Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Basic Pistol Question

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Newbieshooter101
    Junior Member
    • Oct 2013
    • 64

    Basic Pistol Question

    Can I use a 10rd mag in a 15rd-gun?

    I'm trying to SSE two Sigs. Both of which have high capacity mags, one is 14rd and the other is 15rd or something like that. Personally, I don't care about the mags. They can just give me the guns, and I'll buy the CA-compliant mags myself. But I'm not sure if the high-capacity guns would be compatible to 10rd mags. I've seen people buying guns with high cap mags only to have them block into 10rd. Can you just simply swap out the mags?

    Just want to check with you guys first before pulling the trigger.
  • #2
    rbarker33
    Member
    • Sep 2008
    • 119

    As long as they are compatible you have no issue. Manufacturers usually make various mag sizes for different markets - 10 rnds for CA, perhaps 14 or 15 for other states. But, the easier and cheaper way is to simply have your FFL block them at 10 rnd. For H&K Pistols, a 10 rnd mag for the P30L is $70. Most FFL's will pin them for $5 or $10.

    Comment

    • #3
      Newbieshooter101
      Junior Member
      • Oct 2013
      • 64

      Originally posted by rbarker33
      As long as they are compatible you have no issue. Manufacturers usually make various mag sizes for different markets - 10 rnds for CA, perhaps 14 or 15 for other states. But, the easier and cheaper way is to simply have your FFL block them at 10 rnd. For H&K Pistols, a 10 rnd mag for the P30L is $70. Most FFL's will pin them for $5 or $10.
      How easy is it to unblock the mags should I later move to a free state?


      Thanks

      Comment

      • #4
        tophatjones
        Senior Member
        • Jan 2007
        • 1539

        Generally speaking, no. Magwells for 14-15 round magazines are longer than magwells for 10 round mags. (ie. Glock 26 mags are too short for Glock 19). However, some gun manufacturers (like Glock) actually make 10 round mags in longer bodies that will work in the longer magwells.

        Comment

        • #5
          tophatjones
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2007
          • 1539

          Originally posted by Newbieshooter101
          How easy is it to unblock the mags should I later move to a free state?


          Thanks
          I have seen some where the mag follower had an extra piece welded below that prevents the follower from going lower than 10 rounds. Should be as simple as replacing the follower when you move (obviously Don't do it while in CA).

          Comment

          • #6
            Marquand
            Senior Member
            • Feb 2013
            • 1482

            Just a quick point of clarification...If you purchase a magazine designed for you particular pistol it will fit and function regardless of capacity because it will be the same size. Example: A Glock 17 pistol magazine will always fit and function in a Glock 17 whether it has a 17 round or a 10 round capacity. Tophatjones is correct that a physically smaller mag obviously won't fit in a longer magazine well but if you stick with factory magazines designed for your particular model of handgun then they will function.
            "A vote is like a rifle; it's usefulness depends upon the character of the user." - Theodore Roosevelt

            Comment

            • #7
              KahrGuy9
              Banned
              • Aug 2014
              • 198

              Originally posted by tophatjones
              Generally speaking, no. Magwells for 14-15 round magazines are longer than magwells for 10 round mags. (ie. Glock 26 mags are too short for Glock 19). However, some gun manufacturers (like Glock) actually make 10 round mags in longer bodies that will work in the longer magwells.
              For any small frame Glock (G17/G22), or large frame (G21/G20), the magazines are the same length whether it's 17 rounds of 9mm or 15 rounds of 40S&W, or 10 rounds of 9/40, or 10 rounds of 10mm or 15 rounds of 10mm. The larger magazines fit the smaller guns, ie, a G17 mag fits both a G19 and G26, but not the other way around.

              Comment

              • #8
                Newbieshooter101
                Junior Member
                • Oct 2013
                • 64

                Here's the gun's specs.

                Sig Sauer P229 Equinox 9mm

                Item Number: E29R-9-EQ

                Caliber: 9mm

                Action Type: auto

                Trigger Pull DA: 10.0 lbs

                Trigger Pull SA: 4.4 lbs

                Overall Length: 7.4 in

                Overall Height: 5.1 in

                Overall Width: 1.6 in

                Barrel Length: 3.9 in

                Sight Radius: 5.7 in

                Weight w/Mag: 32.0 oz

                Mag Capacity: 15 RoundsCapture.jpg

                Comment

                • #9
                  unusedusername
                  Veteran Member
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 4124

                  Please ignore the confusion added by tophatjones. He is talking about compatibility of magazines between different guns, not about compatibility of mags in different capacities made for the same gun.

                  In "Sig" terms tophatjones would be saying that a P229 (shorter) mag does not fit into a P226. While that it true, it isn't related to the question that Newbieshooter101 asked.

                  Newbieshooter101, to answer your question of "What 10 round magazines work in a P229 Equinox 9mm (E29R-9-EQ)"
                  • 10 round 9mm "P229-1" mags that you posted an image of will work perfectly fine in a 9mm P229, even one sold in California.
                  • The older style "P229" (notice the lack of "-1" at the end) 10 round 9mm magazines also fit in that gun but they are slightly skinnier so they might be able to wiggle around in the magwell a little. They work 100% and can sometimes be found at significant discounts since they are older.
                  • The older style "P228" 10 round 9mm magazines also fit. "P228" and "P229" magazines in 9mm are identical.
                  • You can additionally use 10 round 9mm P226 mags, but they will stick out a little from the bottom of the mag well and you might pinch yourself.
                  • The 10 round P229 22lr conversion kit magazines will work in that gun while the conversion kit is installed, as long as it isn't the "California" version with a magazine disconnect. The magazine disconnect prevents the 22lr conversion kit from functioning properly. If you SSE that model of the gun then the conversion kit and associated magazines will work.
                  • If you were to purchase a slide in a different caliber for your firearm (say .357 Sig, or .40 S&W), then the 10 round P229-1, P229, and P226 magazines for those calibers would work with the proper slide assembly installed. Sig calls these slide assemblies "Caliber X-Change kits".


                  I highly recommend magazines made by Mec-Gar for Sigs. They are considered the highest quality. Avoid anything made by Pro-Mag for Sigs. They don't work.

                  The only difference between a 10 round mag and a 15 round p229 mag is that the 10 rounder either has a plastic base (old style) that makes the inside shorter, or (new style) has a different follower that won't compress all the way down.

                  Additionally, to try to answer "How easy is it to unblock the mags should I later move to a free state?"

                  It depends on how the magazines were reduced to 10 round capacity. The law requires "permanent" modification, without defining "permanent". This could mean anything from changing the follower, which requires purchasing a different follower to restore normal capacity, all the way to using a different magazine body that can not easily be made to hold more then 10.

                  If I were to move, I would sell many of my 10 rounders locally before I moved then purchase new normal-capacity magazines after the move.
                  Last edited by unusedusername; 09-10-2014, 3:57 PM.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Newbieshooter101
                    Junior Member
                    • Oct 2013
                    • 64

                    Originally posted by unusedusername
                    Newbieshooter101, to answer your question of "What 10 round magazines work in a P229 Equinox 9mm (E29R-9-EQ)"
                    • 10 round 9mm "P229-1" mags that you posted an image of will work perfectly fine in a 9mm P229, even one sold in California.
                    • The older style "P229" (notice the lack of "-1" at the end) 10 round 9mm magazines also fit in that gun but they are slightly skinnier so they might be able to wiggle around in the magwell a little. They work 100% and can sometimes be found at significant discounts since they are older.
                    • The older style "P228" 10 round 9mm magazines also fit. "P228" and "P229" magazines in 9mm are identical.
                    • You can additionally use 10 round 9mm P226 mags, but they will stick out a little from the bottom of the mag well and you might pinch yourself.
                    • The 10 round P229 22lr conversion kit magazines will work in that gun while the conversion kit is installed, as long as it isn't the "California" version with a magazine disconnect. The magazine disconnect prevents the 22lr conversion kit from functioning properly. If you SSE that model of the gun then the conversion kit and associated magazines will work.
                    • If you were to purchase a slide in a different caliber for your firearm (say .357 Sig, or .40 S&W), then the 10 round P229-1, P229, and P226 magazines for those calibers would work with the proper slide assembly installed. Sig calls these slide assemblies "Caliber X-Change kits".


                    I highly recommend magazines made by Mec-Gar for Sigs. They are considered the highest quality. Avoid anything made by Pro-Mag for Sigs. They don't work.

                    The only difference between a 10 round mag and a 15 round p229 mag is that the 10 rounder either has a plastic base (old style) that makes the inside shorter, or (new style) has a different follower that won't compress all the way down.

                    Additionally, to try to answer "How easy is it to unblock the mags should I later move to a free state?"

                    It depends on how the magazines were reduced to 10 round capacity. The law requires "permanent" modification, without defining "permanent". This could mean anything from changing the follower, which requires purchasing a different follower to restore normal capacity, all the way to using a different magazine body that can not easily be made to hold more then 10.

                    If I were to move, I would sell many of my 10 rounders locally before I moved then purchase new normal-capacity magazines after the move.
                    This is the kind of answer I was looking for. Thanks so much

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Barang
                      CGN Contributor
                      • Aug 2013
                      • 13606

                      When I bought my P229 in 9mm it had one 12 round mag which was blocked to 10 round to make it ca-compliant.
                      Later, I bought four P229 10 round mags and they fit perfectly.

                      As long as you buy 10 round mag/s that's specific to you gun, you'll not have any problems.

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Newbieshooter101
                        Junior Member
                        • Oct 2013
                        • 64

                        Originally posted by Barang
                        When I bought my P229 in 9mm it had one 12 round mag which was blocked to 10 round to make it ca-compliant.
                        Later, I bought four P229 10 round mags and they fit perfectly.

                        As long as you buy 10 round mag/s that's specific to you gun, you'll not have any problems.
                        I'm crystal clear now. Thank you for sharing

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          Barang
                          CGN Contributor
                          • Aug 2013
                          • 13606

                          Originally posted by Newbieshooter101
                          I'm crystal clear now. Thank you for sharing
                          Groovy!

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            tophatjones
                            Senior Member
                            • Jan 2007
                            • 1539

                            Sorry for the confusion guys. My post made sense to me at the time, but I can see now that it's confusing.

                            An OEM ten round mag designed for your specific model gun will work in that gun. (ie. Glock 19 ten rounders will work in a Glock 19.)

                            A ten round mag designed for a shorter magwell will not fit. (ie. Glock 26 ten rounders won't fit in a Glock 19)

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            UA-8071174-1