Unconfigured Ad Widget

Collapse

Magpul SpeedPlate (for Glock) failure

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • scootle
    CGN/CGSSA Contributor
    CGN Contributor
    • Oct 2010
    • 2702

    Magpul SpeedPlate (for Glock) failure

    My intention is not to knock Magpul products, since they typically seem pretty good bang-for-the-buck... but this is a bit disappointing... I got a 3-pack of the Glock SpeedPlates to test out the other day, and one of them has already completely failed:





    It literally peeled right apart at the glue-bond interface. I have to wonder why these weren't cast as a one-piece assembly to avoid this sort of failure mode. Maybe it's just a one-off QA failure, but I'll touch base with Magpul CS to see what they can do about it.

    This was just while at home testing out how the (Glock 19) magazines handle with the SpeedPlates installed... not in the field, no harsh conditions or crazy scenarios. I'd hate to wonder what would happen if this were to happen to a professional in the field choosing to use these devices (assuming any of them do). I have a set of the similar RangerPlates installed on my "shortie" 10-round PMAGs since it helps a lot with handling the short magazines in the AR, so I figured I'd give the Glock version a try too.

    Just thought people might want a heads up to check that their SpeedPlates carefully before fielding them. Again, this was a brand new unit. The other two in the pack seem to be holding up for the time being.
    SCC CCW *326 Days, $1051.29*
    Application: 2/27/2023 ($72.33)
    Original Interview: 12/21@1030|Actual: 4/13@0900
    'Informal" email Background complete: 9/19
    Email to schedule Psych: 10/27@1539 ($150)
    Psych Test: 11/3@0800|Psych Interview: 11/9@0900 (Dr.McKenzie)
    LiveScan: 11/9 (UPS Store $93+$25)|Livescan cleared: CA/FBI 11/9, Firearms 11/20
    LiveScan Email: 11/17@0842
    Training Email: 11/29@1007|Instructor: 1/10/2024 SaberTactics ($399+40)|Docs: 1/12
    Approval: 1/17@1346 ($264+$7.96)|Pickup: 1/19@1030
  • #2
    scootle
    CGN/CGSSA Contributor
    CGN Contributor
    • Oct 2010
    • 2702

    Just a quick update... Magpul CS made good on this by sending me 3 replacement speedplates free of charge (didn't even have to send in the broken one... just sent them pictures). If anything Magpul does stand by their stuff it seems!
    SCC CCW *326 Days, $1051.29*
    Application: 2/27/2023 ($72.33)
    Original Interview: 12/21@1030|Actual: 4/13@0900
    'Informal" email Background complete: 9/19
    Email to schedule Psych: 10/27@1539 ($150)
    Psych Test: 11/3@0800|Psych Interview: 11/9@0900 (Dr.McKenzie)
    LiveScan: 11/9 (UPS Store $93+$25)|Livescan cleared: CA/FBI 11/9, Firearms 11/20
    LiveScan Email: 11/17@0842
    Training Email: 11/29@1007|Instructor: 1/10/2024 SaberTactics ($399+40)|Docs: 1/12
    Approval: 1/17@1346 ($264+$7.96)|Pickup: 1/19@1030

    Comment

    • #3
      Sam
      Calguns Addict
      CGN Contributor
      • Jul 2008
      • 5205

      Sending you more of a product with a design defect?

      Comment

      • #4
        scootle
        CGN/CGSSA Contributor
        CGN Contributor
        • Oct 2010
        • 2702

        Originally posted by Sam
        Sending you more of a product with a design defect?
        Yeah, we'll see won't we? I only installed 2 of the plates (out of a total of 8 magazines) for the time being to test out in some classes and whatnot.

        As an aside, getting the stupid floorplate off the Glock 19 magazines was a lot harder than I expected. Tore up my knuckle in the process, no less!
        SCC CCW *326 Days, $1051.29*
        Application: 2/27/2023 ($72.33)
        Original Interview: 12/21@1030|Actual: 4/13@0900
        'Informal" email Background complete: 9/19
        Email to schedule Psych: 10/27@1539 ($150)
        Psych Test: 11/3@0800|Psych Interview: 11/9@0900 (Dr.McKenzie)
        LiveScan: 11/9 (UPS Store $93+$25)|Livescan cleared: CA/FBI 11/9, Firearms 11/20
        LiveScan Email: 11/17@0842
        Training Email: 11/29@1007|Instructor: 1/10/2024 SaberTactics ($399+40)|Docs: 1/12
        Approval: 1/17@1346 ($264+$7.96)|Pickup: 1/19@1030

        Comment

        • #5
          locosway
          I need a LIFE!!
          • Jun 2009
          • 11346

          Originally posted by Sam
          Sending you more of a product with a design defect?
          More like a manufacturing defect.
          OCSD Approved CCW Instructor
          NRA Certified Instructor
          CA DOJ Certified Instructor
          Glock Certified Armorer

          Comment

          • #6
            luckystrike
            Veteran Member
            • Feb 2009
            • 4176

            another reason that I dont drink their koolaid

            Comment

            • #7
              locosway
              I need a LIFE!!
              • Jun 2009
              • 11346

              Originally posted by luckystrike
              another reason that I dont drink their koolaid
              They have some great products, and their prices are very good too. I'm not sure about the Glock speedplates because I've never owned one, and I probably won't because I just don't see the need.
              OCSD Approved CCW Instructor
              NRA Certified Instructor
              CA DOJ Certified Instructor
              Glock Certified Armorer

              Comment

              • #8
                luckystrike
                Veteran Member
                • Feb 2009
                • 4176

                Originally posted by locosway
                They have some great products, and their prices are very good too. I'm not sure about the Glock speedplates because I've never owned one, and I probably won't because I just don't see the need.
                I like their AR mags, wish they would make AK mags.... in what time the glock stuff has been out I guess its like the +2s some people have, -%20 reliability.

                Comment

                • #9
                  locosway
                  I need a LIFE!!
                  • Jun 2009
                  • 11346

                  Originally posted by luckystrike
                  I like their AR mags, wish they would make AK mags.... in what time the glock stuff has been out I guess its like the +2s some people have, -%20 reliability.
                  Yeah, their AR mags are arguably the best on the market. I also like their fore grip over the stock AR style grip.
                  OCSD Approved CCW Instructor
                  NRA Certified Instructor
                  CA DOJ Certified Instructor
                  Glock Certified Armorer

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    VirT
                    Junior Member
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 44

                    I've had my speed plate fall apart in exactly the same manner under the same conditions a while back.. I guess I should have contacted MP directly.. just figured it was my bad luck :\

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      luckystrike
                      Veteran Member
                      • Feb 2009
                      • 4176

                      Originally posted by locosway
                      Yeah, their AR mags are arguably the best on the market. I also like their fore grip over the stock AR style grip.
                      I liked the foregrip to untill I fired with one, the top of the foregrip got so hot so quick I couldnt touch it, never had that problem with anything else. did you notice that or is it just me?

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        Falconis
                        Senior Member
                        • Feb 2008
                        • 1688

                        Just make sure you inspect your AR mags every now and then. Friends had some of theirs split near the top after some usage and abusage. I think they may have rectified that problem by now, not too sure. I still buy their mags though.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          scootle
                          CGN/CGSSA Contributor
                          CGN Contributor
                          • Oct 2010
                          • 2702

                          speedplates + MagLULA = not so good?

                          Originally posted by luckystrike
                          I liked the foregrip to untill I fired with one, the top of the foregrip got so hot so quick I couldnt touch it, never had that problem with anything else. did you notice that or is it just me?
                          foregrip or AFG? i doubt it's the fore grip's fault that your handguard heated up significantly though. is your AR a free-float setup?

                          or are you talking about the polymer MOE handguard? i guess if you are talking about it getting hot, you mean the MOE handguard?

                          back to the speedplate discussion... i'm going to see if i can induce another failure by loading my mags with a MagLULA exclusively. i noticed tonight that when loading at the range, pushing down on the speedplate (to use the LULA) really started to squish/flex the bottom of the speedplate (rubber-like plastic). this is compounded by the fact that getting the 10th round into Glock19 mags really does require a bit of pressure to get that last round in.

                          i will report back after i torture test it a bunch more. i'm not convinced these speedplate things are built to the same standards as the ranger plates on the AR magazines.
                          SCC CCW *326 Days, $1051.29*
                          Application: 2/27/2023 ($72.33)
                          Original Interview: 12/21@1030|Actual: 4/13@0900
                          'Informal" email Background complete: 9/19
                          Email to schedule Psych: 10/27@1539 ($150)
                          Psych Test: 11/3@0800|Psych Interview: 11/9@0900 (Dr.McKenzie)
                          LiveScan: 11/9 (UPS Store $93+$25)|Livescan cleared: CA/FBI 11/9, Firearms 11/20
                          LiveScan Email: 11/17@0842
                          Training Email: 11/29@1007|Instructor: 1/10/2024 SaberTactics ($399+40)|Docs: 1/12
                          Approval: 1/17@1346 ($264+$7.96)|Pickup: 1/19@1030

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            luckystrike
                            Veteran Member
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 4176

                            Originally posted by scootle
                            foregrip or AFG? i doubt it's the fore grip's fault that your handguard heated up significantly though. is your AR a free-float setup?

                            or are you talking about the polymer MOE handguard? i guess if you are talking about it getting hot, you mean the MOE handguard?

                            back to the speedplate discussion... i'm going to see if i can induce another failure by loading my mags with a MagLULA exclusively. i noticed tonight that when loading at the range, pushing down on the speedplate (to use the LULA) really started to squish/flex the bottom of the speedplate (rubber-like plastic). this is compounded by the fact that getting the 10th round into Glock19 mags really does require a bit of pressure to get that last round in.

                            i will report back after i torture test it a bunch more. i'm not convinced these speedplate things are built to the same standards as the ranger plates on the AR magazines.
                            yes the MOE

                            do that, if any fail again ditch em

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              Oceanbob
                              I need a LIFE!!
                              • Jun 2010
                              • 12720

                              My speedplates worked fine

                              And all of them are tight and fit perfectly.

                              I have them on my GLOCK 35

                              For 5 bucks each they are worth it.



                              May the Bridges I burn light the way.

                              Life Is Not About Waiting For The Storm To Pass - Its About Learning To Dance In The Rain.

                              Fewer people are killed with all rifles each year (323 in 2011) than with shotguns (356), hammers and clubs (496), and hands and feet (728).

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              UA-8071174-1