Good quality revolver..

[Centurion_D]

I'm shopping around for a revolver for home defense. I was looking at S&W or Ruger. Any other brand names out there people can recommend? I would love to get a Colt but a they seem rare this days and if you find a python in excellent condition expect to pay a premium price. Any recommendations or should I go for my first choice..S&W.

[Brass Balls]

S&W makes a quality revolver. What caliber are you thinking about?

[Centurion_D]

S&W makes a quality revolver. What caliber are you thinking about?

38/357...

[SnWnMe]

Hi. Stick to S&W and Ruger there is almost no chance that you can go wrong.

[ask80]

642 5 shot .38? i think it's like $350

[Thunderhawk]

If your budget is tight go for a Ruger GP100, if not then go for a S&W. You can't go wrong either way.

[taloft]

The 4" barrel would be my choice.

[461]

Ruger or Smith, nothing else worth looking at if your life is going to depend on it unless you find a money tree for a Colt.

[1911whore]

s&w 4in 686. end of story

[saki302]

Shoot both then decide. For the money, IMO, S&W all the way.

Colts are nice, but S&Ws are more durable and I prefer a non stacking DA trigger pull. I do own a python to stare at, but the M625 and M686+ go with me to the range much more often.

-Dave

[Brass Balls]

For HD size and weight are your friend. A full lugged barrel, like the S&W 686 and 586, adds weight and tames recoil and muzzle rise. A 4" barrel would be better if you're going to pack it, but for the home I'd go with a 6". It will really allow your loads to get up to speed, especially if you're shooting .38s.

Another plus with this model is the new versions are being made with a 7-shot cylinder.

[Mr. Beretta]

Older K-frame Smith or Ruger (Security / Speed Six, GP-100, etc.) in either 4" or 2". Can't go wrong. Will work everytime. Good Luck.

[glockman19]

s&w 4in 686. end of story

+1 I agree the S&W 686 4" is a great HD weapon. I prefer the trigger on the S&W over the Ruger.

[tmuller]

Another +1 on the 686...great revolver!!

[MudCamper]

This is basically a Ford vs. Chevy thing. You will find people vehemently loyal to one or the other. My choice is Ruger. Their revolvers are built like tanks. Rock solid durability and reliability.