Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Chokes for HD

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • xLusi0n
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2006
    • 1011

    Chokes for HD

    Most chokes I see on HD guns seem to be Improved CYL - up to modified...is that just because HD is generally shorter range and would benefit from the bigger spread than say a full choke?

    If that's the case, then why does the Vang Comp stress their tight patterns? I know theres other benefits to a VCS, but if you're only concerned about tight patterns, then wouldn't a full choke work better?
  • #2
    aippi
    Senior Member
    • Jun 2009
    • 2302

    The reason you see more I/C is simply that this is the most popular choke and manufacturers make more I/C barrels then any other for HD. It is in-between Cyl bore and Modified so it fits more of a general purpouse. It is a great choke for any shotgun that is for HD or duty.

    For HD ranges that you would find inside homes, choke just does not matter. the Remington Express HD's come with a Cyl Bore for that reason. Most 870P come with I/C

    I don't know why guys want to spend extra money on barrel and shells that give them such tight groups. They spend hundreds of dollars on the barrels and buy special type shells to get these 3 or 4" holes in a target then post their pictures on the web sights. Man, if you want that small of a hole shoot a freaking slug.

    I have modified barrels on my personal weapons as I have property and buildings to check and want a tighter pattern at longer ranges to cover any threat on my property. Inside, it just does not matter so the Modified choke does not impact my weapon if used inside my home.

    Most of the 870's I build for LEO leave my shop with the 18.5" rifle sight barrel Modifed choke or the 18.5" with Tritium bead in Modified choke. They want the patterning at greater distance and Modified is also the best with slugs.
    JD McGuire, Owner
    AI&P Tactical
    Remington Law Enforcement Armorer
    Mossberg LE Armorer
    www.aiptactical.com
    www.tacticalgunslings.com
    If you're going to a gun fight, take a shotgun. If you can't take a shotgun, don't go.

    Comment

    • #3
      xLusi0n
      Senior Member
      • Feb 2006
      • 1011

      aippi, what's your experience with full chokes? I was shooting next to a near identical gun using Winchester Ranger 00 buck except he had a VCS and we patterned nearly identical at 15 yards (mine being a full and his VCS).

      Comment

      • #4
        xLusi0n
        Senior Member
        • Feb 2006
        • 1011

        Also I shot the Winchester Ranger Foster type slugs and at 15 yards was just as accurate - the main difference was that his had a lot less recoil which I attribute to the VCS.

        Comment

        • #5
          aippi
          Senior Member
          • Jun 2009
          • 2302

          I have not used a full choke in many years. I bow hunt now so don't use firearms for hunting and a full choke is more of a hunting choke. I have used an Ex-full Turkey but that is a specialty choke.

          I would not shoot slugs out of a full choke. Modified is best as it stabilized the slug better then all the others.

          I ahve also never shot a weapon with one of Hans barrels on it. I guess I don't see the need for any of that as I use a Modified choke and recoil reducing stocks on my weapons. His system has merit and a good following but not for me.
          JD McGuire, Owner
          AI&P Tactical
          Remington Law Enforcement Armorer
          Mossberg LE Armorer
          www.aiptactical.com
          www.tacticalgunslings.com
          If you're going to a gun fight, take a shotgun. If you can't take a shotgun, don't go.

          Comment

          • #6
            Specter6A
            Junior Member
            • Oct 2005
            • 22

            Most of the guns I've seen with Vang Comp barrels will generally still keep all 9 pellets from a 00 buck load (Usually Federal H132) in the "B" zone out to 25 yards. That's usually about 10 yards further than most standard shotgun barrels. This means you've got a bit more range before you have to think about switching to slugs.

            Comment

            • #7
              dohboy
              Junior Member
              • Jan 2010
              • 77

              Originally posted by xLusi0n
              Most chokes I see on HD guns seem to be Improved CYL - up to modified...is that just because HD is generally shorter range and would benefit from the bigger spread than say a full choke?

              If that's the case, then why does the Vang Comp stress their tight patterns? I know theres other benefits to a VCS, but if you're only concerned about tight patterns, then wouldn't a full choke work better?
              I like cylinder bore for HD. In a stressful situation its harder to aim dead-on...why not have a little spread with the buckshot to compensate...isin't that ONE of the advantages of using a shotgun for HD? That you're more likely to score a hit somewhere even if you can't put 9 pellets right through the center-mass? Still need to practice, still need to aim with shotgun. But for me personally I like a looser pattern for HD.
              Last edited by dohboy; 06-09-2010, 1:08 AM.
              WTB Glock 30, converted Saiga 12

              Comment

              • #8
                tacticalcity
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Aug 2006
                • 10929

                You need to be able to control your pattern and get a nice tight group. Improved cylendar does that. Cylendar tends to put most or all of the hits around the outside of the patern, so as the distance increases you could end up aiming right at him and miss him all together as the pellets hit the ground at his feet, go over his head, and passes his arms and legs. That's a bit of an exadurating for home defense distances, and one or pellets might still make a good hit even as your distance gets out there but you get my point. In order for it to be a stopping blow you need as many pellets all center mass or in the face rather than shoulder, arm and leg and none in a vital organ. 15 yards and in, its not much of an issue as cylendar chokes still get all or most of the pellets in the body. Outside, your distance can start to increase to the point when a cylendar choke is completely ineffective in a hurry. Improved cylendar lets get a little more distance between yourself and the bad guy and is still effective before you have to switch for pellets to slugs.
                Last edited by tacticalcity; 06-09-2010, 1:14 AM.

                Comment

                • #9
                  dohboy
                  Junior Member
                  • Jan 2010
                  • 77

                  Originally posted by tacticalcity
                  You need to be able to control your pattern and get a nice tight group. Improved cylendar does that. Cylendar tends to put most or all of the hits around the outside of the patern, so as the distance increases you could end up aiming right at him and miss him all together as the pellets hit the ground at his feet, go over his head, and passes his arms and legs. That's a bit of an exadurating for home defense distances, and one or pellets might still make a good hit even as your distance gets out there but you get my point. In order for it to be a stopping blow you need as many pellets all center mass or in the face rather than shoulder, arm and leg and none in a vital organ. 15 yards and in, its not much of an issue as cylendar chokes still get all or most of the pellets in the body. Outside, your distance can start to increase to the point when a cylendar choke is completely ineffective in a hurry. Improved cylendar lets get a little more distance between yourself and the bad guy and is still effective before you have to switch for pellets to slugs.
                  Agreed. Cylinder does start to produce "donuts" as the range gets longer than typical indoor distances.
                  WTB Glock 30, converted Saiga 12

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  UA-8071174-1