Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Nikon Prostaff Rimfire 3-9x40mm BDC Review and Range Report (Pics of Scope Added)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Izzy43
    CGSSA Rimfire Coordinator
    • Dec 2009
    • 2670

    Nikon Prostaff Rimfire 3-9x40mm BDC Review and Range Report (Pics of Scope Added)

    So I set out today to test this scope. My objectives were to evaluate the scope in the following areas. Clarity, brightness, operation of the turrets, usefulness of the Bullet Drop Compensating (BDC) reticle, and what I like and don't like about the scope.

    Equipment and ammo. Scope mounted on my Kimber 82G, my most accurate rifle, Aguila Pistol Match (1080fps), shot from a homemade bench, Caldwell Rock BR front rest and rabbit ear rear bag.

    Environment. Temp 55 degrees, elevation, 4500ft, bright sunshine, wind was gusting 5-10mph left to right (weather guesser said calm to 2-3mph, didn't happen). Shooting area was flat.

    Set up: Placed targets at 50, 77, 99, 120 and 142yds for distance shooting. Set targets at 50 yds for initial zero and 25 and 50 yds for group testing. Set target at 50 yds for box test. (more on that later)

    Initial settings on scope were way off for 50 yds. Had the scope zeroed within 10 shots.

    Performed box test with a red dot as the aimpoint. (see photo) Moved elevation up 12 clicks (3") and took second shot, moved windage 12 clicks (3") right and took third shot, moved elevation down 12 clicks and took fourth shot, moved windage left 12 clicks and took fifth shot. The scope returned to within less than 1/4" of first shot. Very good, the 1/4" difference could have been wind, ammo or me. High marks for the box test.



    Print out of BDC reticle using the "Spot On" program at Nikonhunting.com. The reticle is calibrated for the Aquila Ammo, temp, humidity and 4500ft elevation where I shot. Note that there are points indicated on the printout that correspond to the distances that I shot. The top of the reticle in the printout is the crosshairs, the bottom is where the crosshair becomes thicker. Wish they had shown that in the printout.



    Next I shot at the various distances to evaluate the usefullness and accuracy of the "Spot On" program and reticle. Photos below show the results. Keep in mind that I was battling the wind gusts and trying to shoot when the wind was at its lowest velocity. Some targets have more than one hit but I did hit each target with the first shot. On the 142yd target I shot multiple times to see if I could hit it again. I thought I had only hit it once until I walked out to retrieve the targets. To my surprise I hit it 4 out of 5 times. Worst target is the 77 yd target which I can only blame on the wind and me.





    I then shot 2 sets of groups @ 50yds and then 2 more at 25yds. Group sizes are indicated on the photo. Before you ask, yes the lower, right 25yd group is 5 shots.



    I have never shot beyond 100yds with a .22 before today so I can't compare this with anything that I have done previously. I was pleased that the scope allowed me to hit each target on the first shot. Due to the wind conditions I am not disappointed in not hitting the center of the bullseye on each target, not really what I was trying to accomplish anyway. In any case I am fairly pleased with that 3 shot group in the center right of the 142yd target.

    What I like about this scope.
    1. The reticle and program actually work together.
    2. The scope is clear and bright with no change from 3-9X
    3. The elevation and windage adjustments are precise, no backlash and return to zero.
    4. Fit and finish is excellent
    5. Good for long distance shooting and short range target work (25-50yds)
    6. The markings on the elevation/windage are actually in 1/4" steps and when moved 4 clicks, the turret is marked with a "1", 8 clicks "2" and so on.
    7. Scope is not heavy or excessive in length. Looks nice on a .22 rifle.

    What I don't like.
    1. Turret caps are plastic with threads in the plastic. One crossthreading and the threads might be chewed up.
    2. Targets @ 25yds are blurred but this is to be expected as the parallex on this scope is 50yds. At 50yds on out the targets are clear.

    What I would like to see.
    1. Metal turret caps.
    2. This scope with an adjustable objective (AO) down to 10yds. This would increase the price of the scope but I for one would be willing to pay for it. The Target EFR model of this scope has an AO but not the BDC reticle.

    I am very pleased with the overall quality and performance of this scope. For me I think it is well worth the $$$ even without the rebate. I have been through a lot of inexpensive scopes and this one beats them all hands down. I have read many times that a person should sacrifice magnification for quality of glass in a scope. This scope proves that. Better to see a clear, bright target @ 9X than a blurry, dark target @ 24X.

    Thanks for looking
    Last edited by Izzy43; 04-17-2012, 10:28 AM.
  • #2
    bman940
    Member
    • Nov 2010
    • 303

    Iz., Very nice job, Truthful and unbiased.Kudo's to you, I hope other's get a chance to see your post and it helps them with their decision.
    A lot of work in your write up and pictures, thank you again for passing along your thoughts!
    Hopefully I'll get one tot he range soon and paas my thoughts on as well.
    Bart

    Comment

    • #3
      walletclan
      Member
      • Apr 2011
      • 191

      Great review. I have never seen the box method before, but that is great. I ordered the 4x32 Nikon with the rebate deal and am looking forward to put on my 10/22 TD.

      What rings our mount are you using?

      Comment

      • #4
        Quinc
        Veteran Member
        • Jan 2010
        • 3011

        Great Review!
        Shop Amazon and contribute to CGF!
        click this link before going to amazon.com
        http://www.shop42a.com

        sigpic
        www.appleseedinfo.org

        "Everyone has a plan, till they get punched in the face." -Mike Tyson

        Comment

        • #5
          covingtonhouse
          Senior Member
          • Mar 2011
          • 2170

          Great range report!!! Thanks.
          "I don't work for you!" - Joe Biden
          LGBFJB

          "Slavery is the most profitable business in human history. This explains why your current overseers across the world want a GREAT RESET. ?You will own nothing' conversely means 'they will own everything, including you.? -Jason Powers

          Comment

          • #6
            Dirtbikindad393
            Senior Member
            • Feb 2012
            • 981

            Great review and write up. Helped me with a lot of my questions about scopes and to learn more about the factors going into it. I was thinking about the 4x32 that Walletclan bought but I am now thinking the BDC or maybe the target as my first scope to go onto my Ruger 10/22 TD that I will be picking up soon. Now my big question is like walletclan what components do you recommend to mount the scope?

            Do I use a rail and rings?

            Off to use the search function to see if I can get some answers. I need to buy the scope before the rebate ends but would like to purchase from Cabelas while I can get 1.89 shipping.
            NRA Life Member
            GSSF Member

            I don't regret burning some bridges. I regret that some people weren't on those bridges when I burnt them!

            Comment

            • #7
              Izzy43
              CGSSA Rimfire Coordinator
              • Dec 2009
              • 2670

              Originally posted by walletclan
              Great review. I have never seen the box method before, but that is great. I ordered the 4x32 Nikon with the rebate deal and am looking forward to put on my 10/22 TD.

              What rings our mount are you using?
              I used these rings, no other mount. Rings mount directly to the dovetail on the receiver. I think these rings would also work on a semi-auto and would not creep due to the two mounting bolts on each ring. They clamp very tightly. I also use them on a .22WMR bolt action and they never creep even with the additional recoil of that round.



              If mounted on a bolt action, ensure that you have enough room for the bolt to clear the rear of the scope. Not a problem for most bolt action .22 rifles but could be an issue on CZ rifles.

              Edit: Those rings are also available for Weaver/Pictanny type mounts.

              Comment

              • #8
                facn650
                Member
                • Mar 2012
                • 152

                Izzy,
                thanks for taking the time to post the review. Can't wait for mine to come in and test it out.

                Dirtbikingdad, these are the rings for the weaver style and they are also see through and might allow use of iron sights(can't confirm)

                Comment

                • #9
                  facn650
                  Member
                  • Mar 2012
                  • 152

                  Izzy,
                  when you say the targets are blurred at 25yards, is this a full magnification? Would the 4x32 suffer from the same thing since the parallax is also set to 50yards on that scope?

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    HilaryForPresident
                    Banned
                    • Apr 2012
                    • 46

                    These are great value scopes. My friend has a similar one, the clarity surprised me.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Vacaville
                      Veteran Member
                      • Nov 2008
                      • 4360

                      Thanks for the input. I've been thinking of getting one for my Marlin 795.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        sholling
                        I need a LIFE!!
                        CGN Contributor
                        • Sep 2007
                        • 10360

                        That's a shame that it's blurry below 25yds and completely unacceptable for a rimfire scope. I'd actually considered buying one but I'll go with the Weaver RV7 instead. Thanks for the review you've saved me some money.
                        Last edited by sholling; 04-11-2012, 4:03 PM.
                        "Government is the great fiction, through which everybody endeavors to live at the expense of everybody else." --FREDERIC BASTIAT--

                        Proud Life Member: National Rifle Association, the Second Amendment Foundation, and the California Rifle & Pistol Association

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Izzy43
                          CGSSA Rimfire Coordinator
                          • Dec 2009
                          • 2670

                          Originally posted by sholling
                          That's a shame that it's blurry below 25yds and completely unacceptable for a rimfire scope. I'd actually considered buying one but I'll go with the Weaver RV7 instead. That's for the review you've saved me some money.
                          I guess the EFR Target model would be a better choice due to the AO but I think the 1/4" @ 50yds elevation/windage adjustments really takes it out of the realm of a true target scope.

                          I mounted the BDC model on my CZ UltraLux yesterday and due to the mounting height required for the bolt to clear the scope, the farthest I could zero the scope was 40yds with the elevation at maximum. For a scope that has 80 moa of adjustment I believe that is unsatifactory.

                          Still I do like the scope on my Kimber and shoot it primarily at 50+ yds. I did call Nikon Technical support and was informed I needed higher rings to zero at longer ranges. Won't be calling them again. A Weaver RV-9 is on my short list.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            sholling
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            CGN Contributor
                            • Sep 2007
                            • 10360

                            Originally posted by Izzy43
                            I guess the EFR Target model would be a better choice due to the AO but I think the 1/4" @ 50yds elevation/windage adjustments really takes it out of the realm of a true target scope.

                            I mounted the BDC model on my CZ UltraLux yesterday and due to the mounting height required for the bolt to clear the scope, the farthest I could zero the scope was 40yds with the elevation at maximum. For a scope that has 80 moa of adjustment I believe that is unsatifactory.

                            Still I do like the scope on my Kimber and shoot it primarily at 50+ yds. I did call Nikon Technical support and was informed I needed higher rings to zero at longer ranges. Won't be calling them again. A Weaver RV-9 is on my short list.
                            I have the RV9 and it's great for casual target shooting (not enough magnification for serious target shooting) but I'd like something faster (non-AO) for a survival rifle and in that situation the shooter may need to take a rabbit or tree rat from 10-75yds. For comparison purposes my old $50 Bushnell 3-9x32 rimfire is in focus from 10 yards on. I'm really sad because I wanted the Nikon.
                            "Government is the great fiction, through which everybody endeavors to live at the expense of everybody else." --FREDERIC BASTIAT--

                            Proud Life Member: National Rifle Association, the Second Amendment Foundation, and the California Rifle & Pistol Association

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              facn650
                              Member
                              • Mar 2012
                              • 152

                              I'll have to try it out this weekend since it gets here on Thursday.

                              I'd like the ability to focus at 15-100 yards

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1