD shotguns, clay shotguns, hunting shotguns, SHTF shotguns, Tactical, 3-gun, etc.

    But from what I've been reading, it sounds like it just doesn't matter!

    My synthesis of reading these forums for a while now is:
    • Find a shotgun with features you like
    • Find a shotgun you can afford
    • Find the shells that do what you want to do
    • Take a class or two, get some training
    • Go practice and have fun
    • If your gun hurts you, its not fitting you right, or you are holding it wrong.

    If you want a particular brand for the cool-factor? Awesome, you'll enjoy your gun that much more. Yes you'll pay for it, but so what, its your money.

    And if you want to go super cheap? You are still blowing 3/4s of an inch of lead down range at 1200+ FPS

    So get whatever you want, that you can still afford, and work the controls until its second-nature.

    Is that about the jist of it?
  • #2
    NapalmCheese
    Calguns Addict
    • Feb 2011
    • 5963

    Some things matter.

    If you want an HD gun, pretty much anything you train with and practice with would be fine given an appropriate load. If you think you're going to be in some sort of protracted firefight you probably want to get something other than your doubles trap gun.

    If you want to get good at doubles trap you're better off not using the 18 inch pistol grip pump shotgun.

    So, yeah, it matters if you care about your intended purposes. Otherwise, if someone breaks into your house with the intention of raping you and robbing your wife I think you'd be wise to grab your custom 28 gauge Holland and Holland to defend yourself over just using harsh language. If it's self defense I'd rather have any gun with any load than no gun at all.
    Calguns.net, where everyone responding to your post is a Navy Force Delta Recon 6 Sniperator.

    Comment

    • #3
      MossbergMan
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2009
      • 1255

      Just about right!

      Looks about right to me. However I didn't understand to "bolded" statement about blowing "3/4 of an inch of lead....". Did you mean ounce? If so, I got it.
      Larry Renner
      Plus (+) P Proficiency LLC
      NRA and CA. P.O.S.T certified Pistol, Rifle, Shotgun, Tactical Instructor.
      You never rise to the occassion, you only sink to your lowest level of training" Unknown.

      Comment

      • #4
        Frito Bandido
        Senior Member
        • Dec 2012
        • 718

        Can you pull a Joe Biden and use a 28" double-barrel shotgun for home defense?

        Sure.

        Is an 18" pump gun a better option?

        I would say so.

        Discussions focus on what is most efficient... so for the sake of efficiency, it does matter. Which weapon can you get on target quicker? What if you miss and need to do a follow-up shot? What if there are multiple intruders?

        Can that 18" pump gun be used to shoot clays?

        Sure.

        Will a 24" O/U perform better?

        Probably.

        You can get lead downrange either way... but why not pick the right tool for the right job? If you need to sink a nail into some plywood, and you have a hammer and a wrench available, you pick up the hammer. Sure, you could probably get it to go in by carefully pounding away at it with a wrench, but why bother?
        Last edited by Frito Bandido; 05-10-2013, 11:52 AM.
        ~ El Frito

        Are you a Fascist and don't even realize it? Find out! https://www.idrlabs.com/8-values-political/test.php

        Comment

        • #5
          bluedsteel
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2013
          • 649

          in hd situations, some people prefer shorter barrels for manuverability (sp?), esp if u have tight hallways n limited space.

          Comment

          • #6
            Dattebayo
            Senior Member
            • Apr 2013
            • 2344

            At the end of the day a HD shotgun can break clays and a clay gun can kill people. Now as other have mentioned, the shotguns are customized to purpose so buying a purpose specific shotgun, will fulfill the role much better than just any shotgun.

            Now it is arguable that short barrels can be effective trap and skeet guns with chokes, but your sight plane is shorted so much, that it would be more difficult to land shots with. Not saying it cannot be done, it will just be tougher to do.

            A clay gun typically has a longer barrel. This makes it easier for target acquisition and help the swing with the extra weight. Also because of the longer sight radius, it takes longer for a longer barrel to swing vs a short barrel, oftenly giving more smooth swings and transitions - albeit for some winged shooting a shorter barrel is prefered for a faster swing.

            Now trying to use this gun indoors makes it much more difficult to maneuver. Not sure what kind of guns you have, but even try swinging around a full sized hunting rifle around the house, and you realize real fast that it is rather cramped.

            Now, it also depends on your defensive style. If you plan to use the shotgun to clear the house, the shorter length is better as it is easier to maneuver around corners and reduces the chance of a perpetrator grabbing your barrel and disarming you.

            If you plan to use the shotgun more as a defensive weapon to hole up in a room, a longer barrel may not effect you as much.

            Now I would say in this current economy state, purchasing multiple shotguns for different purposes may be too daunting of an investment, so I would say buy the shotgun that you would use most. If you don't ever plan to skeet or trap or want to do it just informally with some friends on occasion, getting an HD gun may be the best choice. If you plan to play the sporting clay games or hunt a lot, I would just get a decent shotgun in 26inches long barrel, and use that as a HD gun until you either can afford a better alternative or a HD barrel.

            Depending on what you want to do and what your plans for the shotgun will dictate which brand and model to purchase. Certain features are easier to implement on certain shotguns vs. others.

            Comment

            • #7
              hardlyworking
              Senior Member
              • Jan 2013
              • 1210

              Thanks for the input guys!

              I've been hemming/hawing about which gun to put my $$$ on. And I've been worried that I'm going to make a "bad" choice.

              I never seem to have the time to get to an LGS, and even if I did they are very likely not to stock (or HAVE in stock) a large variety of guns for me to shoulder and see what feels best.

              So I've made up my mind to go with the Versamax Tactical.

              Shoots anything you put in it due to the gas system, thus if we have a major earthquake in CA and the only thing I can eat after a week is ... Sea Gulls, well god damnit I'm gonna shoot some sea gulls! And if I need to switch to 00 or Brenneke slugs then I'm still good to go.

              Its got an adjustable stock, like a ball/socket that lets you cant up down right left to get a perfect fit, and spacer for LOP.

              Its got a huge loading gate (compared to other autos) for speedy loading in case I want to get into competitive shootin' or defense.

              22 inch barrel means I get better sight radius than the 18" but not as much as the 26", and its not SO LONG that I can't move it in my house.
              And its 70% of the cost of the M4 while having the "same" internals. Thus I can actually afford it.

              And, after all that justification, in the end, even thought it might not be perfect for any one task, its still going to be 12 gauges well thought out compromise = awesomesauce!

              My local FFL (800 feet away) is trying to order me up one right now :P

              Comment

              • #8
                NapalmCheese
                Calguns Addict
                • Feb 2011
                • 5963

                Awesome, you took in data and opinions and made a decision as to what's right for you, that is a wonderful thing.

                As an aside, can we discount the 'sight radius' talk? Barrel length has pretty much everything to do with balance and swing, and to some extent shot velocity. Sight radius on a properly fitted wingshooting shotgun means nothing, there is no rear sight other than your eye, and that is located by your stock.
                Calguns.net, where everyone responding to your post is a Navy Force Delta Recon 6 Sniperator.

                Comment

                • #9
                  89 Vision
                  Senior Member
                  • Sep 2010
                  • 1356

                  You're right, most of these "which" threads are useless. I have 4 pumps, and I like them all for different reasons. Of course I'll probably never ask for which gun to buy advice as I have a pretty strong opinion of my own.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Dattebayo
                    Senior Member
                    • Apr 2013
                    • 2344

                    Originally posted by hardlyworking
                    Thanks for the input guys!

                    I've been hemming/hawing about which gun to put my $$$ on. And I've been worried that I'm going to make a "bad" choice.

                    I never seem to have the time to get to an LGS, and even if I did they are very likely not to stock (or HAVE in stock) a large variety of guns for me to shoulder and see what feels best.

                    So I've made up my mind to go with the Versamax Tactical.

                    Shoots anything you put in it due to the gas system, thus if we have a major earthquake in CA and the only thing I can eat after a week is ... Sea Gulls, well god damnit I'm gonna shoot some sea gulls! And if I need to switch to 00 or Brenneke slugs then I'm still good to go.

                    Its got an adjustable stock, like a ball/socket that lets you cant up down right left to get a perfect fit, and spacer for LOP.

                    Its got a huge loading gate (compared to other autos) for speedy loading in case I want to get into competitive shootin' or defense.

                    22 inch barrel means I get better sight radius than the 18" but not as much as the 26", and its not SO LONG that I can't move it in my house.
                    And its 70% of the cost of the M4 while having the "same" internals. Thus I can actually afford it.

                    And, after all that justification, in the end, even thought it might not be perfect for any one task, its still going to be 12 gauges well thought out compromise = awesomesauce!

                    My local FFL (800 feet away) is trying to order me up one right now :P
                    Hopefully the shotgun barrel comes with some chokes. It would be a rather versatile weapon with that.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      hardlyworking
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2013
                      • 1210

                      Originally posted by Dattebayo
                      Hopefully the shotgun barrel comes with some chokes. It would be a rather versatile weapon with that.
                      It comes threaded for their "ProBore" chokes, and it comes with an Improved Cylinder and a "Tactical" choke, which ... well I don't plan on breaching doors in my own house so unless it patterns buckshot like a mofo I'll be sticking with the IC that comes with it.

                      I think I can buy all the rest, mod, full, skeet, etc. and screw em in if I ever need/want to hunt. But with 7-8 in the tube I understand I'm going to need some kind of blocker or I'll get in deep water with F&G.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        NapalmCheese
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Feb 2011
                        • 5963

                        Yuppers, you need to have a magazine plug in it limiting it to two rounds in the mag if you are going to hunt pretty much anything with it.
                        Calguns.net, where everyone responding to your post is a Navy Force Delta Recon 6 Sniperator.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Dattebayo
                          Senior Member
                          • Apr 2013
                          • 2344

                          Originally posted by hardlyworking
                          It comes threaded for their "ProBore" chokes, and it comes with an Improved Cylinder and a "Tactical" choke, which ... well I don't plan on breaching doors in my own house so unless it patterns buckshot like a mofo I'll be sticking with the IC that comes with it.

                          I think I can buy all the rest, mod, full, skeet, etc. and screw em in if I ever need/want to hunt. But with 7-8 in the tube I understand I'm going to need some kind of blocker or I'll get in deep water with F&G.
                          For your needs, I'd take a look at some Light Modified chokes as they will be perfect for skeet, HD, and 3 gun comps.

                          If you didn't want to buy a stopper, you can make one pretty easy with a dowel of wood. Just cut to length and shove it in the magazine tube.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Thefeeder
                            Calguns Addict
                            • Jun 2007
                            • 5011

                            ><

                            The problem with the net is determing who is the expert.

                            Lets try a some quick questions:

                            Does a shotgun with a front bead sight have a rear sight?

                            Define "birdshot" ?

                            What is a "good pattern" for the purpose of HD, hunting, and for breaking clays?

                            Why does a stock "cheek slap" some shooters?

                            Which has more recoil.....Low recoil 00 Buck or 1 1/8 oz Target Bird shot loads?
                            Last edited by Thefeeder; 05-11-2013, 12:32 AM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              Dattebayo
                              Senior Member
                              • Apr 2013
                              • 2344

                              Originally posted by Thefeeder
                              The problem with the net is determing who is the expert, there are a few ....but only a few that lurk this here site

                              Lets try a some quick questions:

                              Does a shotgun with a front bead sight have a rear sight?

                              Define "birdshot" ?

                              What is a "good pattern" for the purpose of HD, hunting, and for breaking clays?

                              Why does a stock "cheek slap" some shooters?
                              I am definitely a n00b with guns in general, but I am a master researcher and those questions are easily answered after a little bit of reading.

                              Front bead sights sometimes has a second bead to help line up shots, but it is not necessary to have a rear sight with a shotgun, because the shotgun should fit so when you mount it, the front bead should be on a level plane and shoot at where you point it. Also, most of the time, shotgun owners will purposely have the gun shoot high as they can get a better sight picture when swinging.

                              Birdshot are small BB's made typically of lead or steel used to shoot winged game. They often ranged from .080'' to .23" in size with the most popular skeet and trap birdshot being #7-9. Not really effective in taking any game aside from birds and clays.

                              A good pattern for HD would be all the shot from a buck shot round, landing on a man silhouette to up to 25 yards.

                              For hunting winged game and clays, a good pattern would also include having a good effective pattern. Author of Shotgun Shooting Techniques, John Brindle claims that the maximum effective killing pattern of 1-1/8 oz. of shot should not exceed 21 inches. Also for an effective pattern, majority of the shot should be more towards the center of the target point.

                              Stock cheek slap is often from improper technique of using the shotgun or the gun doesn't fit the shooter correctly. Also the Knoxx buttstocks have a reputation for doing this, as a tight and proper cheek weld is more difficult with the spring loaded buttpad. Because the stock actually moves into the buttpad, it causes many shooters to also receive the dreaded cheek slap. I have seen videos where it has been so bad that it has drawn blood.

                              I am actually unsure about the last question, but I assume the 00 buck will have more perceived recoil than birdshot. My assumption comes from the fact that buck shot weights significantly more per than even the largest bird shot, and the powder needed to drive that weight, would give more perceived recoil than target birdshot loads.

                              I could be off on some of this and if anyone that knows better, please correct me so I can learn as well .

                              Edit: I thought about the last question again and remembered that shotgun loads are made to weight, so with all things equal, target birdshot load should have as much recoil as buck shot.
                              Last edited by Dattebayo; 05-11-2013, 1:08 AM.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1