Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Bay Area-1865 My Friend Pat D .32 - Appraisal?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • knifetoagunfight
    Senior Member
    • Jul 2012
    • 547

    Bay Area-1865 My Friend Pat D .32 - Appraisal?

    Reaching out to the community here for some advice. I have an 1865 My Friend Pat D in the rarer .32 caliber 5 shot that I've been holding onto since my grandpa passed away. I have plenty else to remember him by and my family would be better served with a modern revolver or cash. I took it to a local gun shop about 7 years ago and received an offer to purchase, but not a true appraisal.
    1. Are there reputable appraisal stores in the Bay Area?
    2. Would you pay for an appraisal for something like this?
    3. From just my internet searches, it looks like these could go from $1500 to $3000 depending on condition.

    Thanks,

    --J
    Last edited by knifetoagunfight; 04-30-2016, 1:44 PM.
  • #2
    Enfield47
    Calguns Addict
    • Sep 2012
    • 6385

    If you're planning on selling it then I would get it appraised. At least you'll know what it's worth and won't under or over price it. I'm not in No Cal, but I'm sure someone in that area can tell you who does good appraisals locally.

    Comment

    • #3
      73 RB-Z
      Member
      • Jan 2013
      • 352

      Afraid I don't have appraiser advice to offer, but that reminded me of the Forgotten Weapons video Ian did a year ago on this little revolver. Pretty cool!

      He always links to the auction page of the gun he's talking about. The Rock Island search might be useful

      Fine Engraved James Reid My Friend Knuckle Duster with Police Whistle and LetterProduced 1868-1882, this is an early example of a Reid knuckle duster with "MY FRIEND" and patent marking on the left side of the top strap. "61" is marked on the rear of the cylinder and the full serial number "13061" is marked on the butt. It has scroll engraving on the integral grip and a checkered shield at the rear. A police whistle [sic] is included in a cardboard box with a "LE PARFUM IDEAL HOUBIGANT" brass label of a woman sniffing a flower on the bottom. The top of the box is marked "Grandpa Winfelder's/Police Whistle [sic]". A letter is included explaining that this pistol and whistle belonged to the recipients "great grand uncle, Louis Windfelder, which he used when he was a policeman in Renovo, PA. He kept it in his boot as an extra weapon." A copy of a family photograph with Winfelder in it is also included.



      -Andy / Steeltown Duke SASS# 104602

      Comment

      • #4
        nightwolf0215
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2012
        • 1728

        Not the best way, but a good way to estimate how much that is worth is by watching similar auctions. I found these two on gunbroker:


        This one has been relisted a few times. The highest bid it ever got was $2k.


        This one has been relisted a few times as well. No bid or buy.

        For past auctions on gunbroker for the Reid My Friend Knuckle Duster. Most ended without a bid or in the $1000 range. One did sell for $2000 with only 1 bid after 11 days, and its condition is pretty much pristine.



        I am no appraiser, but I think if you list it on gunbroker, it'll likely net you somewhere $1000-1500.
        I'd rather be at the range!

        Comment

        Working...
        UA-8071174-1