3” S&W m19 w/comp or 2” Kimber K6

[acaligunner]

Looking for opinions on the S&W 3” m19 with comp, and the Kimber 2” ( I like the look of the 2”, but may get the 3” model ) 357 magnums. How do you like them and what did you not like. Thank you.

[TheFlashG]

I had the K6s (DAO) version of the Kimber revolver. Truly a "Cadillac" of revolvers! Very nicely finished and smoooth. I'm just too much of a DA/SA revolver guy (need an exposed hammer), so I sold that Kimber.
I have several S&W 686's and love 'em! Don't know about the Comp or PC versions of the M19, but I would definitely recommend either the M19 or M66 in short barrel. Great revolvers and do try to handle the one you buy first for 'feel' and that you'll like it.

[acaligunner]

Thank you appreciate the post 🙂.

[P5Ret]

I faced a similar dilemma a few years back. After some research and finding the only speed loader for the Kimber at the time was $30 a pop, I went with a Smith.

[stormvet]

I have owned the Smith for about 5 years, one of my favorite wheel guns. Can’t comment on the Kimber never even handled one, but 99% of the time I’ll always take a 3 over a 2 inch barrel.

[acaligunner]

^
Those are nice, and thanks for the post.