Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Benelli M4 drop safe?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tdanielran
    Member
    • Aug 2015
    • 188

    Benelli M4 drop safe?

    Can you guys confirm if the safety plunger in a Benelli M4 makes the shotgun drop safe?



    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  • #2
    SkyHawk
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Sep 2012
    • 23532

    That is just a detent spring for the push button safety, it has nothing to do with a firing pin block. All that plunger does is make the safety button go ‘click’ when you push it, and keeps the button from moving when you don’t.

    I am not even sure why they call it a safety plunger when detent is a more accurate description. Don’t think of that like a glock firing pin safety plunger, it isn’t.
    Last edited by SkyHawk; 01-13-2019, 11:05 PM.
    Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

    Comment

    • #3
      tdanielran
      Member
      • Aug 2015
      • 188

      So Benelli M4s are not drop safe?

      Comment

      • #4
        SkyHawk
        I need a LIFE!!
        • Sep 2012
        • 23532

        Originally posted by tdanielran
        So Benelli M4s are not drop safe?
        That is not what I am saying - all I am saying is that the specific part you inquired about would have nothing to do with a typical drop safety feature, and should not be confused with other types of plunger safeties that do block the firing pin - usually found on handguns.

        I have not looked at the whole Benelli M4 action to see what other systems may be in place to prevent AD when dropped, but when in doubt it is generally safer to assume that most long guns are not drop safe.
        Last edited by SkyHawk; 01-14-2019, 6:56 PM.
        Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

        Comment

        • #5
          bayonet
          Member
          • Jan 2010
          • 312

          That picture is from a game called Gun Disassembly 2. Very cool game, but not always accurate.

          Comment

          • #6
            leadstorm
            Senior Member
            • Aug 2008
            • 1191

            Originally posted by tdanielran
            So Benelli M4s are not drop safe?
            To who's standard(s)?

            The Department of Defense no longer has a specification for drop-safe shotguns - they used to in MIL-S-3443G, but it was retracted in the 1990's and is inactive. The USMC does currently use the M1014 (which has the same fire control design as the civilian M4). Los Angeles Police Department has also authorized the M4 for duty use.

            Modern semi-auto shotguns have spring-loaded firing pins, as opposed to floating firing pins. You are not going to overcome that spring with inertia and have the pin hit a primer. Across the board, they're not inherently "drop safe," but as a practical matter they are "pretty-darned-drop-safe."

            Comment

            • #7
              tdanielran
              Member
              • Aug 2015
              • 188

              Originally posted by leadstorm
              To who's standard(s)?

              The Department of Defense no longer has a specification for drop-safe shotguns - they used to in MIL-S-3443G, but it was retracted in the 1990's and is inactive. The USMC does currently use the M1014 (which has the same fire control design as the civilian M4). Los Angeles Police Department has also authorized the M4 for duty use.

              Modern semi-auto shotguns have spring-loaded firing pins, as opposed to floating firing pins. You are not going to overcome that spring with inertia and have the pin hit a primer. Across the board, they're not inherently "drop safe," but as a practical matter they are "pretty-darned-drop-safe."
              So it is drop safe as an Ar-15 with a mil spec trigger?

              Comment

              • #8
                CandG
                Spent $299 for this text!
                CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                • Apr 2014
                • 16970

                Originally posted by tdanielran
                So it is drop safe as an Ar-15 with a mil spec trigger?
                AR-15's do not have spring-loaded firing pins.

                So I would say it's "at least" as drop-safe as an AR-15, but I don't know how much safer, and I'm not willing to drop-test my M4 to find out.

                It seems unlikely that the DoD would adopt a shotgun that can't be trusted not to accidentally discharge when it gets dropped, even if their specifications don't specifically call for it. But I don't know for certain one way or the other.
                Last edited by CandG; 01-14-2019, 1:39 PM.
                Settle down, folks. The new "ghost gun" regulations probably don't do what you think they do.


                Comment

                • #9
                  villabroza
                  CGN Contributor
                  • Jul 2016
                  • 160

                  [/QUOTE].....

                  It seems unlikely that the DoD would adopt a shotgun that can't be trusted not to accidentally discharge when it gets dropped, even if their specifications don't specifically call for it. But I don't know for certain one way or the other.[/QUOTE]

                  Queue the p320 or now known as the m17 😂 though not a shotgun

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    leadstorm
                    Senior Member
                    • Aug 2008
                    • 1191

                    Originally posted by tdanielran
                    So it is drop safe as an Ar-15 with a mil spec trigger?
                    An AR-15 is not drop safe. It has neither a firing block nor a spring-loaded pin. There are examples of AR-15 and M-16/4 rifles firing upon being dropped (or even upon being loaded, aka slam-firing).

                    Two things could cause a discharge in a dropped gun: the hammer disengages the sear or the firing pin has enough inertia to set the primer off.

                    Neither the AR-15 nor the M4 has a positive firing pin block, so in that sense they're roughly equivalent. M4 could be construed as a bit more safe because it does have the spring-loaded firing pin (won't fire inertially).

                    I'm not sure what sort of drop it would take to make the hammer disengage the sear for each of them...

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      tdanielran
                      Member
                      • Aug 2015
                      • 188

                      Originally posted by cockedandglocked
                      AR-15's do not have spring-loaded firing pins.

                      So I would say it's "at least" as drop-safe as an AR-15, but I don't know how much safer, and I'm not willing to drop-test my M4 to find out.

                      It seems unlikely that the DoD would adopt a shotgun that can't be trusted not to accidentally discharge when it gets dropped, even if their specifications don't specifically call for it. But I don't know for certain one way or the other.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        csshih
                        Casual Plinker
                        CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                        • Nov 2009
                        • 670

                        Everything is a calculated risk. the ar15 safety does not block the firing pin, and while unlikely for a drop to set it off, there is a chance that the free floating firing pin has enough energy to set off a sensitive primer.

                        Of course, there is also the chance that a safety will fail as well.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          CandG
                          Spent $299 for this text!
                          CGN Contributor - Lifetime
                          • Apr 2014
                          • 16970

                          Originally posted by tdanielran
                          Would it be safe to leave one in the chamber with the safety on? That’s how I keep my Ar, one round in the chamber safety on.
                          I'm hesitant to declare that anything is "safe" to do, in the off chance that someone listens to my advice and ends up injured or killed... After all, a car is certainly "more safe" if it has seatbelts and airbags, but is it "safe"? You could still die if certain things go wrong in a certain way, so I wouldn't say it's "safe", just "safer".

                          So I'll just say that I do have a shell in the chamber in mine, 24/7 - whether I'm out hunting or keeping in in the safe for home defense. The only time mine doesn't have a shell in the chamber is when I'm cleaning or working on it. Is it 100% safe? Not sure... all I know is that I feel confident in it, and in my handling of it, that I don't personally worry about it.

                          IMO, it's at least as safe as your AR kept in the same condition, maybe even more safe, and probably not less safe.
                          Last edited by CandG; 01-14-2019, 5:09 PM.
                          Settle down, folks. The new "ghost gun" regulations probably don't do what you think they do.


                          Comment

                          • #14
                            SkyHawk
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Sep 2012
                            • 23532

                            FWIW - the military adopted the M16/M4 and it has a completely free floating firing pin, hardly drop safe.

                            Originally posted by tdanielran
                            Would it be safe to leave one in the chamber with the safety on? That’s how I keep my Ar, one round in the chamber safety on.
                            See above. Also hammer spring may take a set eventually, but they are cheap and easy to change. Of course that is of little consequence if you need the gun to go bang but it just goes click because the hammer has been sitting cocked for 5 years. I keep ARs mag loaded & inserted but emtpy chamber and hammer down. The same way cops carry them. Too quick and easy to charge if needed, no need to leave sitting around with hammer cocked.

                            Originally posted by bayonet
                            That picture is from a game called Gun Disassembly 2. Very cool game, but not always accurate.
                            Yep I recognized that straight away - my son has that app

                            I then went and looked at the real schematic and parts list to make sure it was a legit representation before I replied to OP.



                            Parts 81 and 80

                            Last edited by SkyHawk; 01-15-2019, 10:58 AM.
                            Click here for my iTrader Feedback thread: https://www.calguns.net/forum/market...r-feedback-100

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            UA-8071174-1