Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

ACOG or EO Tech

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dark Water
    Member
    • Jun 2008
    • 156

    ACOG or EO Tech

    I have an AR itching for a quality piece of glass and would like to hear your choices. My AR is a 16 inch M4 style that I generally use for distances of 0-50yards. Magnification would be nice but I can get along without it. I like how the ACOG looks like a scope. It compliments the gun well. Let me know what you think.
    sigpic
  • #2
  • #3
    Casual_Shooter
    Ban Hammer Avoidance Team
    CGN Contributor - Lifetime
    • Sep 2006
    • 11741

    If it's in your budget, ACOG now has the "doctor" option which is a small red dot eotech looking addition to the top of their scope. i.e. TA31DOC.
    Guns, dogs and home alarms. Opponents are all of a sudden advocates once their personal space is violated.

    "Those who cannot remember the posts are condemned to repeat them"



    Why is it all the funny stuff happens to comedians?

    Comment

    • #4
      vandal
      Veteran Member
      • Sep 2007
      • 2870

      Benchrest shooting? Carbine competitions?

      Comment

      • #5
        argonadict
        Junior Member
        • Jun 2008
        • 45

        eotech with a aimpoint 3x magnifier on a qd mount,then you can use the eotech at short range,and just clamp on the magnifier for mid work,and still cheaper for all that than a acog alone and versatile.

        or if your only doing short range the aimpoint micro t-1 seems to be getting really popular

        Comment

        • #6
          brando
          Veteran Member
          • Feb 2006
          • 3694

          I've used ACOGs, EOTechs, and all of the Aimpoints from the 1000 (circa 1992) through the CompML to the Micro T-1. For close, dynamic work where you're moving around a lot and engaging targets in less than ideal positions, I prefered the EOTech. The 65MOA ring is very rapid to acquire and the FOV is very wide. This was after using Aimpoints for many years, where the major drawback was the ability to switch to 300m engagements (the 4MOA dot is too large for). However, the EOTech battery life is weak compared to the Aimpoints (which you can pretty much leave on all the time) and the interface is clumsy in my opinion. I eventually put the EOTech away after I had a couple "shut off" mid-recoil which made me glad to have BUIS. So now that Aimpoint makes optics with smaller dots, I gave the Micro T-1 a try. This is now my favorite RDS. It's super light, compact and solid.

          ACOG are fantastic for what they are and very durable, however I think for under 200m they're less than ideal. The fixed magnification is the problem and makes close-in target acquisition slower than a wide FOV non-magnified optic. Kind of apples & oranges if you ask me. Downrange I used my ACOG when I was back in the wire and most likely to engage in a fixed defensive position. This is where the NSN model was great with the BDC reticle and the magnification. I worked out the ranges for the streets and buildings nearby so that IDing targets and engaging them accurately was MUCH easier than had I used an RDS.

          Still, your mileage may vary.
          --Brando

          Comment

          • #7
            What Just Happened?
            Veteran Member
            • Sep 2007
            • 2504

            Originally posted by argonadict
            eotech with a aimpoint 3x magnifier on a qd mount,then you can use the eotech at short range,and just clamp on the magnifier for mid work,and still cheaper for all that than a acog alone and versatile.

            or if your only doing short range the aimpoint micro t-1 seems to be getting really popular
            Why not use the eotech 3x magnifier?

            Comment

            • #8
              argonadict
              Junior Member
              • Jun 2008
              • 45

              Originally posted by What Just Happened?
              Why not use the eotech 3x magnifier?
              the set up i shot had a aimpoint and i liked it alot,ive never used the eotech magnifier so i cant tell anyone else if its good or bad and theres people on this forum that have massive more experience then me so ill leave that duty to them

              the micro t1 is going to go on what im piling up parts for now so then ill beable to review it aswell

              cheers

              Comment

              • #9
                LibertyOptics
                Senior Member
                • Mar 2008
                • 592

                For 0-50 yards, just get the EoTech, without any magnifier. That's what is does best.. I like the small dot Aimpoint also.

                Scott
                Liberty Optics LLC
                "See Better, Shoot Better"
                www.LibertyOptics.com
                Scott@LibertyOptics.com
                406-827-6543
                Scott's cell number: 406-291-8250

                Comment

                • #10
                  get2now
                  Member
                  • Jan 2006
                  • 155

                  Bushnell Holosight is the ticket. Over a hundred dollars cheaper than the Eotech too.
                  I had the Bushnell but my eyes weren't good enough to see anything past 100 yards. I now use an ACOG but that's because I shoot out to 400 yards with it.
                  If money is no object then get the ACOG. However, if you're only shooting out to 50 yards then the Bushnell or Eotech is what you would want. The Bushnell/Eotech has a much faster target aquisition for closer targets than the ACOG too.

                  Comment

                  • #11
                    brando
                    Veteran Member
                    • Feb 2006
                    • 3694

                    That reminds me of something that was brought up before regarding close-in shooting with an ACOG. If it's got one of the illuminated reticles, you can use it in OEG mode (like the old Armson sight from the early 70s), but it requires a little bit of getting used to. The idea is that with both eyes open and focused on the target, the dog/triangle/donut that's illuminated in the reticle becomes superimposed by your binocular eyesight. Kind of hard to explain.
                    --Brando

                    Comment

                    • #12
                      SuperSet
                      Calguns Addict
                      • Feb 2007
                      • 9048

                      Originally posted by brando
                      That reminds me of something that was brought up before regarding close-in shooting with an ACOG. If it's got one of the illuminated reticles, you can use it in OEG mode (like the old Armson sight from the early 70s), but it requires a little bit of getting used to. The idea is that with both eyes open and focused on the target, the dog/triangle/donut that's illuminated in the reticle becomes superimposed by your binocular eyesight. Kind of hard to explain.
                      Have you ever successfully worked this option? Not only was I little bit slower than a dedicated RDS, my POI/POA was different.

                      Comment

                      • #13
                        brando
                        Veteran Member
                        • Feb 2006
                        • 3694

                        Oh totally, I'm against it, but for some folks it works well. Kind of a "your mileage may vary" situation. That's exactly why I recommend EOTech's and Aimpoints over ACOGs most of the time. Going back to Iraq I'd take a Micro T-1, but going to A'stan I'd take an ACOG. Why? Average engagement distance is MUCH farther in A'stan where a magnified optic is more important.
                        --Brando

                        Comment

                        • #14
                          argonadict
                          Junior Member
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 45

                          ive used armson occulated for years,once you get used to it it can be rather quick,for sporting though, i wouldent bet my life on it

                          Comment

                          • #15
                            LibertyOptics
                            Senior Member
                            • Mar 2008
                            • 592

                            Originally posted by SuperSet72
                            Have you ever successfully worked this option? Not only was I little bit slower than a dedicated RDS, my POI/POA was different.
                            Are you referring to the both-eyes-open Bindon Aiming Concept? That will not work well if you are cross-dominant (e.g., shoot right handed; left eye dominant).
                            Liberty Optics LLC
                            "See Better, Shoot Better"
                            www.LibertyOptics.com
                            Scott@LibertyOptics.com
                            406-827-6543
                            Scott's cell number: 406-291-8250

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            UA-8071174-1