This isn't quite true when it comes to shooting. You didn't address the fact that the costs for practicing an instrument is virtually nil. You can play anytime, anywhere you want for FREE. Shooting is not the same. There are range fees and the costs of ammo. You can say dry fire but even that is still insufficient for grip and front sight familiarity.
The reality is that a good instructor can show you quickly what you're doing wrong and (if they're good) can provide insight on how to correct/learn from it. It's one thing to say, "do x, y, z" but making someone understand what goes into obtaining 'x, y, z' is much trickier. If all it took was the instruction to say, "aim at the black circle and shoot" everyone would be a bullseye shooter. That's obviously not the case.
In terms of the cost, just look at the expense for just a 1000 rounds of 9mm or 1000 rounds of .45. Now multiply that over 6 months, a year, or however much you shoot and you'll see it can potentially reach several hundreds (or $1000's). Taking a 1 on 1 class with an instructor (from prices I've seen/heard) can vary from $200-400 dollars for 2-3 days of instruction. That's why I disagree on the economics of it. Someone good can help you improve immediately after observing you shoot just a few rounds of ammo. Time is also another intangible. For most of people, time is not an overly abundant luxury. If I can reach a better understanding in a much shorter of time (im talking about on the order of weeks or months) then almost certainly that's something worth considering paying for.
I do, however, agree with that you "don't" need to take classes to improve. Reading and understanding proper fundamentals goes a long ways to self improvement. There's a lot of information out there if your google-fu is good. But at the same time, I also know that even professional athletes obtain personal training. Pro-baseball, football, tennis, golf players- all have coaches and personal trainers observing and watching them. Same thing with olympic athletes. They all have trainers to help refine their mechanics. Natural talent is a wonderful thing to have, but how often do you run into true savants or those that are uber-gifted? Virtually everyone else trains with instructors.
The reality is that a good instructor can show you quickly what you're doing wrong and (if they're good) can provide insight on how to correct/learn from it. It's one thing to say, "do x, y, z" but making someone understand what goes into obtaining 'x, y, z' is much trickier. If all it took was the instruction to say, "aim at the black circle and shoot" everyone would be a bullseye shooter. That's obviously not the case.
In terms of the cost, just look at the expense for just a 1000 rounds of 9mm or 1000 rounds of .45. Now multiply that over 6 months, a year, or however much you shoot and you'll see it can potentially reach several hundreds (or $1000's). Taking a 1 on 1 class with an instructor (from prices I've seen/heard) can vary from $200-400 dollars for 2-3 days of instruction. That's why I disagree on the economics of it. Someone good can help you improve immediately after observing you shoot just a few rounds of ammo. Time is also another intangible. For most of people, time is not an overly abundant luxury. If I can reach a better understanding in a much shorter of time (im talking about on the order of weeks or months) then almost certainly that's something worth considering paying for.
I do, however, agree with that you "don't" need to take classes to improve. Reading and understanding proper fundamentals goes a long ways to self improvement. There's a lot of information out there if your google-fu is good. But at the same time, I also know that even professional athletes obtain personal training. Pro-baseball, football, tennis, golf players- all have coaches and personal trainers observing and watching them. Same thing with olympic athletes. They all have trainers to help refine their mechanics. Natural talent is a wonderful thing to have, but how often do you run into true savants or those that are uber-gifted? Virtually everyone else trains with instructors.
Comment