Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Looking for a first handgun

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • excal88
    Junior Member
    • Sep 2011
    • 11

    Looking for a first handgun

    Hey guys, so everything finally lined up for me *got money, got my 2 valid forms of CA ID, and got my handgun safety test* so I can now finally look and potentially buy a handgun, rather than drool over the display cases. I was looking for some advice on some of the things I had in mind. Caliber wise, I'm looking at .45 ACP, model wise at the 1911s. However, I'm open to any advice and what not, so although my eyes shine at the 1911, my heart is not set on anything just yet. Usage, I'm looking at mainly recreational shooting, and of course home defense.

    At my local gun range, I rented and shot a lot of pistols, ranging from .22 up to 45, and shot a few different 1911s, ranging from the sig, springfield, browning, and wilson combat. Funny enough I liked the cheapest of that bunch, the sig 1911 and also shot the best with that. In terms of everything else I shot, I shot 9mm with glock and berettas, did not like the feel of either. Shot a .40 smith and wesson, that was pretty nice. And of course shot the ruger 22. I also shot a .357 magnum revolver, smith and wesson from a friend. Couldn't get a good gauge for it since it was reloaded ammo and he didn't put that much grain in the round, so it was slightly skewed for a softer round in terms of recoil.

    In terms of 1911s, how does Rock Island Armory stack up against the other brands? I don't know how they shoot, but I do like the price so I was wondering on what people thought of them. Also, if anyone would give any input on what they think is a reliable * among 1911s* company. I know for the most part all 1911s are generally the same, just the machining process *machined vs hand made, etc etc* so I was curious on what people's opinions were.

    On general handguns, what would you guys recommend? One of my NRA friends recommended a revolver, more specifically a 1890(?) navy 45 revolver since he said its a good platform to learn how to shoot properly. I do have a preference towards semi-auto, but again, its only a preference. Not gonna make a fuss if a revolver is a better choice.

    I know generally the best way to find a handgun is to shoot a lot of different ones, and I have *to the maximum allowance of rentals at my local gun range* tried a decent amount, so now I'm just looking for some pointers from personal experience. Sorry for the wall of text, but I'm looking to make the right first choice Thanks in advance!
  • #2
    m98
    Veteran Member
    • Jul 2005
    • 4088

    Ria 1911 is a decent cheap starter 1911 but qc is kinda hit n miss. You may have to tweak the gun to get it running 100%. My advice is go springfield as they have superb customer service and of all the springfields i've shot and seen shot, i've yet see any major malfunctions not related to el cheapo 5$ mags
    "Screw U guys, I'm going home"...:the great Eric Cartman

    10mm. Because .45ACP just doesn't cut it anymore. <Trailerparktrash>

    Comment

    • #3
      therza2071
      Member
      • Feb 2012
      • 165

      The Rocks are really good shooters, buy with confidence.


      As far as the 1890 .45 revolver goes - well, I've never even heard of one of those, so I'm not sure what he's talking about there. If you want a revolver, just buy a Ruger or Smith.
      RON PAUL 2012

      Comment

      • #4
        CaptBuzz
        Member
        • Mar 2012
        • 177

        Asking for other people's opinion for a gun can turn "Ford vs Chevy" pretty quickly. Do a lot of research and get exactly what YOU want. Don't get anything you can't afford to practice with.

        Comment

        • #5
          MA2
          Senior Member
          • Mar 2009
          • 1129

          G.I. model, go with RIA.

          Rocks work, but as you take it down piece by piece...I find their parts sub-par, parts fitting was just okay (slide to frame was great), you get what you pay for.

          Stepping up, go Springfield Loaded or even Kimber, for better fit and finish.
          Sig's 1911 looks to be a great value as well.

          Comment

          • #6
            S470FM
            Banned
            • Oct 2011
            • 968

            357 has more stopping power than a 45 ACP, it's what I use for HD (SW 686+).

            Comment

            • #7
              excal88
              Junior Member
              • Sep 2011
              • 11

              Thanks for all the replies guys! So far RIA has the most bang for the buck status, but look forward to get some after market parts.

              In terms of HD, I'm probably looking at a handgun fro 85% recreational and 15% HD *unless I move to someplace that'll need it. Hahaha*

              @CaptBuzz
              I've been reading up on a lot of them and asking my local gun stores on what they think, and I've gotten quite a few different answers. Some are saying the RIA are great, others are saying just save up and buy a real nice 1911, so in terms of that line of research its pretty much split. I'd like to shoot a RIA since I've shot the springfield already, but I don't know anyone that has one to rent/borrow.

              @MA2
              It seems a lot of the sig 1911s are out of stock at the moment, but I'm in no rush. But if it turns out that I somehow get to shoot an RIA, I'd like to try the GI model as its simplicity at it's best, and if I like it more than the sig, then I'd go with the RIA.

              Comment

              • #8
                KandyRedCoi
                Senior Member
                • May 2011
                • 1748

                from my experience if you are gonna use this hg for SD/HD and range time and decide to go the 1911 route, i'd get one with a RAIL...and for the price i think the Sig would take the cake

                Kimber and SA 1911 with rails has quite a premium (i own a kimber raptor 2 and just jailed a RIA 38 super in NIckel)

                the RIA as of late has stepped up their game and 99% of the stuff you see and hear about them are GOOD

                as far as revolvers, i can def see the advantages and dis-advantages, its not for everybody
                -Coi- N R A member since 2008
                .177-.22lr-.410-9mm-38spr-.45acp-45lc-7.62x39-7.62x54r-12ga
                ~your friendly neighborhood ZOMBIE hunter~

                Comment

                • #9
                  adrenalinejunkie
                  Senior Member
                  • Dec 2011
                  • 561

                  IMO it all comes doen to your price range and the features you want with the gun. Since you're set on the 1911 i'd assume you want a hammer and safety. 1911's are all metal but some people say they start to break down after higher round counts (I have no experience in this matter and am going off hearsay). If you're looking for the lower price range and don't care about having no hammer, safety, or decocker a glock, M&P, or XD would be a good route. I just bought an FNH FNP .40 because i've heard great things about them, it was within my price range, and had the features that I wanted (hammer and decocker- would've liked a manual safety but the decocker is enough till I have enough money for a USP .45).

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    SantaCabinetguy
                    I need a LIFE!!
                    • Feb 2011
                    • 15137

                    This thread may help you out a bit:


                    But it sounds like you’re set on a 1911 (which is great!) in .45acp.
                    The first 1911 I shot was a springfield Armory some 20 years ago. Great pistol, inexpensive cost, and SA has great customer service.

                    I would give them a look if you can.
                    Hauoli Makahiki Hou


                    -------

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    UA-8071174-1