Solid guide rods for Sigs

[Planetking]

I'm looking for the voices of experience;

Is there any real benefit to solid / stainless guide rods?
I shoot 2-4 times a month, so probably 3000+ rounds annually, per weapon. Also, as long as I'm at it, how often is prudent for spring replacement?

Thanks in advance

[lordres]

I had to replace recoil, hammer, and trigger return springs at about 10k.

As far as solid guide rods go, the theory is, heavier front end, less muzzle flip. Probably won't be able to notice the difference.

[9mmepiphany]

I'm looking for the voices of experience

The only benefit of a solid rod is cosmetic...looks pretty.

I've tried them side-by side on a pair of P6s and a pair of 220STs and there wasn't a lick of difference worth mentioning.

Springs should be replace at 3500 rounds, but you could stretch it to 5000.

The most important thing to do to prolong the useful life of the SIG is to lube the rails with grease and not oil

[uhlan1]

Most think there is no or not much difference with polymers like Glocks. Never even thought of putting one in one of my all steel Sigs. Be a waste of money imo.

[Mojave Desert]

I replaced the hollow steel tube guide rod on my P6 with a solid stainless steel guide rod. I did notice a small reduction in muzzle flip.

[mej16489]

I have a first gen P229 with easily more then 12k rounds through it. I've never replaced anything and it still shoots like new.

[Planetking]

Sounds like I can buy a box of ammo, instead of unnecessary toys. Thanks for the input, much appreciated!

I am aware of the Sig 'wet operation' preference and maintain accordingly.

Have only ever had one FTE, and I know the cause ~ it was a premature limpwristed flyer...

[JDay]

Save your money.

Sent from my SGH-T999 using Tapatalk 2

[barca101]

I purchased a black Grayguns Fat Guide Rod for my Sig 229R. The guide rod is heavier than the OEM steel one. Other than it looks good, it doesn't do anything else that the OEM part can't do. Save your money.