Which would you buy? **Update**

[caduckgunner]

Between a Sig Pro and a Smith & Wesson Sigma, which one would you get? The Sig is a 9mm, comes with 2 mags and 2 sets of grips and is on sale for $399. The Sigma is either 9mm or .40, SS slide, comes with 2 mags, and is on sale for $319, plus I can get 2 extra mags and $50 back from Smith & Wesson, making the total $269. plus 2 extra magazines. I already own a Sig Pro 2340 in .357 sig w/ a .40 barrel, a P226, and an P229.

[The SoCal Gunner]

Where is it on sale for $399? Since you already own a Sig Pro, I would say neither but if you had to go with one, the Sig Pro.

[yzErnie]

Between the two...Sig all the way.

[IH8CALAWS]

I have a sigma that I have owned for 7 years and I would not recomend it to anyone.It's not acurate at all and the trigger feels like garbage.

[Jeffrock]

Sig pro in 9!

[Black Majik]

It ain't even close, definitely the SIG!

[Ratters]

I've shot two Sig Pros and they were both the equal of my 229. Fantastic handguns, regardless of price.

[Gnote]

What about adding a different manufacturer to the fold? Maybe a M&P? Same rebate/magazine offer applies...

[bwiese]

Fugheddabout the Sigma, get the SigPro.

The Sigma is a short-service-life lower cost firearm for basic personal protection and not a lot of shooting.

It is not comparable to other synthetic guns like the SigPro, the S&W M&P, Glock, XD, etc.

In fact S&W was running an offer recently - buy an S&W M&P pistol and you can buy a Sigma simultaneously for just $99 extra.

[C.G.]

Never shot a SigPro, but if you look at my sig line you will see my Sig line.
Go with the Sig!

[thatsteveguy]

I've owned and shot both, definitly go with the Sig! Here's another idea for you, I bought a Barsto 9mm drop in barrel for my Sig Pro 2340 and now I can shoot 9mm AND 40 cal out of the same gun using the same magazines! These barrels usually go for around 2 bills but you may find a deal at the Sig forum where I found mine. I paid about a hundred for mine and it was flawless.

[Cato]

Sig all the way. They are reliable, accurate, and ergonomic. S&W makes great revolvers. The M&P is OK. The Sigma? That's a Glock knock off. Add to that Jason Bourne kept a SigPro in his safety deposit box in Geneva!

[5968]

Where is it on sale for $399? Since you already own a Sig Pro, I would say neither but if you had to go with one, the Sig Pro.

+1... Why not just get a real Sig?

[Teletiger7]

Save up alittle like everyone says. Then get a Glock, XD, CZ, ETC.

[The SoCal Gunner]

Save up alittle like everyone says. Then get a Glock, XD, CZ, ETC.

I've actually been debating about selling my XD to fund a Glock or Sig. I'd definitely put it towards a Sig classic but wouldn't mind trying the Sig Pros either. If the trigger is as smooth as everyone says they are, then I would not be disappointed. Nothing wrong with the XD whatsoever and I'm quite accurate with it but I guess I got bored with it. I've put it up for sale before but I am not really disappointed that it hasn't sold.

I'm interested to know why all the neithers? Is it because most would rather put that money towards a more expensive gun?