Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

C&R licensee record keeping requirements after license expires Official BATFE Info

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SVT-40
    I need a LIFE!!
    • Jan 2008
    • 12894

    C&R licensee record keeping requirements after license expires Official BATFE Info

    So as not to spam up any other threads (more than they already have been). I thought I would start a new thread to inform C&R licensee's of their record keeping requirements after their licenses expire.

    So once and for all, direct from the BATFE. Not my opinion, and not from a random Agent. These directives are direct from the BATFE Licensee newsletters.


    C&R licensee's ARE NOT REQUIRED TO KEEP THEIR RECORDS AS REQUIRED IN 27 CFR 478.129(e) if they are no longer a licensee.

    BATFE "suggests" that you keep the records, but it is not a requirement of law.





    See page (7) in the below 2004 BATFE news letter link. . The BATFE explicitly says records kept by C&R licensee's "ARE NOT BUSINESS RECORDS"




    "Licensed collectors are not required to turn in their acquisition / disposition records if their license is not renewed or they discontinue their collecting activity. The GCA requires the delivery of required records to the Government within 30 days after a firearms “business” is discontinued.

    A license as a collector of curios or relics does not authorize any
    business with respect to firearms.

    This is in contrast to firearms importers, manufacturers, and dealers who are licensed to engage in a firearms business.

    Therefore, the records required to be kept by licensed collectors under the law and regulations are not business records and are not required to be turned in to ATF when collector’s licenses. "





    More from a BATFE 2011 news letter. See page (5) This specifically says record retention as specified in 27 CFR 478.129(e) IS NOT REQUIRED



    "ATF receives numerous inquiries concerning record retention requirements applicable to holders of Collector
    of Curios or Relics (C&R) licenses that discontinue their
    collection activities and do not renew their licenses. If
    someone who held a C&R FFL is no longer a licensee,
    then he or she is no longer required to comply with
    ATF regulation of licensees, which includes the record
    retention requirement specified in 27 CFR 478.129(e).


    In addition, C&R licensees are not required to submit
    their A&D records to the ATF Out-of-Business Records
    Center."


    However, we suggest that all C&R records be
    retained for future reference.
    Additionally, there may be State laws pertaining to C&R
    FFLs. C&R licensees should contact the appropriate
    State attorneys general office or other appropriate State
    agencies to inquire about these laws. A list of State attorneys general offices, with contact information, may be
    found at http://www.naag.org.
    Last edited by SVT-40; 08-03-2022, 4:30 PM.
    Poke'm with a stick!


    Originally posted by fiddletown
    What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.
  • #2
    Milsurp1
    Veteran Member
    • Aug 2016
    • 3091

    Comment

    • #3
      Milsurp1
      Veteran Member
      • Aug 2016
      • 3091

      Comment

      • #4
        flyer898
        Senior Member
        • Feb 2009
        • 2015

        SVT-40, thank you for your post and the citation to authority.
        Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference. So said somebody but not Mark Twain
        "One argues to a judge, one does not argue with a judge." Me
        "Never argue unless you are getting paid." CDAA
        "I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it." George Bernard Shaw

        Comment

        • #5
          SVT-40
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Jan 2008
          • 12894

          Originally posted by Milsurp1
          The 2011 letter, I will note, is on point, but I would not rely on that. Look how many times the ATF’s informal position has changed on braces.


          Lol.

          So even though the BATFE expressly writes in their publications that there is no requirement for C&R licensees to keep their records after their license expires, you still won't admit you're wrong.

          Oh, and this isn't their "informal" opinion.

          It's their official opinion direct from the BATFE licensing division which they use to relay official information to licensees through their official newsletter.
          Last edited by SVT-40; 08-03-2022, 1:45 PM.
          Poke'm with a stick!


          Originally posted by fiddletown
          What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

          Comment

          • #6
            Milsurp1
            Veteran Member
            • Aug 2016
            • 3091

            Comment

            • #7
              SVT-40
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Jan 2008
              • 12894

              Originally posted by Milsurp1
              https://www.atf.gov/file/2026/download

              An open letter, like the handbook I am linking in this post, is an informal opinion because it was not promulgated under the APA procedures. It may be cited in court for Skidmore deference, but not Chevron deference.

              Also note that the ATF’s curio and relic handbook expressly says that collectors may dispose of bound books after 20 years. That is why courts do not treat these informal opinions as trumping binding regulations from the CFR.
              The link you posted is a 2007 list of C&R firearms. It also has "SELECTED" regulations (27C.F.R.) applicable to Licensed Collectors. See the bottom of page (2).

              This is not a complete list, and contains dated information.




              The September 2011 Official newsletter published by the BATFE expressly says that C&R licensee holders are not required under 27 CFR 478.129(e) to keep any of their records after their license expires.



              PERIOD END OF STORY

              It's not a "open letter". It's not "informal"

              This newsletter is the Official way the BATFE communicates with license holders

              This notification appears at the top of each newsletter:

              "September 2011
              In an effort to keep Federal firearms licensees (FFLs) abreast of changing firearms laws and regulations, the Bureau of
              Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) will provide semiannual FFL Newsletters. Previous editions of the
              FFL Newsletters are available on ATF’s Web site (http://www.atf.gov)".



              As I previously said these "Newsletters" as printed above are the official way the BATFE communicates "CHANGING FIREARMS LAWS AND REGULATIONS" to licensee's.






              "ATF receives numerous inquiries concerning record retention requirements applicable to holders of Collector
              of Curios or Relics (C&R) licenses that discontinue their
              collection activities and do not renew their licenses.

              If someone who held a C&R FFL is no longer a licensee,
              then he or she is no longer required to comply with
              ATF regulation of licensees, which includes the record
              retention requirement specified in 27 CFR 478.129(e).

              In addition, C&R licensees are not required to submit
              their A&D records to the ATF Out-of-Business Records
              Center."



              So unless you have any guidance issued by the BATFE AFTER September 2011 that contradicts their Official news letter, well then the issue is settled.
              Last edited by SVT-40; 08-03-2022, 2:38 PM.
              Poke'm with a stick!


              Originally posted by fiddletown
              What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

              Comment

              • #8
                MajorSideburns
                Senior Member
                • May 2013
                • 1675

                Their constantly shifting opinion is not law.

                Comment

                • #9
                  SVT-40
                  I need a LIFE!!
                  • Jan 2008
                  • 12894

                  Originally posted by MajorSideburns
                  Their constantly shifting opinion is not law.
                  Where has the BATFE "shifted" its opinion relating this issue?

                  Post a link where anyone at the BATFE has contradicted the guidance related to C&R license holders not needing to keep their "records" after their licenses expire as published in their 2011 Newsletter...

                  This has been the policy of the BATFE for many decades. The 2011 notice in their newsletter was just a reminder as to what official policy was. It is still the same policy today.

                  What some are missing is that C&R license holders are NOT IN BUSINESS. that's why there is no requirement to both turn in records, or keep any records once a C&R licensee ceases licensed activities, or their license expires.

                  It's really just that simple, and that is behind the BATFE's policy.
                  Last edited by SVT-40; 08-04-2022, 1:37 PM.
                  Poke'm with a stick!


                  Originally posted by fiddletown
                  What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    flyer898
                    Senior Member
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 2015

                    As a general rule, once the agency promulgates an official interpretation of a rule or statute, licensees are entitled to rely on that interpretation until it is changed or rescinded.
                    I think anyone who disposes of the records upon license non-renewal, has a safe harbor.
                    This is just my opinion.
                    Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference. So said somebody but not Mark Twain
                    "One argues to a judge, one does not argue with a judge." Me
                    "Never argue unless you are getting paid." CDAA
                    "I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it." George Bernard Shaw

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      nwfdub
                      Junior Member
                      • Sep 2020
                      • 16

                      Here we go again. Different thread. Same behavior. What a Troll. PEBCAK.

                      Sent from my SM-G715U using Tapatalk

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        BrokerB
                        Calguns Addict
                        • Sep 2010
                        • 5285

                        Oops mine are all gone
                        Beans and Bullets

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          smle-man
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Jan 2007
                          • 10580

                          How long will this go on?

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            SVT-40
                            I need a LIFE!!
                            • Jan 2008
                            • 12894

                            Originally posted by smle-man
                            How long will this go on?
                            Your question isn't really clear. Are you asking how long the BATFE has had this policy, and how long will it continue?
                            Poke'm with a stick!


                            Originally posted by fiddletown
                            What you believe and what is true in real life in the real world aren't necessarily the same thing. And what you believe doesn't change what is true in real life in the real world.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              19K
                              Veteran Member
                              • Aug 2013
                              • 3621

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1