Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

HD ammo type

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Apocalypsenerd
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2009
    • 942

    HD ammo type

    So I'm doing some research on what ammo to use in my shotguns for home defense. I have a pump and a SxS. Both have 20" barrels so I am guessing I can use the same ammo in both.

    For HD should I look at the 00 Buck with 12 pellets and 1100 FPS or the 00 Buck with 9 pellets and 1250 FPS?

    My reasoning to go with the 12 pellets is that with the slower speed there is less likelihood of overpenetration and you get a wider spread.

    Thoughts? Experienced knowledge?
    Let me handle your property needs and I will donate 10% of the brokerage total commission to CG.
    Buy or sell a home.
    Property management including vacation rentals.
    We can help with loans and refi's. 10% of all commissions will be donated to CG.

    Serving the greater San Diego area.

    Aaron Ross - BRE #01865640
    CA Broker
  • #2
    Pfletch83
    Member
    • Feb 2011
    • 201

    Either load should work fine and as far as the 12 pellet load you have to figure the payload is still going at 1100 fps
    It isn't the size of your hallway howitzer,it's how you use it.

    Comment

    • #3
      mrkam
      Senior Member
      • Jun 2008
      • 636

      More pellets means more effectiveness, but the difference is sort of nitpicking. I don't know about a wider spread, as you have to aim a shotgun in close quarters pretty well anyway. As for barrel length, it generally doesn't matter. Barrel length doesn't make a load just "not work," especially in a pump or a SxS.

      Most of the time, people tend to overthink this stuff. Get any major brand 00 buck in any velocity or form, and it'll do all you need. Of course you can get fancy, and get the more expensive ones with super accurate wads, but that's up to you.

      Comment

      • #4
        -hanko
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor
        CGN Contributor
        • Jul 2002
        • 14174

        Birdshot

        I saw it on the internet.

        -hanko
        True wealth is time. Time to enjoy life.

        Life's journey is not to arrive safely in a well preserved body, but rather to slide in sideways, totally worn out, shouting "holy schit...what a ride"!!

        Heaven goes by favor. If it went by merit, you would stay out and your dog would go in. Mark Twain

        A man's soul can be judged by the way he treats his dog. Charles Doran

        Comment

        • #5
          003
          Veteran Member
          • Jul 2010
          • 3436

          I believe number 4 buckshot is the ideal round for home defense shotgun use. 27 pellets will give an excellent spread at the average home defense range. 27 pellets each .24" in size is a very effective load. 1260 FPS and each round has a total of 1890 foot pounds of energy.
          Last edited by 003; 08-21-2011, 9:57 AM.

          Comment

          • #6
            Richard Erichsen
            Senior Member
            CGN Contributor
            • Jan 2011
            • 1911

            Originally posted by Apocalypsenerd
            So I'm doing some research on what ammo to use in my shotguns for home defense. I have a pump and a SxS. Both have 20" barrels so I am guessing I can use the same ammo in both.

            For HD should I look at the 00 Buck with 12 pellets and 1100 FPS or the 00 Buck with 9 pellets and 1250 FPS?

            My reasoning to go with the 12 pellets is that with the slower speed there is less likelihood of overpenetration and you get a wider spread.

            Thoughts? Experienced knowledge?
            This topic has been exhaustively discussed as "search" will show.

            A brief summary of the topic goes something like this:

            * The type of choke doesn't really matter, even a skeet type "spreader" - if you were counting on spread, don't. Each shot must be aimed to cause a disabling wound in your opponent.

            * 5-7 yard ranges are typical for HD. The size of the pattern at 10 yards on most shotguns is about the size of a golf ball.

            * Velocity below 1300 FPS is only really important because it gives you a sense of the recoil impulse - lower recoil is generally better for HD.

            * 9 pellet 00 typically recoils less than 12 pellet at similar velocities

            * Energy determines penetration, which is both speed and mass. Lighter shot moving slower has less momentum thus less penetration.

            * #1 and #4 buckshot is probably the best HD shot available due to shot density, reduced risk of over-penetration and availability of reduced recoil shells. Harder to find than 00 buckshot however.

            * Better answers are often available on Shotgun world. This thread: http://www.shotgunworld.com/bbs/viewtopic.php?t=135074 covers several myths and misconceptions as well as citing the "Box Of Truth" where penetration claims are put to the test.

            Good luck.
            Last edited by Richard Erichsen; 08-21-2011, 9:50 AM.
            Mangler of loose parts into modernized boom sticks

            "Your breathing should be slow and steady. It should sound like HEE HEE HOOOOOOOOooooooo!!!" - CBruce

            Comment

            • #7
              voiceofreason
              Veteran Member
              • Oct 2010
              • 3785

              This is just MY opinion and I might be a pimply 13 year old that has never touched anything but airsoft so take it with a grain of salt.

              Feel free to disagree, just MY opinion.

              1.Wider spread is BAD. I feel the home defense shooter needs to be able to account for each and EVERY pellet/round.

              2. My shotguns have patterned best with Federal Tactical Reduced Recoil 00 buck. For pumps, I prefer reduced recoil; NOT for semis.

              3. I worry less about how many pellets and their velocity and more about getting them on target and potential penetration.

              4. I personally run 00 & slugs, no problem with #1 at all. #4 is a bit short on penetration for me, but I do keep a case of #4 buck in case I ever NEED a ton of ammo.

              5. Its really important to pattern your shot and see how it works with YOUR gun.

              6. The manual of arms on a shotgun is more complex than that of a handgun or rifle with limited ammunition based on weight & size of it.

              7. Put a dedicated light on it. Doesn't have to be a $200 Surefire, PM me for a $5 solution.

              8. Keep it clean lubed loaded with side saddle and buttstock saddle.

              9. Practice with it loaded up, empty and everything in between.

              10. Keep the safety on until your sights are on target and you're ready to fire.
              "You will never know how much it has cost my generation to preserve your freedom. I hope you will make good use of it."
              John Quincy Adams

              "You will never know how little my generation has traded away our freedoms and rights for. I'm sorry and ashamed for what we've left to the following generations."
              voiceofreason

              Comment

              • #8
                Richard Erichsen
                Senior Member
                CGN Contributor
                • Jan 2011
                • 1911

                1. - Agreed. The myth of the football sized vortex of destruction is popular, but just that.

                2. - You and just about everybody else, though give the Fiocchi a try.

                3. - Point 1 restated

                4. - If you are defending a ranch and need reach, slugs, but for just about any other scenario slugs are too much thump for a B.G. at 7 paces and will cruise through every wall in your house and possibly several of a nearby neighbor.

                5 - Indeed. Buy many types of 2.75" shells from different makers and see what works best in YOUR shotgun.

                6 - Ammo manipulation more so than the "manual of arms" I'd say. Clearing jams on semi-autos is about the same, loading and unloading is not. Pumps are fairly unique in the firearm world, but far from difficult.

                7 - Agree on the light, not sure about going cheap here. You often get what you pay for. I went through 3 lesser lights before springing for a quality unit. LEDs do better than incandescent.

                8 - Agreed on side saddle, buttstock is a maybe.

                9 - Agreed. Practice is the only way to become effective with any weapon.

                10 - If you train that way, yes. If you train with safety off and finger off the trigger, do that. You fight like you train. There are benefits and drawbacks to each.
                Mangler of loose parts into modernized boom sticks

                "Your breathing should be slow and steady. It should sound like HEE HEE HOOOOOOOOooooooo!!!" - CBruce

                Comment

                • #9
                  L84CABO
                  Calguns Addict
                  • Mar 2009
                  • 8796

                  Originally posted by -hanko
                  Birdshot

                  I saw it on the internet.

                  -hanko
                  +1000...and make sure you go with a pump gun...because the sound of pump being racked will scare the living hell out of the bad guy EVERY time so that you won't even need to use your birdshot.
                  "Kestryll I wanna lick your doughnut."

                  Fighter Pilot

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    voiceofreason
                    Veteran Member
                    • Oct 2010
                    • 3785

                    8- I like to keep as much ammo on my gun as possible. personal preference; I'm a fairly big guy, so weight isn't an issue for me;
                    for cheek weld issues, weight, or other things, not so good for other peeps; my friend is female and doesn't like even a side saddle on her 20 because it gets too heavy for her, so NO ammo on the outside of the gun
                    do what works for YOU

                    10- How you train and fight is up to you. I prefer to keep the safety on with single action weapons, I'm not necessarily correct, again personal pref.
                    It's your gunfight.

                    7-I agree about the quality light being the BEST choice, but I've worked with a lot of people that if given a choice between a quality fore-end for $$ vs. nothing, they'll inevitably choose nothing. My $5 solution works reliably and well. NOT as good as a Surefire/etc., but better than no light at all.

                    on 6, I agree with you
                    "You will never know how much it has cost my generation to preserve your freedom. I hope you will make good use of it."
                    John Quincy Adams

                    "You will never know how little my generation has traded away our freedoms and rights for. I'm sorry and ashamed for what we've left to the following generations."
                    voiceofreason

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      xxINKxx
                      Veteran Member
                      • Jun 2008
                      • 4289

                      How's the low recoil stuff? Call me a wimp I don't care, but 12g packs a big punch, it sucks shooting one at the range after a bit. I would imagine low recoil ammo would help with quicker follow up shots. Is it acually a noticeable difference then standard load?
                      Last edited by xxINKxx; 08-22-2011, 12:15 AM.
                      "If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so." - Thomas Jefferson

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        voiceofreason
                        Veteran Member
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 3785

                        A semi would likely not cycle correctly using low recoil ammo, but I do observe a noticeable improvement in both times and accuracy when watching people move from standard to low recoil loads. I know I do better personally.

                        Not quite 44 mag to .38 special difference, but maybe .44 mag to a hot.357. I'm not particularly recoil sensitive. I just try to go with what gets me hits on target quickly and accurately at a power level I'm comfortable with.

                        In handguns, I consistently shoot more accurately with .40 than I do with 9mm. I trained primarily with .40 for years. Don't know why, but my times and groups are better with the higher recoiling round. My groups are best with 10mm from my G20, but the times jump significantly.

                        I shoot cleaner and faster with lower recoiling long guns though. Whether in sporting rifle configuration or bolt action, I shoot .223 MUCH better than I do .308, 20 gauge better than 12.

                        20 gauge hits hard and shoots easier for me. For what I'm putting into it though, I get more value out of the 12 gauge for my time, weight, energy. I prefer at least #1 buck and it's a struggle to find #1 in 20 gauge easily in local stores whereas 00 in 12...

                        Primarily I use the Federal Tactical Low Recoil with the "Flight Control Wad" (or something to that effect) because it groups noticeably tighter in my shotguns than any other 00 load I've tried. It's a good load, as I've noticed I'm not alone in getting good groups with this load. Get a few boxes and pattern for yourself. I believe the FCW is not a gimmick and actually works. I could be wrong about the FCW, but the little dots appear closer together for me at given distances when compared to other 00 loads.

                        I've noticed that different guns like different slugs. My primary pump loves Winchester Super-X slugs, wheres my secondary likes anything BUT Win S-X. I keep slugs on the gun primarily for penetration purposes. In my house, there is almost nothing here that a slug won't go through. 00 will likely penetrate most things here as well, but I've watched only 2 pellets of a 00 load penetrate through an old couch to hit an IPSC sized target. I guessed at least 1/2 the load and I was wrong. Don't plan on doing any precision hostage rescue type shots, but I want the option of a load that doesn't spread available to me. I'm happy with slugs out to 50, but buckshot past 25 makes me kind of nervous.

                        I'd never call anyone a wimp for going low-recoil, though I'd call someone a fool for choosing a heavier recoil firearm than they can handle for the wrong reason.

                        Pick up a few boxes and pattern them against your current standard or magnum load while utilizing a timer. My money is on the low recoil stuff in terms of times.
                        Last edited by voiceofreason; 08-22-2011, 4:25 AM.
                        "You will never know how much it has cost my generation to preserve your freedom. I hope you will make good use of it."
                        John Quincy Adams

                        "You will never know how little my generation has traded away our freedoms and rights for. I'm sorry and ashamed for what we've left to the following generations."
                        voiceofreason

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          xxINKxx
                          Veteran Member
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 4289

                          Dang good post ^
                          "If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so." - Thomas Jefferson

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            AaronC11
                            Junior Member
                            • Jan 2011
                            • 73

                            My 18" barrel Remington patterns 1" for every yard. At 7 yards you'd have about a 7" spread.
                            Sig SP2022 9mm

                            M&P 9mm

                            Beretta PX4 .40

                            S&W Model 28 .357 mag

                            Remington 870

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              coyotebait
                              Senior Member
                              • Jan 2011
                              • 1319

                              Originally posted by -hanko
                              Birdshot

                              I saw it on the internet.

                              -hanko
                              Originally posted by L84CABO
                              +1000...and make sure you go with a pump gun...because the sound of pump being racked will scare the living hell out of the bad guy EVERY time so that you won't even need to use your birdshot.
                              You're killing me... Someone will pop up shortly to seriously defend those two theories.

                              OP, this get's asked just about once a month. A quick search will get you more info than you can shake a stick at.
                              R.I.P. Chris Kyle. 2/2/13

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1