XD Vs. M&P for first handgun

[Newshooter]

Another Newbie here looking for some input. I am looking to purchase my first semi-automatic pistol and have narrowed it down to the XD or the M&P. The gun will be a 9mm and will be full size. I was hoping to get any pros and/or cons for both models from the experienced users of this forum. Thanks for any and all input!!

[CarlozRossi]

Imma noob too, and in the same position your in. I absolutely fell in love with both of these and in IMHO you can't go wrong with either. I've found that the XD has a bit more aftermarket accessories available though. Both have excellent ergonomics and both are really reliable.

I'm saving up for both. The Subcompact XD in 40. and a M&P9c. You'll find that the XD Service Model is about $100 less than the M&P. The M&P does have a lower bore axis than the XD but IMO you cant really tell a significant difference when firing both.

[sholling]

Both are good reliable pistols. The M&P is made in the USA and the XD in Croatia. Both have lifetime warranties from companies renowned for their superb customer service. Personally I prefer the M&P for the lower barrel axis and the interchangeable backstrap allowing you to fit it to your hand or add a Crimson Trace grip laser. And I like the the looks of the M&P better. But both are excellent handguns. Both have lots of holster and accessory choices.

Edit: In the compact versions I prefer the 1/2" longer barrel of the M&P. The 3.5" M&P is every bit as concealable and the extra 1/2" of barrel improves the ballistics of round.

[Legasat]

Both made my top 3 list when I was looking. I chose M&P because it was more comfortable in my hand, and therefore I shot it better (more accurately).

The only intelligent way for you to choose is to go rent both, and shoot them side by side (like I did). See which shoots better, which is more comfortable, etc.

Both are fine handguns, and you won't lose which ever one you choose.

[OneSevenDeuce]

Honestly? They are both great guns. Go out and rent each one from a range and shoot them a bunch. You'll know which one is best for you after a couple boxes of ammo.

[kozumasbullitt]

Both are great as well as the glock 17, you should hold all 3 to see what feels best.

[Fate]

Agree with what the above respondents said. M&P was my choice. I now own two of them with an eye on a compact

[Nor-Cal]

My first semi auto handgun was a SA XD, really liked how I shot with it and very comfterble, now I have 3 xds, but like others say go to a range and try all your choices before choosing which to purchase

[CSACANNONEER]

It should come down to which one fits you the best. But, I'd suggest buying a .22lr pistol first! It'll save you a lot of money in the long run.

[Dismal_Scientist]

Honestly? They are both great guns. Go out and rent each one from a range and shoot them a bunch. You'll know which one is best for you after a couple boxes of ammo.

This

[KillZone45]

Some good answers, I like how this thread has stayed on track. I have the XD and would love to own an M&P, I tried to get a used one but I am getting an H&K instead. You will be happy with any gun you get really.

[Acorn556]

I have the M&P in a 40 and I was set on the XD. Picked up the S&W M&P and it fit so much better in my hand.

Had a buddy shopping recently and told him the same advice. Shoot it, hold it, read reviews online, hold it again, shoot it some more, then buy one.

[evidens83]

M&P9 all the way no contest.

[OneSevenDeuce]

As you can see, everyone has their pet favorite.

[Noah3683]

If this is going to be your only pistol for the time being and you are dead set on a compact model............ Go with the m&p. At least you get an extra 1/2" of barrel and it also conceals better than the xd. That being said I love my xd9 and I am now starting to love my glock 23 (with 9mm barrel for the range) You should really consider looking into a full frame for your first though. At the least consider something in the size range of a Glock 19/23