Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

HELP: rupturing case on a custom Rem700 SA

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • NewbieDave
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2006
    • 1277

    HELP: rupturing case on a custom Rem700 SA

    Sorry… this is going to be a little long.

    HISTORY:

    This whole thing started as a trued and lapped Rem 700 SA receiver with a 1/11.25 SR-60 contour barrel installed. The job was done by a reputable smith with years of experience dealing with the Remington 700 actions. NOTE: I have not contacted the shop about this yet so I don’t want to state their name until I’m sure it’s not a rifle issue.

    Once I got the action, I dropped it into a chassis, tightening everything up to factory spec, mounted the base and scope myself following all factory guidelines. In the last couple months, I managed 2 range trips with the rifle, and put 40 rounds of factory Federal Gold Match 168 BTHP, the older blue/white box. Lot # 214452Y359. Cleaned the chamber and barrel after each trip. Never noticed any issue from last 2 range sessions. I kept all 40 brass from the two boxes of Federal ammo.

    On a prefect day, with great conditions, and sand bagged front and back… I managed my best 3 shot group (below).





    TODAY:

    Fast forward to today’s range session. Shooting the same factory Federal Gold Match 168 BTHP (blue/white), same lot number. First 2 rounds was good, third round fed, fired and impacted without issue but noticed extra smoke leaking out of the bolt area in the rear. Knew something was not right so I ejected the case and noticed a ruptured case. Pulled bolt out, checked face and chamber… noticed no deformation or anything visual that would state an issue other than the ruptured case from weak brass. I chuck it up as a deformed/weak brass... understanding that even factory match rounds can and will have issues.

    I must say that I was still unsure about chambering the fourth round; a picture of a grenading receiver did cross my mind. .. so I sand bagged it up and shot the next 2 rounds while protecting myself, just in case. I know, it was probably a dumb move and I could have gotten hurt... but my “need to shoot” got the better of my judgement. Anyways… nothing happened so I went back to normal shooting. All was good with the next couple rounds, with no effect in accuracy… until my 15th round of the same box, and it happened again. This time, I completely stopped and called it quits.

    Went home, inspected the chamber and bolt face but noticed no unusual deformation, cracks, etc. It got me thinking and I went back to check my other 2 boxes of brass from the last 2 range trip. Sure enough, I located 1 single case ruptured brass… which I didn’t notice before. But I don’t know which trip it came from, not that it matters. Here’s some pictures of the 3 effected brass, I highlighted the extractor marking with blue highlighter.





    At first, I was thinking something is wrong with the chamber, maybe unsupported area that’s allowing the brass to rupture… but then I noticed that the extractor mark is not in the same place as it compares to the ruptured area… so that puts holes in my theory. Unless the whole area is cut badly at the base of the chamber. But I’m no expert and not sure how to check.

    Here’s picture of all the brass from the 3 range trip.



    Last edited by NewbieDave; 08-25-2015, 4:58 PM.
  • #2
    NewbieDave
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2006
    • 1277

    Continued...

    Buddy looks over the brass and tells me its over-pressure and probably a brass issue. He mentioned tight match chamber may be causing a bullet set back. OR that my factory loads may have issues... so he recommended my to mic the remaining rounds to see how they compared.



    I immediately noticed that #1 was off a little and #2 was off a lot… but I don’t know what that really means as it compares to my issue. I don’t reload and have always shot Federal Gold Match out of my older Win70 without issues so I’m kind of at a lost. I know the ammo is old, probably 8+ years old but it’s always been stored correctly and not exposed to heat/cold. This factory Federal ammo is NOS that I brought from CMP couple years back when they found a stash of it at their warehouse and sold it, I still have 340 rounds left with the same lot number.

    If it’s possible chamber/barrel issue… I’m sure the shop would make it right. I just don’t want to be shipping this thing across the US just so that the shop can say it’s an ammo issue. If you guys think it’s an ammo issue, I’ll be contacting Federal next to get some answers. Someone mentioned that I should contact CMP because they were sure that they will make it right before Federal would even get back to me.

    I’m just looking for opinions and options on what I should be looking at… I just want to make sure it’s NOT a gun issue, cause I really really like this rifle and setup.

    Thanks,,
    dpc
    Last edited by NewbieDave; 08-25-2015, 4:01 AM.

    Comment

    • #3
      TKM
      Onward through the fog!
      CGN Contributor
      • Jul 2002
      • 10657

      Bad lot number 214452Y194 was mentioned on Arf.com.

      It's not PTSD, it's nostalgia.

      Comment

      • #4
        LynnJr
        Calguns Addict
        • Jan 2013
        • 7959

        My guess would be bad brass.
        If it was seperating horizontally around the casehead it might be the chamber but splits running longitudinal usually mean bad brass.

        On the overall length you can only measure it that way with sorted bullets that have had the meplats trimmed. Get yourself a comparator for measuring.

        Next if you look at the cases mouth as you rotate the case in your fingers you want the smoke that is left on the case to look like a sine wave and yours does.
        Next take some fired rounds that didn't rupture and slowly roll them across something very flat like a piece of glass while watching the firing pin strike. It should be perfectly centered in a trued of action. If it looks off center the action isn't trued.
        Lynn Dragoman, Jr.
        Southwest Regional Director
        Unlimited Range Shooters Association (URSA)
        www.unlimitedrange.org
        Not a commercial business.
        URSA - Competition starts at 2000 yards!

        Comment

        • #5
          ar15barrels
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Jan 2006
          • 57202

          Originally posted by TKM
          Bad lot number 214452Y194 was mentioned on Arf.com.

          http://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.ht...&f=16&t=657179
          The cases in that thread have the exact same failure mode as the ones in this thread.
          That's some wild co-incidence.
          The lot numbers are very close too...
          Randall Rausch

          AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
          Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
          Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
          Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
          Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

          Comment

          • #6
            crowbar
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2005
            • 563

            Federal Gold Medal Match; great ammo using *****ty brass.

            Comment

            • #7
              NewbieDave
              Senior Member
              • Feb 2006
              • 1277

              Randall,

              Yeah... I read that whole thread, don't think it's a coincidence at all, will be contacting Federal about this. And if I get the same result as the Arfcommer... maybe I can contact CMP and see if they are willing to help me out. Worst case is that I buy a handloader, break down the rounds and reloaded it... probably get better accuracy.

              Now, the bigger question... is my rifle damaged in any way? And how I can go about checking everything, like what am I looking for?

              dpc



              Originally posted by ar15barrels
              The cases in that thread have the exact same failure mode as the ones in this thread.
              That's some wild co-incidence.
              The lot numbers are very close too...
              Last edited by NewbieDave; 08-25-2015, 4:57 PM.

              Comment

              • #8
                ar15barrels
                I need a LIFE!!
                • Jan 2006
                • 57202

                Originally posted by NewbieDave
                Now, the bigger question... is my rifle damaged in any way? And how I can go about checking everything, like what am I looking for?
                Look for pitting in the chamber like is seen on the boltface in this thread:
                Last edited by ar15barrels; 08-25-2015, 5:04 PM.
                Randall Rausch

                AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                Comment

                • #9
                  NewbieDave
                  Senior Member
                  • Feb 2006
                  • 1277

                  I looked over the chamber as best I can, cant get a good pic but the bolt looks good to my untrained eye.





                  Also got a call from Federal, same outcome as the Arfcom thread... "Your ammo is 20 years old, and the brass is deteriorating and weakening, causing your issue. Can't replace, go kick rocks."

                  But I got a call back from the shop that built it... was told that my rifle is built like a tank and should be no issue. The smith even say that he probably would use the ammo and toss the brass after... weak brass is disheartening but if it didn't blow it up the first time, it won't blow it up period.

                  but I'm not going to take the chance... I'll put it aside and see if CMP would do anything about it.



                  Originally posted by ar15barrels
                  Look for pitting in the chamber like is seen on the boltface in this thread:
                  http://www.calguns.net/calgunforum/s....php?t=1107093

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    vliberatore
                    CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                    CGN Contributor
                    • Dec 2011
                    • 10055

                    Originally posted by NewbieDave

                    Also got a call from Federal, same outcome as the Arfcom thread... "Your ammo is 20 years old, and the brass is deteriorating and weakening, causing your issue. Can't replace, go kick rocks."
                    You should mention my 50 year old LC M118LR that has zero issues.
                    Originally posted by fighterpilot562
                    Damn it man! We could have got drunk, called a taxi and drop by Kest house with a mega phone.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      ar15barrels
                      I need a LIFE!!
                      • Jan 2006
                      • 57202

                      HELP: rupturing case on a custom Rem700 SA

                      Originally posted by vliberatore
                      You should mention my 50 year old LC M118LR that has zero issues.

                      I don't think there has BEEN M118LR made for 50yrs.
                      M118 is approaching 50yrs as a spec, but not the LR...

                      M118LR seems to date to sometime just after 1993.
                      In the late 1950’s the United States military adopted the M14 battle rifle and M60 machine gun as standard combat arms incorporating the 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge which was the newly adopted NATO round. At this particular point in time the US Military had fallen back into the cycle of disbanding official snipers among its combat... Read more »
                      Randall Rausch

                      AR work: www.ar15barrels.com
                      Handguns: www.handgunbarrels.com
                      Bolt actions: www.700barrels.com
                      Foreign Semi Autos: www.akbarrels.com
                      Most work done while you wait on a scheduled shop visit.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        vliberatore
                        CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                        CGN Contributor
                        • Dec 2011
                        • 10055

                        Originally posted by ar15barrels
                        I don't think there has BEEN M118LR made for 50yrs.
                        M118 is approaching 50yrs as a spec, but not the LR...

                        M118LR seems to date to sometime just after 1993.
                        http://www.snipercentral.com/history-m118-ammunition/
                        I assumed it was LR (didn't want to go in the basement and check), but you're probably right.

                        In any case, it's a 1967 headstamp.
                        Originally posted by fighterpilot562
                        Damn it man! We could have got drunk, called a taxi and drop by Kest house with a mega phone.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          russ69
                          Calguns Addict
                          • Nov 2009
                          • 9348

                          Originally posted by NewbieDave
                          ...Also got a call from Federal, same outcome as the Arfcom thread... "Your ammo is 20 years old, and the brass is deteriorating and weakening, causing your issue. Can't replace, go kick rocks."...
                          No BS, the manufacturer is telling you that the brass has lost some of it's properties over time. I have heard of this but can't find any supporting evidence on the web but I think the manufacturer knows it's products.
                          sigpic

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Noonanda
                            Veteran Member
                            • Oct 2005
                            • 3404

                            NewbieDave, have you had that ammo for a while or did you recently buy it? because if you bought it recently the manufacturer doesnt have a leg to stand on because it is obviously still in circulation.
                            "You see in this world theres two kinds of people my friend. Those with loaded guns, and those who dig... You Dig" Blondie from TGBU

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              AFTII
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2014
                              • 1617

                              Federal has always had crap brass, i.e., the primer pockets loosen up after one or two shots and they are useless. But, I've never seen them fail like that before. That's a serious defect.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1