On the last round the follower in the clip presses on the slide stop, slide stop presses on the slide slowing it down to where the slide catches the stop but, the slide has not traveled far enough back to eject the case. Cause; springs too stiff for the load or, load to soft for the spring or, soft grip. A 1911 requires a firm grip and a stiff wrist otherwise you absorb the recoil and the slide doesn't make the full cycle. The shorter the barrel the stiffer the grip needs to be!! Short barreled Kimbers are more prone to this than Colts or Springfields. Me thinks its the spring rate!??
Unconfigured Ad Widget
Collapse
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1911 Expert Help Requested
Collapse
X
-
Me don't.Me thinks its the spring rate!??
He said he has a Custom II. That is a Gov't size gun and a 16# spring is right. Gov't sized 1911's aren't as prone to "break" wristing that causes FTE's and FTF's.
He posted a pic of a gun that wasn't his and showing a problem that he isn't having. It was just a "conversation starter."
Last edited by Kruzr; 05-28-2011, 1:28 AM.Comment
-
Well I performed the test and steps shown in the video.
It wasn't exactly falling out due to gravity or a slight shake, but it was falling out a heck of a lot easier than shown in the video. So I adjusted the tension as shown. Until the test performed as shown in the video.
I also cleaned out the channel and all the internals.
So as soon as the ammo I ordered shows up I will take it to the range and see what happens. Probably won't happen until next weekend...unless I get ancy and decide to pay retail for ammo at the range.
I will report back then.
Thanks for the help guys! Whether this solves the issue or not I learned a lot.Last edited by tacticalcity; 05-27-2011, 11:41 PM.Comment
-
While I do not completely discount this, my Kimber is the 5" and not the shorter model. Given that it is the factory spring and that I am shooting 230 grain Magtech factory new ammo I would think that if anything the spring would been worn out, and not too stiff. After all, I purchased it used. So they might have shot it to the point the spring is starting to wear out. The magazine is new, but the gun is old.On the last round the follower in the clip presses on the slide stop, slide stop presses on the slide slowing it down to where the slide catches the stop but, the slide has not traveled far enough back to eject the case. Cause; springs too stiff for the load or, load to soft for the spring or, soft grip. A 1911 requires a firm grip and a stiff wrist otherwise you absorb the recoil and the slide doesn't make the full cycle. The shorter the barrel the stiffer the grip needs to be!! Short barreled Kimbers are more prone to this than Colts or Springfields. Me thinks its the spring rate!??
I am a pretty well trained shooter. I fully admit I do not know jack about 1911s. But I have been shooting Beretta M9s (military) and Glocks consistently for the past 20 years. I also take regular professional shooting courses. I can spot limp wristing in others pretty easily. And limp wristing causes havok on Glocks as much or more than most semi-autos. So it seems rather unlikely it is happening to me now all of a sudden, and not before. I am not saying it is impossible. Just that given my experience level I am inclined to look elswhere first.
Since the extractor test did indicate that it was just a tad too loose, I tightened it up. Hopefully this solves the problem. If not, I will give your suggestion another look.
Here is a picture so you can see what gun I own.
Comment
-
See? 1911's aren't so bad to work with right?
WTS all BNIB: Colt S70 Repro, HK45c, Gen4 G19Comment
-
Three things could be wrong.
1) extractor tension. I think this is what your problem is from the photo shown. The video posted is great.
2) ammo. If you are using reloads sometimes they are "well used" and over stretch in the champer due to being reloaded too many times. I have seen this with a lot of reloaded ammo from ranges.
3) worst case scenario is your chamber is too tight. I think this is highly unlikely though as Kimber is pretty good about opening them up just enough.
Pm me if interested and I can scan the pages out of one of my smithing books on the 1911. Or just follow this link from Bill Wilson on extractors: http://www.m1911.org/technic2.htmLast edited by intl1911; 05-28-2011, 12:48 AM.Comment
-
Only person confused was you. Spelled out pretty clearly why.Originally posted by jessegpresleyWhy did you post a picture of a gun that isn't yours doing something that yours isn't doing? Seems to confuse things.
A lot of people sell used guns because they don't run right and it's easier to sell them than try to get them fixed. If you bought yours used at a shop this might be the case.
People were confusing what was happening with what they thought was happening in a previous post. So on this one I said...NO THIS RIGHT HERE THAT YOU ARE DESCRIBING IS NOT WHAT IS HAPPENENING IT IS SOMETHING ENTIRELY DIFFERENT.
And no, that is not a junk gun that was sold off because it was not running right.Last edited by tacticalcity; 05-28-2011, 1:17 AM.Comment
-
1. Well as stated the image shown is NOT what is happeneing to mine. It is there to get people who half read my previous post for help to stop rushing to conclusions about what my issue was. I wasn't explaining it well and they assumed what was happening to me was something they had seen a thousand time. But what was going on with mine was slightly different and I wanted to spell that out. But I think you are right that it was the extractor tension in which case it should be fixed.Three things could be wrong.
1) extractor tension. I think this is what your problem is from the photo shown. The video posted is great.
2) ammo. If you are using reloads sometimes they are "well used" and over stretch in the champer due to being reloaded too many times. I have seen this with a lot of reloaded ammo from ranges.
3) worst case scenario is your chamber is too tight. I think this is highly unlikely though as Kimber is pretty good about opening them up just enough.
Pm me if interested and I can scan the pages out of one of my smithing books on the 1911. Or just follow this link from Bill Wilson on extractors: http://www.m1911.org/technic2.htm
2. As stated ammo is factory new.
3. We'll see if there is still an issue. I don't want to even think about that one.
Honetly guys, we are good for now. I am not going to mess with it until after I test out the fix already applied. If I do anything else then I won't know what fixed it...or worse I could cause more problems. I will of course report back after my next range trip.Last edited by tacticalcity; 05-28-2011, 1:26 AM.Comment
Calguns.net Statistics
Collapse
Topics: 1,870,990
Posts: 25,178,271
Members: 358,862
Active Members: 5,382
Welcome to our newest member, 1776 Arms.
What's Going On
Collapse
There are currently 31367 users online. 115 members and 31252 guests.
Most users ever online was 239,041 at 11:39 PM on 02-14-2026.

Comment