getting a .22lr conversion kit vs. a .22lr gun

[bayonet]

I want to start shooting some .22lr and I want a range pistol that shoots it. Is it more practical to get a .22lr conversion kit for a P229 or CZ75 than getting a gun designed for .22lr like a Ruger 22/45 or Mosquito? I think the prices are about similar if I get a used gun. Thanks

[jmaglipay]

I say get a dedicated .22 pistol. I bought a Kimber conversation kit and I'm disappointed at it. It's ammo picky and mine has quality issue. First week I took it out, the front sight fell off. Took Kimber 2 months to repair it. The manual recommends to use cci mini mags. Which are expensive and is I use bulk rounds about 10-20 ftf and free for every 100 rnd. Also the finish on the ejector side is already coming off just from the casing ejecting. I bought a 22lr single action revolver as a second option.

[rabidmonk]

I've got the TacSol conversion for my Glock 17, and the Beretta 22lr conversion for my M92. Both work fine, though the TacSol is pickier on ammo. I also have dedicated 22lr revolvers and a Ruger SR22P. I'd say if you want to train on a specific platform on the cheap, get a conversion. If you don't care and just want to shoot a 22lr handgun, get a dedicated one. You really aren't saving that much money on a conversion kit.

[wild_weasel]

I have both a Ruger MkIII Stanard in 22lr along with 22lr conversions for my 1911A1. Both are great fun to shoot. But these days I have been having the most fun with a CMMG 22lr conversion in my S&W MP-15 Sport. It allows me to shoot it at the local indorr without having to drive across town to Field Time or to angeles. But with the cost of the Kimber 22lr conversion these days you may be better off buying a dedicated pistol. Good luck finding 22lr ammo however.

Cheers,
W-W

[Oceanbob]

Get a new .22 handgun. Also, in my opinion, stay away from the SIG. Ruger does it well. Have fun!

[r1ghtw1ng]

Anyone have any feedback on the GSG 1911 .22LR drop-in slide/barrel/mag combo? $200 on PSA. LINK I think it was on sale for $170 awhile back... I was tempted but didn't pull the trigger.

[IPSICK]

A Ruger Mark II/III and a 22/45 are excellent and many variations are reasonably priced. If you want to splurge, an S&W 41. The 41 has one of the best triggers of ANY handgun out there.

I tried a Glock conversion once and it jammed way too much and the finish wore off too easily for the price I paid for it. I've heard of a lot of good things about Marvel conversions for the 1911, but for the price you might as well get a good 22/45.

[BanjoGunner]

I have an Advantage Arms kit for a G17; it has been reliable with a variety of ammo including Remington Golden Bullets and allows me to train using the same trigger as my HD firearm. The main disadvantage is that due to its lack of recoil, it adversely affects my 9mm recoil management. I offset this to some degree by always finishing the day firing a box or two of 9mm, which also confirms that the G17 has been properly reassembled and is functioning. (Trust, but verify...)

So I picked up a Ruger Mark III to practice with as well and really like it. I guess because the grip/function/etc of the Mark III is different (enough) from the Glock, it gets filed into a different area of muscle memory and as a result practice on the Mark III does not adversely affect 9mm recoil management. I still use the Advantage Arms kit, but a bit less than I use the Mark III.

So my recommendation is to eventually get both, but start with a dedicated .22.

[billofrights]

Another vote for a dedicated .22 pistol. I was looking at conversion kits for my G17, but for the price I just got a Walther P22. Great little gun, I'm getting much more range time in, and when I do go back to the 9mm my technique has improved, so all around a good investment.

[vintagearms]

I personally dont see the point in getting a dedicated .22 pistol. I would prefer to shoot my AA Glock conversion since it aids in muscle memory and is the same trigger, manipulations, etc. Recoil management is a non issue as your going to be accurate or not accurate regardless.
Mine has had some hiccups but that was with cheap ammo. CCI mini mag and Wolf MT have been accurate and flawless.

[desertexplore]

Tagged, Im in the same boat with the OP.

[CasperSYTFU]

I've got the Kadet .22 conversion for my CZ 75B.
I prefer the conversion since I get more trigger time on one gun, so as it breaks in you get really used to it rather than switching back and forth.

My conversion eats Fed Bulk 22 no problem.

[aca72]

My vote: .22LR handgun

Rugers are great! The Ruger SR22 is fun. Stay away from Mosquitos and Walthers.

[Caseless]

Get a whole gun.
I started with getting 22LR adapter kits for each pistol type I use the most, but bought duplicate centerfire pistols later. So there is no need to disassemble/reassemble a bunch of 22LR slides every time going to the range.

[chickenfried]

I own a ruger MKII, I've owned both a marvel unit II and I but I'm still confused about which way to go.