Looks like the BCG has been banging into the threads as they're cleanly taken off on either side at the same place:

The BCG and Buffer make contact before the lower closes and I don't see any chatter marks from the buffer hitting the retainer so I don't think it's that. Upper and lower have a good fit but not super tight. Rifle shoots great otherwise so I'm really confused here.
Maybe bad buffer, spring, or out of spec buffer tube?
edit: carbine buffer, tube and spring

The BCG and Buffer make contact before the lower closes and I don't see any chatter marks from the buffer hitting the retainer so I don't think it's that. Upper and lower have a good fit but not super tight. Rifle shoots great otherwise so I'm really confused here.
Maybe bad buffer, spring, or out of spec buffer tube?
edit: carbine buffer, tube and spring
Comment