Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

1911 help

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • lincoln6echo
    Member
    • Mar 2008
    • 198

    1911 help

    I'm looking at picking up a 1911 and wanted to ask how big of a difference there is in performance between something like a S&W DK vs. a Wilson CQB. I know the Wilson is the superior weapon but do you really feel the $1k+ difference or does this start to enter the diminishing returns area?

    edit - This will be for range use, some csmping/plinking but could end up as my nightstand gun if it proves to be near as reliable as my HK.
  • #2
    slick_711
    Veteran Member
    • Feb 2006
    • 4400

    No, the difference between a Springfield/Kimber/Colt and a $2k Wilson is not something the "average shooter" will notice (or may notice but will not feel was worth $1k extra). A big part of the price difference is branding and people wanting to be a bit more unique (you hit it on the head with the phrase diminishing returns). Get one of the higher end Springfield/Kimber/Colts. You'll be more than happy and it will last you a lifetime.

    If you do feel like paying extra for the name and a better gun, get a Baer. Superior to the Wilson and less expensive.
    Last edited by slick_711; 04-16-2008, 9:19 PM.

    Comment

    • #3
      aplinker
      I need a LIFE!!
      • Feb 2007
      • 16762

      Performance? Probably none.

      The DK S&Ws are very accurate.

      The difference is in fit/finish. The DKs are nice, but the Wilson is a true custom shop gun that's built out by them en-masse.

      The line between top factory and semi-custom guns is getting blurrier, too.

      For the money of the Wilson, though, I'd rather have a true custom. Since we're in CA we have set models from Wilson with no variations.

      Google Map of OLL Dealers

      List of CA-friendly Manufacturers, Dealers, Middlemen, and Magazine rebuild kit dealers
      Click me-->So you're a n00b and you want to build an AR? <--Click me
      This post is based on actual events. Some facts may be altered for dramatic purposes. All posts are pure opinion. All persons, living and dead, are purely coincidental, and should not be construed.

      Comment

      • #4
        lincoln6echo
        Member
        • Mar 2008
        • 198

        I also was also considering the Spingfield MC Operator but I've read almost nothing bad about the S&W DK and for the price it seems hard to beat. I'd love to have a Wilson or Brown but I don't want to put $2k into something that really doesn't knock my socks off when compared to the $1k arena 1911's.

        Comment

        • #5
          DesertGunner
          Member
          • Jan 2008
          • 336

          I've had this exact same argument with one of my friends many times.

          He has a $2300 Wilson CWB with tactical cone barrel, phaser, etc.
          I have a $700 S&W 1911.

          Mine is better in every respect (IMHO) and you could buy 3 S&Ws for the price of 1 Wilson.

          Comment

          • #6
            CSDGuy
            Veteran Member
            • Mar 2007
            • 3763

            I own a Springfield 1911A-1. Nice gun. A friend of mine owns a Kimber CDP II. Very nice gun. They shoot about the same, but his feels better. He paid about twice what I did. It's worth it, but the folks that think so are familiar with 1911's and can feel the difference. New shooters or those that aren't as familiar with 1911's probably won't feel the difference or if they can, won't think it's worth the money.

            Comment

            • #7
              JTROKS
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Nov 2007
              • 13093

              I've held s S&W DK and a PC 1911 and couldn't really tell which one is better except I like checkering on the PC. Both are built tight and smooth. Too bad I could dry fire them, they wouldn't let me. Asthough the new front strap of the DK will be better once it is checkered. A standard S&W 1911 are also built solid. I'd take the PC or DK over a Wilson.
              The wise man said just find your place
              In the eye of the storm
              Seek the roses along the way
              Just beware of the thorns...
              K. Meine

              Comment

              • #8
                Knifemaker
                Senior Member
                • Jul 2007
                • 576

                Yep I would go with a factory built gun in the $800-$1200 range. I think you would be very happy with one of these.

                Comment

                • #9
                  ohsmily
                  Calguns Addict
                  • Apr 2005
                  • 8997

                  Originally posted by DesertGunner
                  Mine is better in every respect (IMHO) and you could buy 3 S&Ws for the price of 1 Wilson.
                  What respects are those? Can you please elaborate?
                  Expert firearms attorney: https://www.rwslaw.com/team/adam-j-richards/

                  Check out https://www.firearmsunknown.com/. Support a good calgunner local to San Diego.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Max-the-Silent
                    Senior Member
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 786

                    If you're an average end user the Smith will do fine.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      BlackDrop50
                      Senior Member
                      • Mar 2008
                      • 1023

                      I bought a Kimber, had problems with it during break-in, 400-600 rounds. Now is flawless for the past 500-600 rounds. Not one FTF FTE. Very accurate. I bought a Les Baer during break-in with the Kimber, haven't got it yet, but now that the Kimber is fine, I almost wish I had just bought a bunch of more different toys.... oh well... we'll see once the LB gets here.


                      The real question is?

                      DO YOU HAVE MONEY TO BURN?

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        FatOnCoke
                        Member
                        • Feb 2008
                        • 379

                        Originally posted by DesertGunner
                        He has a $2300 Wilson CWB with tactical cone barrel, phaser, etc.
                        I have a $700 S&W 1911.

                        Mine is better in every respect (IMHO) and you could buy 3 S&Ws for the price of 1 Wilson.
                        ONLY if your humble opinion of better = cheaper!

                        Better = Greater in excellence or higher in quality than another of the same class, set, or kind.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          lincoln6echo
                          Member
                          • Mar 2008
                          • 198

                          My local shop did not have any S&W 1911's but I made the mistake of fondling a Ed Brown Special Forces and compared it to a Wilson CQB, a couple Kimbers and a couple Springer (mil spec, loaded, etc.)

                          I don't know what it would feel like to shoot them and compare but the Brown stood out to me. Fit, finish and overall feel in my hand was very impressive. The slide was amazingly smooth and the trigger felt perfect... perfect weight and 0 creep when I dry fired it a couple times. Now I wish I hadn't even gone in there!

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            RECCE556
                            Senior Member
                            • Oct 2006
                            • 1221

                            if you decide to buy the S&W, make sure you THROUGHLY inspect the gun. Look at the breech face and make sure it's machined completely (compare it to a Wilson side by side). S&W likes to save CNC time and sometimes doesn't completely machine the slides correctly. Also check the barrel lug stop as people have had this area also incompletely machined and suffered broken barrel lugs and pins after a while. Slide to frame fit is lacking (mine had some seriously uneven wear)

                            Also check to make sure all the safeties work. S&W 1911's sometimes have timing issues. Check the serrations...they don't do the best job on these. Also check to make sure various parts aren't loose. Their loose triggers are pretty well known and they've had problems with their plunger tubes coming off.

                            The external extractors have also loss spring tension after some use/time so keep an eye on that and on some of the older ones that had the MIM slide stops, these have been know to snap in half. S&W changed to a billet or forged unit from what I heard. Their slide finish also isn't very good.

                            Outside of that, it should be great!

                            After I had all the problems with my S&W1911, I got rid of it...after it went back to S&W a few times to continually fix problems. What frickin' waste of time that gun was. At this point, for me to take a S&W1911, it would have to be dirt, I mean DIRT cheap and it would have to be the Scandium frame version only. Then I would pretty much strip it down completely and I would only keep the Scandium frame and build it up using better parts from another manufacturer.

                            Here's the way I look at it when you compare something like a Wilson Combat to the S&W1911...it's like comparing cars. If you break it down to the basics (four wheels, they steer and they accelerate), then yeah, they're the same. But when you start looking at the craftsmanship, the build quality, the quality control and the quality of the materials and parts, you'll see that the Wilson's (and other like Ed Brow, Les Baer, Nighthawk) are superior. That's what you're paying for. Wilson's do tend to be a bit more expensive then the other factory customs I mentioned and in this case, I don't think the Wilson's are worth the extra cash (which is why I have a Ed Brown)

                            Will the S&W or other basic 1911 shoot? Sure, they may even be accurate (and in the case of S&W, you might actually get one that's made correctly!) but I think in a large sampling, you'll find that the factory customs are more accurate. The trigger pull, the safeties and control will also be better. I've yet to find any standard 1911 to match any higher end 1911 in these terms (and I have a lot of 1911's and fondled more 1911's then I care to admit)

                            If you want a good basic 1911, get a Colt XSE or a used Springer Loaded if you can find one for cheap. I think Springfield's "new" price on the Loaded models is a bit too much. I'd stay away from the "base" models unless you want to customize it....in which case, buy TWO. One to shoot while you wait for the other one to get back.

                            edit: I see you got to fondle an Ed Brown...now you know the difference.
                            Last edited by RECCE556; 04-17-2008, 7:55 PM.

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              RECCE556
                              Senior Member
                              • Oct 2006
                              • 1221

                              Originally posted by DesertGunner
                              I've had this exact same argument with one of my friends many times.

                              He has a $2300 Wilson CWB with tactical cone barrel, phaser, etc.
                              I have a $700 S&W 1911.

                              Mine is better in every respect (IMHO) and you could buy 3 S&Ws for the price of 1 Wilson.
                              So if the Wilson *CQB* and your S&W1911 were the same price, you'd still take the S&W? I'm pretty sure that if they were the same price, even a 1911 noob would be all over the CQB.

                              Also, I'm pretty sure the fit and finish on your S&W isn't as good as the Wilson. I think you might like it more because it's yours.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1