Nikon Monarch: which one?

[Adrn]

I just recently picked up a Rem 700 in .308 WIN. Now, I have the joy of purchasing a new scope to go with it. I have checked out the Nikon line and I want to go with the Monarch in either 4-16x42SF or 5-20x44SF. I would mainly be using this rifle for pig, deer, and occasional range shooting. Most hunting here in CA. The 5-20 has 1/8MOA while the 4-16 has 1/4MOA. Also, is the side focus extremely beneficial? Let me know.

Thanks for any feedback.

-Adrian

[NapaCountyShooter]

Side focus isn't crucial. If you're primarily using it for hunting, get the one with a lower starting magnification. 3X or 4X maximum low end. You'll want that low end for the larger field of view for finding game before you zoom in on it. I like 1/4 moa adjustments better than 1/8 personally. Less clicks to get to where you're going.

[OpticsPlanet]

Adrian,

I like a 4-16x42. Perfect for shots from 50 yards with the SF to over 600-700 if need be for target. I used that same Monarch, 4-16x42SF, on a shoot recently and was very impressed with it. Picking the 4-16 or the 5-20 may depend on how far you're looking to shoot. I woudl only go with teh 5-20 if i was looking to shoot 300-1000+ yards majority of the time. 4-16 is ideal for 100-700+ yards. I actually prefer a side focus. Easy to keep you eye behind the glass and adjust for the distance you need rather than move and adjust an AO. Comes down to preference though. 1/4 MOA is my go to for a good all around turret as well.

Trevor B
OpticsPlanet

[pdugan6]

^^^^agreed. you will rarely be taking a shot on an animal over 300yd so 5-20 is just added weight. when hunting your magnification is usually on lowest power anyways, as to acquire the target easier and you are rarely at full magnification.

[Adrn]

Thank you all for the detailed responses. I am really starting to like this site and the members.

[bruce_ventura]

Let me repeat what Napa said. Think lower magnification. Big game hunting in California is hilly and brushy. Short range shots (<150 yds) are common. Pigs can be dangerous. Fast target acquisition lowers your risk Seriously think as low as 1.5-6X, no more than 3-9X. IMHO 4-16X is too much magnification.