Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

training scenario

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Warhawk014
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2008
    • 1498

    training scenario

    ok ladies and gents, heres a scenario for everyone to discuss. serious comments only please, do not pollute this thread with smart *** comments. i want to know what you would do in this situation. the situation is exactly as i discribe it. no other unknown variables exists. ok...

    you live by yourself in a 1 story house outside city limits, the closest neighbors are approximately 200 yards away. while sleeping in your room with your corgi at the foot of your bed, you awaken to a loud thunderous crash coming from the living room. your dog begins to bark at the bedroom door leading into the hallway. you quickly retrieve your 1911 45 acp from the nightstand. you load it with a single 8 round mag and head into the hallway to investigate the noise. as you turn into the living room you are confronted by a burglar wielding a 32 inch machete. you immediately take aim at the suspect and order him to drop the weapon on the ground and put his hands in the air. the suspect does not comply with your order and begins to charge at you from a distance of 15 yards away. you fire 4 shots center mass all with positive impacts but the burglar only flinches, stops for a split second and continues his charge towards you. he is now only 10 yards away from you and you fire 2 more shots aiming for his head. because he is moving you miss both shots, you know you only have 2 rounds left in the gun. it is now apparent that the suspect is wearing some sort of body armor and cannot be taken down with COM shots and head shots are very difficult because he is a moving target. you have only seconds to decide your next course of action, if you fail to act and the suspect closes the remaining distance HE WILL KILL YOU. you must somehow SLOW him down long enough to retreat to your bedroom so that you can reload.

    what do you do...... lets discuss this in a serious manner. please explain your reason for taking a certain course of action. i know what i would do, what would you do.
    http://www.shop42a.com/
  • #2
    InGrAM
    Veteran Member
    • Dec 2010
    • 3699

    lol I like that you added in a cute little corgi. To bad hes not going to be much after getting hit with a machete :/.

    Comment

    • #3
      jermzzzzzzz
      Senior Member
      • Jan 2008
      • 817

      Corgi's rock! I'd still go for the headshot. And I'd carry something that can carry more than 8 rounds.
      sigpic United States Air Force Security Forces

      Comment

      • #4
        UserM4
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2010
        • 1687

        The head is the most stable part of a human body that is running. I wouldn't miss with the last two rounds since the target is even larger as it approaches.

        But lucky for me, I have 18+1 rounds of 9mm in my HD handgun, 8 rounds of slugs in my HD shotgun, and 30+1 rounds in my HD rifle, which would also punch holes through soft body armor as if it wasn't there.
        While we're here arguing about the latest high tech running shoes, there's some Kenyan out there running barefoot. Guess who's gonna win the marathon?

        Comment

        • #5
          Warhawk014
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2008
          • 1498

          Originally posted by UserM4
          The head is the most stable part of a human body that is running. I wouldn't miss with the last two rounds since the target is even larger as it approaches.

          But lucky for me, I have 18+1 rounds of 9mm in my HD handgun, 8 rounds of slugs in my HD shotgun, and 30+1 rounds in my HD rifle, which would also punch holes through soft body armor as if it wasn't there.
          so you would risk it with the last 2 shots and not try to retreat.
          http://www.shop42a.com/

          Comment

          • #6
            UserM4
            Senior Member
            • Apr 2010
            • 1687

            Honestly, I wouldn't have had time to think about it. Just shoot.
            While we're here arguing about the latest high tech running shoes, there's some Kenyan out there running barefoot. Guess who's gonna win the marathon?

            Comment

            • #7
              zfields
              CGN Contributor
              • Aug 2010
              • 13658

              Sure am glad I have 10 rounds of .45 acp in my XD, or 19 rounds of 9mm in my CZ : )

              Either way, Id either go for the head, or the knees while i retreated to my bigger guns.
              Sandstorm Custom Rifle Slings : Custom Paracord slings

              10% off slings for calguns members. PM for details. Like us on facebook!

              Comment

              • #8
                UserM4
                Senior Member
                • Apr 2010
                • 1687

                Just another reason I don't consider 1911's seriously for HD usage. My USP45 holds 12+1 and even that isn't remarkable. But I'd rather have 19rds of 9mm than 13rds of 45ACP any day let alone a 1911 with 8rds.
                While we're here arguing about the latest high tech running shoes, there's some Kenyan out there running barefoot. Guess who's gonna win the marathon?

                Comment

                • #9
                  DannyZRC
                  Member
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 465

                  Doctrinal failures...
                  • You didn't call the police when awoken by a loud crash
                  • You are ALONE, but decided to grab a handgun and poke around
                  • You didn't provide yourself with a lightsource (big one)


                  Things that break my suspension of disbelief...
                  • you live alone but in a fairly big house (15 yds across your living room)
                  • it's dark but you can see that your shots are good and then assume it's a vest that is causing them to not stop instead of just emptying the magazine into them?
                  • An intruder has a vest... but no firearm?


                  To play along:
                  If we first acknowledge that you started things off wrong, and then we accept for the purposes of argument that a vested intruder has broken into your house wielding a machete, and we further accept that you stopped firing into the threat before it was neutralized, well...

                  you could attempt to knock the attacker off their feet, you could go for a contact headshot, you could turn and run for your bedroom improvising obstacles along the way (closet doors and the like).

                  None of these are good options, you made mistakes early in the scenario that are hard to overcome now at the end.
                  The Range is a place where you carry a gun around and spend most of your time shooting it.
                  The Real World is a place where you carry a gun around and spend most of your time not shooting it.
                  Plan Accordingly.

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    Laser Sailor
                    Senior Member
                    • Aug 2010
                    • 614

                    As described, I probably take my last two shots, miss with both and get chopped up by the machete wielding burgler... Just being honest...

                    The smart answer is to retreat to your bedroom and access more firepower. Even smarter is to retreat the moment you see the threat, lock your bedroom and call 911.

                    Now in badass mallninja mode I'd rush him to close distance try to block his first blow with my offhand arm and put the gun into contact with his head before pulling the trigger on the last two.
                    Common sense is so rare these days that it really ought to be classified as a superpower.
                    ATTN FEDERAL AGENTS: I DON'T ACTUALLY OWN ANY GUNS, I'M JUST HERE FOR THE EGO BOOST.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      j1133s
                      Senior Member
                      • Jul 2007
                      • 1343

                      Originally posted by Warhawk014
                      ... your dog begins to bark at the bedroom door leading into the hallway. you quickly retrieve your 1911 45 acp from the nightstand. you load it with a single 8 round mag and head into the hallway to investigate the noise. as you turn into the living room you are confronted by a burglar wielding a 32 inch machete. you immediately take aim at the suspect and order him to drop the weapon on the ground and put his hands in the air. ...
                      1. If I keep a pistol for HD, it'll already be loaded and ready to go.
                      2. I don't issue orders, I will just shoot.
                      3. I will not investigate w/ pistol, calling 911 seems easier if I feel the need for a pistol and investigaet

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Warhawk014
                        Senior Member
                        • Apr 2008
                        • 1498

                        Originally posted by DannyZRC
                        Doctrinal failures...
                        • You didn't call the police when awoken by a loud crash
                        • You are ALONE, but decided to grab a handgun and poke around
                        • You didn't provide yourself with a lightsource (big one)


                        Things that break my suspension of disbelief...
                        • you live alone but in a fairly big house (15 yds across your living room)
                        • it's dark but you can see that your shots are good and then assume it's a vest that is causing them to not stop instead of just emptying the magazine into them?
                        • An intruder has a vest... but no firearm?


                        To play along:
                        If we first acknowledge that you started things off wrong, and then we accept for the purposes of argument that a vested intruder has broken into your house wielding a machete, and we further accept that you stopped firing into the threat before it was neutralized, well...

                        you could attempt to knock the attacker off their feet, you could go for a contact headshot, you could turn and run for your bedroom improvising obstacles along the way (closet doors and the like).

                        None of these are good options, you made mistakes early in the scenario that are hard to overcome now at the end.
                        thus the purpose of this discussion, so that we can learn to think critically and not make mistakes. i like the improvising obstacles.
                        http://www.shop42a.com/

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          JTROKS
                          I need a LIFE!!
                          • Nov 2007
                          • 13093

                          I know it's a handgun thread, but if you had a 12 gauge instead of a 1911 then all is solved.
                          The wise man said just find your place
                          In the eye of the storm
                          Seek the roses along the way
                          Just beware of the thorns...
                          K. Meine

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            Voo
                            Senior Member
                            • Feb 2008
                            • 1702

                            I'd run back to my room and close the door. Then i'd wait.. Not so close that if it crashes open it hits me, but put myself in a position so that it's literally contact distance when he enters. If they enter slow.. take the shot.. If they crash in, you should have a small amount of time before he realizes "where" you are.. Take that time to take two well aimed shots.. even if it's something like his pelvis to slow him down just enough to take one well aimed shot at his head..

                            Beyond that I can't see myself doing much else.. it's either stand your ground and shoot.. retreat and wait for a better shot... Or try to retreat completely..
                            Aloha snackbar!

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              jshoebot
                              Senior Member
                              • Feb 2010
                              • 1857

                              Go for the pelvis shot. It's a good sized target (almost as large as a torso), and it usually stays in a stable position while someone is charging in a straight line towards you. If you hit the pelvis, it will break, and he'll be immobile. Then call 911 and get the police on the way.

                              Would have handled it differently from the get-go, personally.
                              Any opinions expressed in my posts are not necessarily the opinions of any organizations in which I am a member.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1