Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Trigger Re-do

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • RawHP
    Senior Member
    • Dec 2014
    • 633

    Trigger Re-do

    I originally did the trigger job on my 10/22 about 18 years ago. I took my time, re-cutting the angle on the hammer to about 3-4 degrees and cut the sear to match. I also added a trigger stop to the trigger guard. The result was a pretty clean breaking trigger, with a 2-1/4 lb pull, and very little take-up, which I always planned on eliminating at some point. Well 30k+ rounds later, I still haven’t done anything about it, but all of these threads on triggers, trigger groups, etc. finally got to me, so I decided to re-do my trigger this weekend.

    When I pulled the trigger group apart, the first thing I noticed is that it still looked great, with no real wear on the hammer and sear. I patted myself on the back for a job well done way back then; the cuts on the hammer and sear produced no discernable movement of the hammer until the break, indicating the angle cuts were good, so I wouldn’t need to change them. At that time, the finest grade of sand paper you could get in the big box stores was 600 grit, so I decided to smooth out all the contact points with 1000 grit which is common now (starting at 240 for parts that I never polished, and 800 for parts that I had already hit with 600). I decided to shoot for a clean 2 lb pull, so I started by polishing all contact points on the hammer, sear, and disconnector that rub against each other when the trigger resets, since I planned on clipping a coil or two off of the trigger return spring. I also polished and radiused the trigger return plunger.



    Left to right, sear with portion above the engagement area polished. This is where the bottom of the hammer rides while cycling, before resetting. Next is the disconnector, installed in the trigger. The top is polished, but I really only needed to polish the front portion where the hammer touches it to disconnect from the sear. On the right is the trigger return plunger that I buffed and radiused, so it can travel smoothly in the hole in the trigger guard, and against the trigger itself. Further over is the trigger return spring, which I clipped three quarters of a coil off of.


    Both the hammer and sear looked exactly like they did when I first did the trigger job, but I could see exactly where they engaged by the clean edge along the hammer’s sear notch. I clamped both in my vise and gave them 3 or 4 passes with my trigger/sear stone. I used the same India stone on all of my trigger jobs, which was fine at the time, but there are some really fine ceramic stones on Brownell’s now that I’ve been eying that would give an ultra-high polish for the lighter pull I’m using. $30 a pop for the gray and white stones, so I’m still deciding, but I know if I get them, I’ll be redoing more than my 10/22 trigger.



    Upper left is the hammer face that rides against the bolt, polished for smoother cycling. Upper right is the bottom of the hammer, which rides on the sear when resetting. Lower left and right are the engagement areas of the sear and hammer, before hitting them lightly with the stone. If I get the ceramic stones, I’ll polish these further.



    This is the bolt radius, where the hammer rides when cycling, polished to 1000 grit.

    Finally, to eliminate the take-up, I decided to try to JB Weld trick on the sear the eliminate the slop. If it worked, I would later remove the JB Weld, and hit that part of the sear with a blob of silver solder, then do the same mod with something more permanent.



    This is the blob of JB Weld that I applied to the sear after roughing it up with my fine trigger/sear file. I reshaped the blob with 800 grit until the disconnector would reset, and then gave it another 4 or 5 passes. This eliminated 80% of the take-up that I’ve been living with all of these years. I doubt most people would have noticed the take-up before I did this, but I think I’ve grown ultra sensitive to it, so I needed to address it.

    Results: The take-up is basically eliminated. The only thing that might make it even better would be to replace the hammer, trigger, and disconnector pins with oversized stainless pins, which I haven’t been able to locate. Some forums mention Kidd pins, but I haven’t seen them on their website, and suspect that may be on purpose. I may need to fabricate them from drill bit stock, if I can find it with the right specs. Measuring the pull with my trusty coat hanger, plastic water jug, turkey baster, digital scale and water method, the trigger breaks at 31 ounce, plus or minus a quarter ounce, averaged over 10 pulls. Very consistent.

    Next steps: 1) Re-do the JB Weld mod with silver solder, which will be a permanent fix. 2) Bite the bullet and get either one or both of the finer ceramic hammer/sear stones to give the engagement surfaces an ultra smooth finish. I’m guessing this may take another ounce or so off of the pull weight. 3) Locate or make tighter tolerance hammer, sear, and disconnector pins. This might require some minor adjustments to the hammer and sear if the tighter tolerances change the angles at all.

    This is the best video I’ve seen that shows exactly how all of the trigger group parts work together. If you go to about the 16 minute point, you can really see how the slop between the disconnector and the sear causes the trigger take-up. The JB Weld trick eliminates that slop.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ks6...ature=youtu.be
    Last edited by RawHP; 05-21-2015, 9:12 PM.
  • #2
    Red9
    Veteran Member
    • Sep 2014
    • 2892

    Hey wheres the picts? I want to see the great job on your trigger.
    At least i cant see them.
    Never enough reloading stuff

    Comment

    • #3
      RawHP
      Senior Member
      • Dec 2014
      • 633

      Hmmm, not sure what the issue might be. The pics show up for me with every browser I've tried, and several PCs.

      Anyway, I was able to locate a source for oversized pins (TriggerShims.com), right before I was about to order stuff to make my own. If they tighten up the tolerances, I'll have a good idea of what I have left to deal with. Meaning, if the JB Weld trick eliminated the take up caused by the sear to disconnector slop, and the oversized pins remove the take up related to loose pin tolerances, then whatever is leftover would be creep. So here's my new plan of attack:

      1) Install oversized pins. If all take up and/or creep is eliminated, then I'm done. If not (which I suspect will be the case), then
      2) Disassemble the trigger group and mark the hammer hook with magic marker.
      3) Reassemble and cycle the action several times.
      4) Check the hammer hook and measure the sear to hammer engagement.
      5) If greater than the sear width, stone the hammer until it matches the sear width. If less or equal (I'm guessing it's equal based on the marks before I started the re-do), go directly to step 7.
      6) Re-mark hammer hook, reassemble, if creep is gone, skip to step 9. If creep is still present,
      7) Break the sear edge and relieve to decrease engagement.
      8) Mark hammer hook, reassemble, cycle several times, check for creep, if present, repeat step 7 and 8, keeping an eye on sear engagement, until perceivable creep is eliminated.
      9) Check all functioning, safety, cycle action several more times before range testing, using normal post-trigger work precautions.

      Comment

      • #4
        FiremanBob
        Junior Member
        • Jan 2015
        • 77

        Excellent write-up of a good job. Have you polished the back of the sear and the disconnector where they engage? That will smooth out your reset.
        Author of The 10/22 Companion: How to Operate, Troubleshoot, Maintain and Improve Your Ruger 10/22
        Blog: 1022Companion.wordpress.com
        Project Appleseed Instructor

        Comment

        • #5
          RawHP
          Senior Member
          • Dec 2014
          • 633

          Originally posted by FiremanBob
          Excellent write-up of a good job. Have you polished the back of the sear and the disconnector where they engage? That will smooth out your reset.
          Thanks. Yup. I didn't include a pic, but the lip of the disconnector is polished to 1000 grit. It's hard to see in the last pic, but the back of the sear is also polished, but you can't tell because the surface has some JB Weld residue from me removing the overrun with a razor. I cleaned it all up when i sanded the blob for final fitting.

          Once I get the new pins, I'll post a follow up showing what the finished (interim) sear looks like with the JB Weld sanded down.

          If you look closely at the bottom two shots in the 4 shot pic, you can see the outline of where the sear engages the hammer notch. I took the pic before cleaning that area as a reference, but if you look at the sear edge it has a slightly broken corner that matches up with the mark on the hammer. I'm pretty sure that after the pins are replaced, I'll be breaking the top (in the pic) edge of the sear to reduce the engagement slightly to achieve perfection. Like I mentioned, most people probably wouldn't perceive any creep since both surfaces are mated and honed very smoothly, but i'm always looking for perfection with this part of my hobby.

          Comment

          • #6
            RawHP
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2014
            • 633

            The oversized trigger group pins arrived today. I installed them and noticed right away how tightly they fit. The disconnector pin is especially tight, but the other two were tight with no play. There is no more slop, but the tighter tolerances caused the hammer to bind against the sear when cycling, almost enough to stop the hammer from fully cycling. I stoned off about 6/1000ths off the bottom of the hammer to allow it to cycle freely again; no binding and no play!

            After that, I tried the trigger pull again. I could detect a very small amount of take up, but no creep, but only about one in five times cycling the action. So I proceeded with the steps I listed above, marking the sear's edge and hammer hook with magic marker, reassembling, and cycling several times, and then inspecting the engagement areas. I ended up relieving about 1/3 of the sear edge with my India stone, and then testing again. Next I stoned off a very small amount off of the hammer hook so that the marking on the hook was exactly the same width as the width of the remaining sear edge. After reassembling and cycling several times, the trigger felt perfect with no detectable creep.

            I remeasured the trigger pull weight and it came in exactly at 31 ounces again. I also realized that I did have a small grey ceramic stone that I didn't realize I had gotten back when I did the original work. I pulled everything apart again, and lightly honed both the sear edge and hammer hook, polishing them to a mirror finish.

            Here's a pic of the results:


            The first pic is the JB Weld that I had sanded to remove all slop between the disconnector and sear. The next pic is the bottom of the hammer after taking off around 6/1000th. You can tell it was a significant amount, if you compare with the earlier pics. That's how much tighter the tolerances are because of the new pins. The next pic, lower left, is the reworked hammer hook, which is noticeably narrower in depth than the earlier pics, and perfectly matches the sear edge width. The last pic is the sear edge, with the top edge relieved and slightly radiused (shiny part of the edge), leaving about 2/3 of the original width to engage the hammer.

            I'll still be going back to redo the JB Weld and replacing it with silver solder, but will probably put a few thousand rounds through first to make sure I'm 100% satisfied with the job. Can't wait to go to the range, after doing some more dry firing and safety checks.
            Last edited by RawHP; 05-21-2015, 7:00 PM.

            Comment

            • #7
              RawHP
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2014
              • 633

              Range test today. 400 rounds, no problems. Ultra crisp break, and after a few rounds it felt like as soon as my brain said "fire", the rifle would go off, no take-up, no creep, just *BANG*. I'll probably get lazy and keep the JB Weld there for a while and just enjoy shooting it.

              Comment

              Working...
              UA-8071174-1